Morning After
Josh's cock was shrinking inside me and semen began to leak from the condom.
We were in a motel room and last night I had watched him masturbate several times and he had finger fucked me to orgasm. The session had gotten me over my obsession with watching him ejaculate and this morning I had mounted him with abandon and ridden him to climax out of sheer carnal passion. But I was already feeling regrets. Josh Westerly was a frequent overnight visitor in my dorm room at USC. My roommate, Rachael spent many of her nights fucking his roommate in their room so he came to our room. He and I had been intimate a couple of times but for some reason I always felt guilty afterwards.
Why did I feel bad again? What was with me? Why was it that whenever I had sex with Josh I felt bad about it the next day? I liked him. I liked him a lot. And he really knew how to please me. Despite his small penis I could get off almost every time.
Josh sure didn't seem to feel bad. He was attentive and clearly wanted to do it again. The next day he asked me out and kept dropping hints. Now I felt bad about saying, "no sex tonight."
Father Ray was a priest at the campus Catholic Student Center. I had found that I could talk to him about anything, including my sex life. Father Ray had been working on me to avoid sex with Josh. As a result, since Josh returned from spring break I had managed to avoid sex until this morning.
I had decided not to talk to Fr. Ray about what Josh and I had done but my feelings drove me to his office. I just couldn't stay away and when I was with him I always felt obliged to tell him everything, no matter what my original intentions.
"Susie, what a pleasant surprise," he greeted me with a smile. He noticed my downcast appearance and asked, "What can I help you with?"
I turned to confirm that the door was closed behind me and told him about what I had been doing with Josh. "Now I don't feel good about it," I concluded.
"Maybe because you realize it's wrong?" he suggested.
I expected the question and had been considering it. I answered honestly, "no, I don't think that's it."
He sighed slightly, "Did you read the book I gave you?"
"Yes."
"And?"
"And what?"
"And what do you think of what you are doing based on what the book says?"
The book had been heavily biased against pre-marital sex. "I don't think I agree with it," I answered.
"None of it?"
"Well, a lot of the details made sense. But the idea that sex is only for marriage ..." I left the rest of what I had to say hanging.
"I see," he replied. Then after a pause, "So what about Josh. Why do you think you might feel bad?"
After a half hour of discussion he managed to convince me that the problem was likely that Josh wanted a long term relationship and I didn't. I felt bad because I wasn't giving him what he wanted. And, I knew it.
"By having sex with him, even the mutual masturbation, you're kind of leading him on," Fr. Ray said. "Do you see that?"
"Yes, I guess so," I answered.
"Don't you see how that's wrong?" he asked.
That was harder to admit, "yes," I squeaked out.
He smiled, "I think you need to let Josh know that you aren't interested in him romantically, or sexually."
I gulped and told him, "but I
am
interested in him sexually."
"Don't you see? For Josh a sexual interest implies a long term relationship," He smiled a smile of suppressed laughter.
"What's funny?" I asked.
"Not funny, ironic, definitely unusual. Usually it's the man who just wants sex and the woman who is taken advantage of because she expects a long term relationship."
"You mean I'm like a guy who takes advantage of a woman for his sexual enjoyment?" I was angry at the suggestion.
He sat still and stared at me, non verbally implying I knew the answer.
"I'm not!" I exclaimed. "I do it because Josh wants it too."
He continued to just look at me.
I sat in silence and after what seemed like forever he spoke calmly and quietly, "I think Josh wants to because he hopes it will lead to a long term relationship. And ... I believe you realize that."
"It will be devastating to Josh if I tell him we are to be 'just friends'."
"Exactly my point, Josh doesn't want 'just friends'. He expects, ... wants, more. I think you need to let him know only that you have no intention of a long term relationship and since sex implies a long term relationship it is best there be no sex."
"But sex doesn't imply along term relationship."
"Susie, for Josh, I suspect it does. At least he expects it to possibly lead to a long term relationship. And, honestly, I need to correct you. Sex
does
imply a long term relationship."
Okay, maybe Josh was hoping for a long term relationship and maybe I was just leading him on. But I wasn't about to dash his hopes again. "
He must feel like a yo-yo
," I thought. We have sex and then I tell him no sex and then I have sex. But, God, I was glad he put up with it.
Waiting for Summer
Father Ray might be an expert on proper behavior and seemed to have a real feel for me but he had no clue about what it might do to Josh if I told him we were "just friends" again.
The semester will be over in a month, I realized. After that Josh would be graduating and leaving for a job he had obtained in the Bay Area. Therefore, I didn't need to tell him anything. We still had the agreement that we would have sex only when I agreed to it. I'd just keep putting him off and the semester would end, he'd leave for his job, and then, sadly, this episode of my sex life would draw to a close.
But Josh started dropping hints about good medical schools in the Bay Area. "You could go to Stanford," he mentioned one evening.
It had become clear that what he wanted was for me to come to the Bay Area with him. I decided to confront the issue. "Why would I want to do that?" I asked.
"It wouldn't be hard," he said, avoiding my direct question. "I'm sure your grades are adequate."
"I don't want to be applying to another school," I stated. "I'm doing fine here. Why change?"
Well, ..." he hesitated and then, in a subdued voice, admitted his motive. "You could come to the Bay Area with me."
I tried to be a sweet as possible. "Josh," I told him, "I'm not coming to the Bay Area with you."
His look betrayed his disappointment.
"You really want to be with me, don't you?" I said and he nodded.
"Josh you are special to me too, but not 'move to the Bay Area' special. Just like I don't think I'm 'stay in L.A.' special to you."
"Susie, you are 'stay in L.A.' special. I can find a job here."
"No, Josh, You need to get on with your life. You can't build your life around me. I like you. I like you a lot. But, Josh, you're not the person I'm ready to build my life around. Let's make the best of the couple of weeks we have left."
I held him in my arms and felt a couple of tears drop from his eyes. "