Matt left the sauna with a satisfied grin, basking in the afterglow of his intense threesome. He spotted Mike across the gym floor and hurried over.
"Hey man, that pre-workout you gave us was amazing! Got any more?" Matt asked eagerly.
Mike raised an eyebrow. "Yeah I've got a few more samples, but fair warning - that stuff is extremely potent and addictive, especially if you take it more than once in the same day, so I'd take it easy if I were you."
"Psh, don't worry about me, I can handle it! Give me five doses." Matt scoffed.
Mike looked hesitant but handed over 5 more sample packets. "Alright man, but seriously - be careful with this stuff. It's playing with fire."
"Thanks man!" Matt said, instantly getting fresh ideas in his mind. It seemed almost as if the drug was trying to influence him, even though the effects have mostly worn off.
Matt returned home and stepped into the shower, feeling invigorated after the steamy threesome at the gym. As the hot water cascaded over his muscular body, his mind wandered back to Nora and Ariana. What did they think of him now after what happened?
He pondered if they had secretly desired him all this time. The way they eagerly devoured his cock made him think they must have really enjoyed it, even if the aphrodisiac supplement lowered their inhibitions.
As Matt reminisced about his past relationship with Nora, he recalled how conservative she used to be in bed. She was always hesitant to try new things, and seemed shy when it came to sex. Things had gotten repetitive and vanilla before they broke up.
That's why her unbridled slutty behavior today shocked him so much. The timid girl he dated had transformed into a cock-hungry vixen who eagerly fucked him with her sister watching! It had to be the influence of the drug lowering her inhibitions.
Matt wondered - was this Nora's true self underneath, and she had been sexually repressed all this time? Or was the drug simply bringing out her dormant inner whore? Either way, he knew he wanted more.
"Then there was Ariana... Nora's prim and proper sister joining in was the biggest surprise of all," Matt thought.
"She always seemed to disapprove of me when I was dating Nora. I figured she saw me as some dumb jock Nora could do better than. But the way Ariana hungrily sucked my cock and rode me with total abandon told a different story."
Matt's dick stiffened as he pictured Ariana's curvy, thick body bouncing on his lap, her big tits jiggling wildly. Her moans of ecstasy echoed in his mind.
"I never knew she had such a freaky side to her. Under that reserved librarian exterior was a slut just waiting to be unleashed. I bet she's been secretly fantasizing about fucking her little sister's ex this whole time."
Matt grinned to himself as he stroked his now fully hard cock, continuing to indulge his fantasies about Nora and Ariana. One thing was clear - with more of that supplement, he could turn them into his personal sex slaves. He just had to figure out the best way to get them alone again...
As Matt stroked his cock in the shower, a devious scheme began forming in his mind. He knew Nora would be hesitant to see him again after what happened at the gym. But if he pretended to be remorseful and apologized profusely, he might be able to manipulate her into meeting him.
Matt got out of the shower, taking a look at the clock on the wall. It was 8:15pm. "There's still time" Matt thought, remembering Mike's warning about the drug's extreme addictive properties if taken in the same day. As far as he was concerned, he didn't need to take any. He wasn't sure if his extreme arousal was part of the lingering drug effect, or purely caused by the fact that he was planning to do something so wrong and devious.
Matt dialed Nora's number, trying his best to maintain composure. She finally answered, but kept silent on the other end. Matt spoke in a somber tone. "Nora, it's Matt. Look, I just want to say how sorry I am about what happened. It was so wrong."
Nora was quiet for a moment. "I mean, we were both kind of out of control..." she replied uncertainly.
"I know, but I should have been the responsible one and stopped it before things went too far," Matt said, laying the remorse on thick.
"That supplement really messed with our heads. But it doesn't excuse what I did."
"Well, I guess we all got a little carried away," Nora replied softly. Matt could tell his apology was working to make her feel more at ease. Time to reel her in.
"I'd really like to make things right between us, Nora. Could we meet up tonight and talk things through in person? Maybe over coffee?" Matt asked.
There was a pause before Nora responded hesitantly. "I don't know Matt, after what happened..."
Matt interjected "Please Nora, just give me a chance to properly apologize and explain myself. Meet me at the cafe on 5th street at 9pm?"
After a long pause, Nora reluctantly agreed. "Okay fine, I'll see you there." Matt's plan was in motion.
Matt arrived at the cafe at 8:45pm, scoping out the most private booth in the back corner. He wanted to be sure they wouldn't be overheard when Nora arrived.
Right on time, Nora walked through the entrance looking around hesitantly. Matt gave a friendly wave and Nora made her way over.
"Hey Nora, thanks for coming," Matt said as she took a seat across from him in the booth.
"I really appreciate you giving me a chance to talk things through," he continued. Nora nodded, looking uneasy.
"Can I get you a coffee or anything?" Matt asked.
Nora nodded, still seeming reserved. "I'll just have some green tea, thanks."
Matt signaled the waitress and ordered a green tea for Nora and black coffee for himself.
While they waited for the drinks, an awkward silence hung in the air. Nora avoided eye contact, clearly still feeling uncomfortable seeing Matt after their encounter.
When the waitress brought their drinks, Matt took a sip of coffee and then spoke. "So, about what happened earlier... I know things got out of control really fast."
Nora kept her eyes down, focusing on stirring her tea. "Yeah... it's just, that drug made me act so... unlike myself," she said quietly.
Matt nodded understandingly. "I know, it really seemed to lower our inhibitions drastically. I think we both got caught up in the heat of the moment."