Welcome to another series of tales based on the consequences of a single, 'What if?' question. For new readers of mine, please don't expect realistic scenarios. I lean to the plausibly ridiculous.
----------
A REPUTATION 1: CLEANING UP
"Well, that was epic, Will," my roommate Mitch observed drily.
"Yeah," I sighed. It had been a bad five minutes. Bad.
Mitch and I had entered the line for the dining hall to get some 'food' for dinner, when things went wrong. I should not diss the chow in my dorm. Both La Floridita Dorm and its attached dining hall are among the most newly renovated on campus and boast an experimental new dining format. It basically means that there is more variety of mediocre options than in most other dorms. That, and on Thursdays they inexplicably do Italian food pretty well.
Mitch and I had both somehow gotten ahead on our homework, and were looking forward to streaming an older superhero movie we had both somehow never seen after we were done with dinner. (Before more homework.) We were in a good mood, and that unfortunately set me up.
The line was actually a little crowded that evening, so we would be waiting for a while in it. As soon as I realized this, I also noticed that standing right in front of us, one person ahead, were Jessica and her roommate. Jessica is a very nicely put together girl who lives in the next 'house' over in La Floridita from my own. With light, sandy-brown hair and a pretty face, combined with a much more than adequate figure, I had been keeping an eye on her over the month and half since school began this year. I had only talked to her twice, and then only in passing, but at least I knew her (first) name and she always seemed to recognize me when we passed on the road to the dorm or in the dining hall.
She never seemed terribly interested, but hey, she wasn't snubbing me either. It seemed in that moment that a dining hall line was a good place to ask a girl out for the first time. We were sort of stuck in place, and I'd have time to speak to her for a bit before asking her out... to a movie, probably. And... noting ventured, nothing gained, right?
"Hey Jessica," I said, as we reached a turn in the line. Mitch raised an eyebrow at my sudden attention to someone else, but did the right thing and shut up while trying to be invisible.
She turned to me and said, "Oh, hi... Will, right?"
It was a measure of how poorly things had been going for me on the dating front that I took this as an auspicious reply. Rather than stick with my plan to chat her up through most of the time in line, I went for it after but a sentence or two. "Hey, I was wondering, are you interested in going to see the new Fast and Furious with me Friday?" I asked as cooly as I could.
Her face barely twitched. "No... I don't think so," she said in a soft voice that nevertheless thundered with finality. There was no, 'I'm busy Friday.' There was no, 'I've got someone else I'm dating.' There was no, 'I'm seeing it with my roommate.' And there was no, 'I hate Vin Diesel.'
There was only an unmistakably polite but devastating, 'I don't want to go out with you... Will, was it?'
At this moment, as she turned to her roommate to resume their conversation (mercifully with no titters at my expense), I realized that my ideas about the brilliance of asking her out while in line had not taken into account the consequences of a hard No.
Now I had to stand here, one person away from the girl who had just rejected me, for another five minutes. My appetite abated significantly.
Fortunately, the room was loud with fifty chattering kids, waiting for food, ordering food, complaining about food, and eating food. Unfortunately, that meant that Mitch and I could converse about what happened.
"Well, that was epic, Will," my roommate Mitch observed drily.
"Yeah," I sighed.
"And so the dry spell continues," Mitch gently, almost sympathetically, ribbed me. I glared at him mildly.
"Dry spell?" I replied softly, not wanting this conversation to drift past the single person in line between us and Jessica. "We are sophomores, and I still have had a grand total of one date while in college! And that girl didn't even go to this school!"
"Don't forget that she was a psycho,"Mitch added, oh so helpfully.
"She was indeed," I snorted at the memory.
"Still, you should have nailed her before you bailed," he said, not for the first time. "At least she was kinda hot."
"Never wet your wick in crazy," I intoned wisely. Then I added more honestly, "And besides, she wasn't the right kind of psycho for that to happen."
"You always said you could have had her," Mitch accused, genuinely surprised.
"Yeah, well, I wanted to keep some dignity over the whole mess," I confessed, "but since I am already currently utterly humiliated, it seems like a good time to confess that piece of information as well."
Mitch nudged me gently with his elbow. "Ah, don't worry. College is a great time for sex. You will get yours."
I looked at Mitch skeptically. My roommate was not exactly overwhelmed by his own social calendar. In fact, I'd never seen him shot down, because I'd never seen him try. Since we'd become friends, he'd dated one girl, for a month, back in Spring of our freshman year, before we were roommates.
Unfortunately, that made the cocksucker the Voice of Experience when it came to college sex, compared to me.
"You know, you failed so hard because of the bad Karma," Mitch went on slyly.
"Bad Karma?"
"Yeah, you asked her out with her roommate right there, and me right here. You couldn't have gone for the double date?" Mitch asked in a mocking voice. "You deserved your failure."