Chapter 1 - The night we met
We have seen each other at the bar a few times and his eyes which show trials beyond his years show through his intense stare. He works behind the bar, and each time I have come in I have sat in a seating area away from him to give myself safety and boundaries. No one should be this infatuated without even talking to that person - should they?
Each week I have come in, it is under the guise of meeting friends or interacting with coworkers and always getting drinks from a cocktail waitress. For some reason I can't approach him. I can't initiate. And "why" is beyond me, I don't shy away from most things. But to me he is just so intense and untouchable. Just a look and I am overwhelmed.
Those feelings don't keep me from continuing to stare. He is a beacon, someone that intrigues me. He is not all hard edges - but seems defiant and searching. I imagine as a bartender, he has to be so different from me. He is not looking to climb the corporate ladder or get ahead, however in my imagination he seems to be searching for...something. He smiles at coworkers and handles his drink orders with a nod but when I have caught his eye those few precious times it is always returned with intensity.
I feel my insides go aflame and my mind go blank. It's like my entire body points due north...to him.
That moment is what I seem to crave. He pauses, looks at me, and a hint of a smile crosses his lips. His eyes burn into mine and maybe only a second or two passes, but it fuels my body even across the room. Lust surges through me, my nipples tighten and my breath stills.
But who am I to him? I definitely am not the prettiest girl in the bar. I have I have quick smile, and pretty, soft curly brunette hair that sits on a curvy, athletic figure that's always felt a little too big compared to my blonde, lithe friends that look more like what you see on magazine covers. I wonder if I am imagining this connection. If to him I seem like just another of his hundreds of patrons that walk through his bar's door. However, when his eyes were on me I felt like I was the only one there at that moment.
The first few times I came in, it was relatively early in the night. I left well before closing and knew I needed to leave due to work the next day. I would crawl into bed dreaming of his hazel green eyes and intense stare. Sometimes rubbing my nipples against my sheets to find relief.
Last night, a few friends from work had decided to go to dinner together. We joked and laughed and let off steam about work, pressures we felt, and wondering if we all were pointed in the right direction in our lives. Bottle after bottle of wine was consumed, and laughter continued. We didn't want the night to end.
When the group asked each other, where to next, I blurted out his bar before realizing what I was suggesting. Everyone in the group just nodded and rolled out of the restaurant without question. All navigating the few blocks to where I was praying he was working that night.
As I walked through the door, I realized there was a different vibe to the night than the after work crowd I was used to. The bar was full, the music was louder, and the feel was much more casual.
After showing my ID to the bouncer, my eyes immediately shot to the bar looking for him. His broad back was to me, but I could tell it was him. And at that moment, immediate relief and excitement shot through my veins. He was here tonight! My lace panties immediately were wet as I pressed my jean clad thighs together.
The women in my group congregated into a corner around a cocktail table away from the bar as the guys went to the bar for the first round of drinks. And I realized I couldn't continue to stare without being noticed by the group. My disappointment was almost physical, as I was so drawn to his presence. I navigated around the table to at least partially face the bar, so I could periodically watch him work.
The night went on, the conversation turned silly as we bought round after round. Each of us taking a turn. When it was mine, I made the excuse to go to the bar stating the waitress was busy. Which wasn't exactly a lie, but really I was eager for it to be true. My alcohol fueled brain making me brave.
I squeezed through the crowd and made my way to the front toward his side of the bar, trying to catch his eye. Some jerk who seemed to forget his manners thought that because I was alone it should be fair game to touch me. The jerk had his hand on my hips trying to steer me into an embrace. As he walked up to take my order, he saw me struggle away from the jerk's hands trying to pull me against the bastard.
