"Uhhh sorry, what was that?" I ask, crossing my legs and worried that it might be exactly what I heard.
"Which of us have you had a sex dream about?" Bea asks, her arms folded as she smirks. She can tell the question makes me uncomfortable, though I hope she can't see me already starting to get hard. Our game of truth or dare had already been veering into spicier territory, but she just escalated.
"Uhm, when you say
sex
dream..." I ask, in part just stalling to try collect my thoughts.
Lucy coughs, adjusting her glasses before she leans forward to answer, having taken on the unofficial rule of rules lawyer for questions like this.
"Well, any dream about one of us that turned you on."
She bites her lip, watching me. The quietest girl, but she has been picking some odd moments to speak out during the game.
Jess interjects, "Yeah you don't need to have straight up fucked. I've had plenty of sex dreams that involved oral or just a really good make out session."
"Sooo, enough stalling. Who's your answer?" Bea draws my attention back.
My eyes bounce from girl to girl, my cheeks a bright red. Hazy memories flash through my mind. Lucy grinding on a pillow to masturbate. Jess pushing my head down between her thighs. Bea sprawled out naked on our couch and teasing me for drooling over her curves.
I inhale.
"...all three of you."
There's a heaviness to the air, as my answer sinks in. I don't know where to look. I realise each girl was curious if I'd say their name. But all of them are surprised by my answer.
"Wowww, so our little Tony's a slut, hmmmm?" Jess reacts first, breaking into a grin. She's sitting cross legged on the floor, wearing tiny shorts that leave most of her thighs bare, and a matching button up top that she's only lightly buttoned. The tallest and slimmest of the group, she tends to show the most skin and casually flirt.
"I uhhh, think sluts would be having more sex," I try defuse the tension.
Bea chuckles, "that's an easy problem to fix..."
Jess snaps her fingers. Looking at me with an intensity. She's sitting in a chair opposite me like it's a throne. Because she's not my roommate, I don't know her that well. So she can make me uncomfortable so easily, and loves to do it all the time.
She always oozes an arrogant confidence and now her eyes meet me with an intense gaze. She's wearing make up, because she
was
on a date. Not that I've never really seen her without something on to highlight her gorgeous face. Her outfit creates a funny contrast, as she's wearing a ratty old t-shirt borrowed from Jess, stretched tight on Bea's much larger chest, and hanging to about her mid thigh. She's got nothing on her bottom half, besides her panties... I hope.
This impromptu sleepover happened because Bea turned up on our doorstep, fuming and crying over a disastrous date with her long term boyfriend. Rather than go home with him, she needed anywhere else to crash, and a distraction.
"So what kind of gross dreams are you having about me?" Bea asks with a smirk. Not worried about my answer, instead ready to own it and make me squirm over it.
"Your turn's up, he answered your truth," Lucy interjects, coming to my rescue. I only now turn to look at her, most worried about her getting grossed out by my answer. When she turns from Bea, she just has a look of intense focus, studying me. Lucy is a tall chubby girl, with wide hips. She's wearing a tank top and a pair of yoga pants molded to her incredible curves. She's so exactly my type, I had to avoid checking her out while she gave me the house tour original. It was tough, but she's such a sweet, innocent girl I can't imagine her responding well.
Me, Jess and Lucy have been living together 6 months now and it's gone great. I've always wanted to make them comfortable, knowing the idea of a guy roommate can be awkward at times. But it's been pretty smooth, and we've gotten close. I've made sure never to be a creep to them, or any friends that came over. Never passed a comment or made any kind of move.
But obviously, I've 'noticed' Lucy and Jess. It's... probably not an exagerration to say I'm a slut. I just find most women hot. So many women have good features, I can't ignore it. But I opted to keep my mouth shut, so I don't make them feel like I was trying to get into their pants as a roommate.
Except well, Bea just blew that up a little. She came over for consolation, which led to booze, which led to some party game fun. Truth or dare, only she seemed keen to get very personal and... probing. She was obviously upset about her boyfriend, and I feel like I got designated the available male punching bag.
"So uhm, I'm going to pick you again," Lucy said to me, a little apologetic as she eyed me, "Truth or dare?"
"Dare me, I should play it safe and not take another truth," I pat her arm, hoping the show of affection can smooth things over some.
"Lucy will play it safe too..." I hear Jess mutter, and Lucy seems to hear it too, giving her a sharp look before turning back to me.
She looks at me closely, her cheeks still flush when she declares, "I dare you to describe your dream about me in detail."
My mouth goes dry. Even though a part of me wants the excuse to tell her, I look at the other two girls ready to eat my words up.
"Is that not uh... basically a truth?"
"Hm, ok I dare you to describe it, whispering directly into my ear. That way, only I hear it."
I debate if I want to argue this but I meet Lucy's eyes and she looks at me with an unexpected intensity. She meets my gaze, before deciding to come straddle my lap before I say anything.
I know I'm hard, with everything that's been happening. I try to shift so she won't feel it, but she plants herself firmly. Her eyes flickering only briefly as I make contact. She then leans forward, turning her head so I can speak directly into her ear. I can smell her perfume wafting from her neck, and her thighs squeeze the side of my legs.
"Go on," she whispers, and I tell her about my dream...
It starts with me waking up on the couch. Groggy, half asleep. I stretch and head for my room, but I hear a noise coming from your room, and feel a strong urge to check it out. Getting close, it sounds like you're excited. But I feel a pull to continue, so I knock and open the door.
And you're there Lucy, clothed but... gasping and moaning as you grind on a pillow. You're wearing a t-shirt and yoga pants. The diamond patterned pants that show off your figure really well. And you're just desperately grinding and humping, getting any friction you can as you're desperate to get off.
It's incredibly hot. In the dream I'm dumbstruck, just staring and taking it in. A long moment passing before I even think to apologise. But you say sorry back, panting through an explanation about just needing to finish. Everything you say is punctuated by hip thrusts, and my body quivers with every single one.