Julie was a sweet girl. She just had gotten wrapped up in something. In her senior year of high school, Julie's friends had concocted a plot to celebrate the end of the year. The prank ended with the principal and a few students slipping on a bag of marbles they released into the hallways. It was never meant to be anything serious, but a few students were minorly injured. As was the principal's pride, Julie surmised. And this, she thought, was more to the point.
In something of an overreaction, the principal had expelled all four students involved. Julie was perhaps the least involved of the four, but nevertheless suffered the same fate. Julie's parents were in quite an upset over the incident. She hadn't had behavioral problems before, not like this anyway. And though her parents were usually not overly strict, they had a solemn, anxious attitude that was sent into overdrive at the thought that their darling girl was headed down a dangerous (perhaps criminal!) path.
Their decision to send Julie away was impulsive and fear-driven. But she had no say in the matter, and in what seemed like no time at all, Julie found herself on a train to Saint Irene's Institution of Post-Secondary Education. The school specialized in offering a corrective path forward for troubled 18-20 year old students who failed to graduate from high school. Saint Irene's had a ghastly reputation for intense discipline and high expectations. It felt like being sent to jail. There were no phones at Saint Irene's, except for the ones at the front office. In fact, students were barely allowed any contact with the outside world at all. Worst of all, Julie heard that corporal punishment was used liberally and frequently. She wasn't sure of the details but just the thought of it was so infuriating, humiliating.
Julie felt small and scared on her journey to the Saint Irene's. When she arrived, she saw that the school looked like it sounded. Austere, grand stone stared into her, pronouncing its formality, its accolades and standards. It looked like a church she thought.
Her check-in process was not so bad. The staff was friendly. They did remind her that this was a very strict school, and there would be no funny business. This was a time to study and get back on track. Julie was given a thick student handbook and advised to read it carefully.
Before long she soon found herself settled in and feeling a bit more relaxed. She even made a friend in trigonometry, Tina. One fateful day, Tina said something that would mark the beginning of Julie's descent into hell. It was study hall, and Tina and Julie were both struggling to understand inverse trigonometric functions.
"We don't have time for this," Tina lamented. "Look, Gregory isn't by his desk. He's at the top of the class. Walk past and tell me what he's got for number 14."
Julie hesitated. She truly wasn't a rule breaker, but she did need a friend in a place like this. Maybe this was an opportunity to earn Tina's trust. One glance couldn't hurt she thought.
Tina egged her on.
"Come on. Just pretend you are going to the bathroom."
Julie nodded and walked past Gregory's desk glancing at number 14. She paused as long as she could without seeming suspicious, trying to memorize what he'd written down. Then, she went to the bathroom. When she returned, Tina was gone. She hoped Tina would return soon, because there was only a few minutes left before the period ended, and the assignment was due immediately afterward.
Julie wrote down what she remembered from Gregory's paper. By the time she finished, the bell rang, and she went to class, still wondering what happened to Tina.
Finally, Tina arrived at Trigonometry with 30 seconds before the start of the period. Tina motioned for Julie to come over, but Julie shook head communicating that it was too late to share the answer discretely.
Julie turned in her assignment, and things went on as normal for a while. Apparently, Tina had left to discuss Rachel's new crush or something.
The next day in homeroom, Ms. Chitiwic stopped Julie at the door, and handed her a small orange piece of paper.
"Principal Stone would like to see you." Principal Stone was actually one of the Vice Principals, but apparently they were all called Principal so-and-so. Julie immediately felt a flutter of fear at being called away. Could this somehow be about the trigonometry assignment? Ms. Chitiwic sounded a bit grim, but there was no way of knowing.
"Straight away." Ms. Chitiwic said with a bit more force, gesturing for Julie to leave.
As she walked down the halls, butterflies in her stomach, she finally thought to look at the orange slip she was holding. It read:
PUNISHMENT REQUESTED
Tuesday, the 2nd of September
Julie Stappording
To be handled by: Principal Stone
Her heart sank. Punishment? For what?
After what seemed like an age, Julie arrived at the front office. She walked in and looked around. She found a secretary at the front desk, and said "I was told Principle Stone wants to see me."
The secretary looked at her with a cold, blank expression and gestured for the orange slip. Julie handed it over with mild reluctance.
"Wait over there. I'll let you know when he is ready for you." The secretary motioned to a line of chairs up against a wall.
Julie sat and waited, wondering what would happen next.
After another long passage of time, the Secretary called "Julie?" as if having forgotten her face already.
Julie stood up.
"Okay sweetie," the secretary said with a bit more warmth in her voice. "Go down this hall and knock on the third door to your left." Somehow the secretary's encouraging tone was not comforting. Instead, it gave Julie the impression that the secretary pitied her situation and was sorry for what was coming.
Julie found the door and knocked.
"Come in." Said a low, muffled voice.
"Ah Julie. Come sit." Principal Stone seemed much more inviting than the secretary, and Julie relaxed ever so slightly.
"How are you enjoying Saint Irene?"
"I'm getting along very well, sir."
"Good, good. Making friends?"
Julie paused to look up at the man. He was a large man, tall with broad shoulders. He was standing behind an equally large oak desk. The office was warm, a bit like a library.
"A few." She managed to reply.
"Well, Julie. I don't like to begin a new relationship with a student this way, but it seems I've received a troubling report about your trigonometry assignment yesterday."
Julie heart sank a second time. How did he know? How could he know anything about that? She looked up at Principal Stone with anxiety.
"Do you know what I'm talking about Julie?"
"No, sir." She said quietly.
"I see." He paused and looked at Julie sternly.
"Well, I guess I'll have to lay it out for you then," he said sounding disappointed.
"Your trigonometry paper was frankly atrocious. The only problem you managed successfully was the last one, number 14. We need to see better work from you in the future."
Julie felt a sigh of relief internally, though tried not to show it. Maybe, this was just because her paper was bad, not because she had copied from Gregory.
"Now, a minor punishment would be in order for such careless work, Julie. But there is another matter."
Julie's anxiety began to rise again.
The principal opened a drawer and produced Julie's assignment. He handed Julie the paper, which was full of corrections in red ink.
"Problem 14. Your success story. You've written 4, here and here," he pointed.
"Now that term should be the variable 'q', wouldn't you agree?"
"Y-yes, sir." Julie said without thinking.
"Why would you have written that Julie?"
"I don't know, sir. I must have just made a mistake."
"You meant to write 'q', but you wrote 4 instead?"
"Yes, sir."
"I have to say, it's a bit of a strange mistake. Especially, considering that you arrive at the correct answer, which would be impossible laying out the equation as you did."
Julie was quiet, staring at the floor.
"Well, I wouldn't do anything drastic on a hunch, but then there's this." Principle stone pushed a button on a remote, and, to Julie's horror, a video of Julie's study hall appear on a TV behind the principal's desk. It showed Julie walking over to Gregory's desk and peering at it more obviously than she imagined.
"I took the liberty of glancing at Gregory's paper. Not only did Gregory solve number 14 correctly, which is unsurprising, after all he is at the top of his class, but he also did something most of the other students did not. He chose to write his variable with a lower case "q," which could look a bit like a 4, to rushed, unwelcome eyes."
Principal Stone stared piercingly.
"It will be better for you if you admit it now. Did you cheat on your assignment Julie?"
Julie froze in an extended and explosively still panic.
"Y-y-yes, s-sir." She almost sobbed.
"I'm glad you told me at this point, but unfortunately this does require a serious intervention. Cheating is no light matter at Saint Irene."
Julie nodded.
"You'll have to be punished, of course."