My eyes went wide as he reached across the bar grabbed the jerk's arm and simply said, "let go of her". The malice in his voice didn't give room for doubt. And the look in his eyes burned the message that he was just looking for a reason to do damage to the jerk with the octopus hands. Surprisingly the jerk quickly submitted, and turned away. I stood there amazed as he then turned his gaze to me. I realized that I must have been looking into his eyes for a while, not necessarily hearing what he was asking. As the sound in the room caught up to me and the rushing sound in my ears seemed to recede, I realized his stare included a question. And as the "smooth operator" I was channeling, I replied "huh?"
That grin, his grin, again replaced his expectant look. I realized that I needed to pull myself to the present and stop staring. I could feel my blood rushing to my face.
But as I never ever take myself too seriously, I smiled, red face and all, and asked for my drink order, he cocked his head to the side and turned to fetch me the beers and drinks I ordered. Upon his return, as I passed cash across the bar, he placed his hand over mine and said...
"I have seen you here before, I would like to know your name?"
"Carina" was my breathy reply. And not because I was trying to be alluring, just my breathe seemed to vanish when he looked at me so intensely.
"Well Carina, beautiful name for a beautiful girl" he squeezed my hand before letting go and turned to his next drink order.
As he turned to make his next round of drinks, I was still dumbfounded and rooted to the spot. He pivoted to grab something below the bar, he saw me still standing there, winked and said, "I'm James" and left to grab another bottle behind the bar.
I walked back to my table in a daze. Having been given a new identity to my crush, "James." And shook myself internally as I handed drinks out to my friends and co-workers to re-engage into the conversation.
Shortly after a waitress came to the table and took our orders, she returned and handed me a single drink, slipping me a cocktail napkin and a smile. The conversation around the table was loud and rowdy, so no one notice the exchange. I put the folded napkin in my nap and opened it away from prying eyes. It read "Blue Diner. 1 AM. James"
The night continued and my group thinned. I lingered and heard last call be hollered through the bar. I was surprised at the time, I guess I had been lost in the decision trees I was running through my head. Do I go? Why wouldn't I go? My normal self-limiting, "I follow the rules" and you-don't-meet-strange-guys-in-unknown-places internal fears were being over-ridden by tonight's earlier conversation with my friends. We all were worried we were wasting our youth striving for very middle-age notions of success, wealth, and promotions. Though we were all driven, a few of us, me included, worried we were missing out on life. Just then I caught your eye and that grin shot straight to my lace panties. At that moment I nodded my head and decided to meet you, which then started another internal monologue of ohmygod-ohmygod-ohmygod.
Finally my group rose to leave. I shared a ride home with a friend who would be dropped off first, I claimed I was good to get myself home and she closed the door with a "see you Monday". But instead of telling the car driver where I lived I asked him if he knew where the Blue Diner was located. And as he pulled away from the curb, I wondered if this is what Alice felt when she fell into the looking glass.
The Blue Diner was a local foodie spot, that as it turns out, is open "after hours" to a select few who don't mind eating while the staff preps for the next day. This "after hours" seating caters mainly to other chefs, bartenders, and musicians. Not exactly closed to public, but definitely not highly advertised. As I walked through the door, I had a waiter give me a wave toward a set of tables that was covered in paper instead of linen as he carried out a stack of plates obviously just out of the dishwasher. I choose a two top in the corner and sat down as someone across the room casually yelled, "Coffee, water or alcohol?" at me. I asked for water and tried not to fidget or stare at the few surrounding tables that seemed to be filled with those in chef tunics, waiters with ties open, or groups with instrument boxes sitting along the wall.
As 1:10am came, I started to realize I would need to leave, disappointment settling heavily down on my chest until I saw him walk into the doorway, eyes searching for me. Then instant relief washed through me, followed by intense heat.
"You came"
I'm not sure who said it first. But I blushed and that grin spread across his face. The one that seems to do havoc to my insides. He moved the chair to sit next to me and simply asked if I ordered yet. I shook my head, then he flagged down one of the busy waiters and ordered two small plates of the porterhouse agnolotti and two glasses of pinot noir for both of us.