Mandy was one of the last girls I dated before getting married. The way she looked at me made it impossible for me to say 'no' to her. It lead to some poor decision making like driving down the interstate at 85 mph while she gave me a blowjob. That's probably a story for another time...
The first time we met was through her cousin Nikki who was trying to play matchmaker for me. I had flirted with Nikki quite a bit. She was blonde, slightly overweight, but really cute. Nikki lived a few minutes away, but she was in a serious relationship so we didn't visit in person often. We would get on webcam together though. She would undress for me when he wasn't around, and she would watch me jack off.
Nikki let me know that her cousin Mandy was coming for New Year's to her boyfriend's apartment about a half hour away. I can't remember what his name was. She said I could join the three of them if I would like. I didn't really like her boyfriend (was probably jealousy now that I look back), but meeting a new girl and spending time with Nikki sounded like fun.
I showed up around 7:00. Nikki and her boyfriend were already drinking. Mandy was shy and quiet but friendly and seemed very interested in meeting me. Nikki offered me drinks, but I wasn't really drinking alcohol at that time and Mandy was too young to drink. Mandy sat down next to me in the love seat, but we weren't getting much of a chance to talk yet. I had forgotten how chatty Nikki was.
Mandy was significantly younger than I was by almost 10 years. She had long dark hair, and she wasn't as slender as most of the girls I dated. However, she was not what I would consider obese. I usually dated shorter girls. She was taller, with her weight very proportionate with her height.
Whenever we had breaks from Nikki dominating the conversation, paying attention to the boyfriend or leaving the room to get something, Mandy and I would ask each other questions trying to get to know each other. Honestly as nice as she seemed, I was taken in more by her beauty, her really large breasts, and her perfect ass.
To this day I'm still not sure what she saw in me, but as the night went on she got closer and more comfortable, flirting, touching my arm, and then eventually resting her hand on my thigh.
The ball dropped, and Nikki was clearly horny. The lights had been off for a while, but I had seen her feeling him up for the past hour on the couch. She started dragging her boyfriend to his bedroom. I asked if she wanted me to make sure Mandy got home safe on my way out, and she said "Oh, no... She's staying here for the night. It's a long way back, and you don't need to drive in the dark. You should stay too."
I looked over at Mandy. She nodded and smiled. I thanked them, and they disappeared behind the closed door. Moaning and occasional giggling came through the thin walls.
Mandy said she would be right back and disappeared around the corner. A few minutes later she came back, changed into a t-shirt and flannel. She came over to the couch, straddled my legs, and sat down on my lap facing me. I looked up past her breasts where her nipples were pushing out against the t-shirt. She leaned down, and we kissed. "You were supposed to do that with me at midnight," she said with a mock-stern look on her face.
My cock was ready to burst out of my jeans as we kept kissing, eventually with me on my back, her on top of me. Her breasts brushed up against my chest as we made out, and I grabbed her ass as she was grinding up against my thigh.
We did finally slow ourselves down and cuddled together on the couch where we fell asleep.
Less than a week later we were dating. I was calling her every day after work, and whenever I could, I would make the hour-long round trip to be able to see her for part of an evening or weekend. We spent a lot of timing making out in the car, finding places to park as much as we could. We spent more time doing that than talking.
