We decided to just talk for a while and laid down facing each other on the bed, me on my left side and her on her right. I don't really remember everything about our conversation that night, it kind of wandered in that way that good conversations go. I do remember feeling very close to her and I think she felt the same way too, because when she got cold, instead of just grabbing a blanket she suggested getting into bed.
It was kind of funny undressing with her that night. We had already had sex, so you wouldn't think it would be a big deal. But I didn't want her to feel like I was assuming anything. Which meant that I was watching her to take my cue about how much to take off. Of course she was gorgeous so I was watching her for that reason as well. And she was watching me watching her as well and feeling shy too, judging from the blush that seemed to cover most of her body. So we ended up standing in our underwear, me in my boxers and her in panties and bra. That was when she decided to slip into bed and get under the covers. I followed and she took off her bra while I was getting into the bed.
I had a double bed at the time, a gift from my parents. We went back to facing each other on our sides, but this time a little closer. We started talking again, but we also started kissing. Somewhere in there we heard my roommate go to bed and she seemed much more relaxed after that. It was really nice laying there kissing her, going slow but wanting more. We hadn't really done this kind of thing exactly and I felt very close to her.
Of course, having an almost naked girl in my bed did eventually cause my hand to wander from her face and shoulder down her back. And when she shifted closer and I could feel her breasts touching my chest, my hand wandered even lower and onto her butt, pulling her closer. As much as I had enjoyed this position while we were talking, it seemed awkward (at least back then) to try to do a lot more. We were kissing non-stop at that point, or at least only breaking to take breaths before starting again.
I ran my hand around her hip and between her legs and she shifted so she was laying on her back next to me with her legs a little open. Obviously she enjoyed and wanted this. I teased her by running my fingertips over her thighs and stomach while I was kissing her neck. She had her arm around me, and her fingers in my hair as I kissed. I laid my head on her shoulder then and concentrated on teasing her more. Something I noticed was that her own hand kept moving almost by itself down close to her pussy, then she would pull it back. Her hips were also moving up and down slowly. I moved my fingers so they brushed the front of her panties, which were already soaked, and she moaned softly. Those soft moans she made always really got to me.