"Guys, I need to tell you something," Mandy announced one afternoon in March. "I'm pregnant!"
Stunned silence. "Oh, lord, you can't be." "How did that happen?" "Are you sure?"
"Well, I suppose it happened because someone fucked me. And yes, I just came from the doctor."
More stunned silence.
"What are you going to do? Are you going to keep it?" Cathy asked.
"You mean, abortion? I couldn't do that. I'm due September 25
th,
, will finish out this semester and then go home and have the baby. After that I just don't know, maybe give it up for adoption. Right now I can't think straight."
This was certainly an unplanned and exceedingly disruptive development.
"I don't suppose there's any way to know whether the baby is mine or Jim's?"
"DNA. And maybe after it's born since you have blond hair and Jim's is dark. But does it really matter?"
"If it's mine, I would be responsible," I rushed to reassure her. "We could get married."
"Thank you for that but we're too young to get married. And I really don't want to know. I love you both."
Everything was in turmoil for days.
"I'm really horny and want to fuck. Both of you," she declared one night. "You too, Cathy. Come eat my pussy and then I need two cocks. Badly."
For the remaining two months of school we pretended that everything was normal. In May Mandy was showing and we were afraid to hurt her with our cocks. She checked with her doctor who said no problem for another two months. Perhaps it was the hormones but she was horny all the time.
School ended and I returned home. Mandy went to her aunt's in Connecticut for her last months and to have the baby. We stayed in touch via Facebook. She met with counselors and decided she was too young to properly bring up the baby and put it up for adoption. Cathy and I lived only a three-hour drive apart so we got together frequently during the summer.
"Who did it look like, Mandy?" I was dying to know. "Jim or me?"
"Hard to tell, Bobby, it could have been either of you. But it's not."
"What?"
"Everyone wondered how I could get pregnant, being on the pill. Of course it's not quite 100%, but there's more to the story. A three weeks before Christmas break my prescription ran out. My doctor wanted to see me before renewing it. Well, you know me, always busy. I knew you were going to visit your relatives in California so I could safely skip the pills for a little while.
"Bad decision as it turned out. Really bad. You were gone and I got horny. And then I bumped into Eric, that older guy that I first fucked. We hooked up several times. I'm sure he's the father, the timing's right. Anyway it doesn't matter now since I gave the baby up."
"I cheated on you and I'm sorry. I've decided to wait out a year before going back to school. My uncle has a business here and offered me a job. We can stay in touch, Bobby." This was a goodbye.
I contacted Jim to verify he was coming back in the fall. With one less person to share the apartment cost we needed to downsize. I did some looking and found one that had a convertible sofa plus one bedroom with a queen bed. That would have to do.
So now we were three. I really missed Mandy. Aside from the long relationship I enjoyed the two pussy arrangement. Cathy giggled and said she was now going to be one well-fuck girl. The sex was good and both of us ate creampie without regard to the source. We also dp'd her, Jim in her ass, me in her pussy.
A few weeks later, "Bobby, I think you and Jim are both so great but things are different without Mandy. Our loving was softer and sensitive compared with the strong fucking you and Jim give me. Don't get me wrong, I love your cocks.
"But I'm really feeling uncertain about things. How do you really feel about me? I mean, you and Mandy were a couple and then I came along. I wasn't surprised that a horny teenager would welcome another pussy to your bed. The sex was super and I always felt you liked me as a person, I mean, besides my pussy. This summer was extra special, just you and me.
"I spend a lot of time thinking about us. I like the sex, two cocks for me. But I'm searching for something more, a deeper relationship. I guess what I'm trying say -- god, this is so hard."
She stopped to wipe her eyes. Uh, oh, this a 'dear john'? I am being dumped. Damn, damn.
"Bobby, I love you. I want to be your girl, just you."
She looked at me, tears running down her face.
"Cathy, you are beautiful, loving girl. I like being around you, you make me laugh, and we are very good in bed together. This past summer was also very special for me. I fell in love with you but didn't know how things would be when school started. There's no one I would rather be with. No one."
"Not even Mandy?"
"No, things are different now and I don't expect us to reconnect."
"You mean because of the baby? Don't be hard on her. That big cock of yours pumped lots of cum to her cervix. You might be the father."
"Mandy says no, it was someone else."
"Oh."
We told Jim when he returned. He accepted our decision and promised to find another place to live as soon as possible. It took the better part of a week before he moved out, which was a little awkward.
With only one pussy and one cock between us we spent less time in bed than before. But it was definitely quality time and gave us more time to be social with our friends. It was obvious that Cathy and I were now a couple. Those that knew us last year asked about Mandy and I just said she was taking a year off. One of the girls asked Cathy if Jim was now 'available'. Cathy said he's a really nice guy and very good in bed and go for it.
Now we were just another dating couple and lost our aura of sexual wildness. But back at our apartment she and I were as adventurous as ever. Cathy loved sucking my cock and eventually was able to take all of me. It was a struggle given my size. I perfected my pussy eating skills for both before and after sex.
We tried many positions but our favorite for energetic fucking was doggy. We had several variations, most commonly Cathy laid on the bed, me on top. Sometimes she was on the floor, butt up in the air. Sometimes I did her from the rear, bending over the sofa arm or kitchen table.
We both liked her on top so she could control the action. I preferred reverse cowgirl to watch my cock slide in and out of her tight pussy. Cathy liked cowgirl so she could kiss me as we fucked. If our day was really full we just snuggled in bed, spooning. Usually my cock got hard and she lifted a leg to give me access. Occasionally we fell asleep, my cock still inside until it fell out as I moved around. It was a most pleasant way to end a day.
The weeks flew by. Our studies were going well, both getting almost all A's. I had not met her parents nor had she met mine. We spent Thanksgiving with my folks. They knew that Mandy and I had split and were much taken with Cathy.