Requested by Big Boat
"Oh, fuck," Brad mouthed, and he stood over a slender, blond hair woman and stroked his long, thick cock to completion. Lily counted the ropes of cum he left on the woman's pretty face and open mouth. One...Two...Three...Four...Five....
"Lily...?"
"Huh? What?!" Lily paused the video on her phone and looked up to find her boyfriend, Paul, standing in the doorway of their bedroom, and she silently and immediately compared him against the man in the video she was watching. Paul was very little like Brad. He was shorter than Brad, but his skinny body made him look taller than his 5'10" height actually was. Because he was so skinny, he was all elbows and knees with a shock of thinning brown hair on the top of his head despite his age.
His dick was different, too. Brad had a beautiful dick. Easily 8" and very thick with a delicious rightward curve that hooked a woman and kept her on. Paul was not so well-endowed and measured at most 5" on his proudest days. Even if he were longer, it wouldn't matter, because his dick was on the thinner side and had never brought her to climax. He was good with his fingers, though, and great with his tongue, but then again, he had to be, and she made sure he got plenty of practice.
"Lily, are you coming? It's about time."
"Oh. Sorry. Right." Lily rose from the bed, and her heavy bosom bounced with her movements as she crossed the room. Her nipples were hard and visibly through the soft pink top she was wearing, but she saw no reason to hide them. In the worst-case scenario, she looked easy, which she was used to. In the best-case scenario, it helped negotiations get off on the right foot.
Paul eyed her stiff nipples and then stared down her womanly, hourglass figure. Lily was tall for a woman, standing at 5'7", and had wide hips and shapely thighs. Her curves were what drew men to her to begin with and were what allowed her to make money. They were what paid the bills for the couple, so Paul not only wasn't jealous but had no right to be jealous. Most of the time, he was proud of her body and didn't mind that she showed it off and drew attention wherever they went. Lately, however, he has been feeling a bit inadequate.
"What were you watching?"
"Oh, just doing some research," she lied, and she gave him a smile and kissed him on the cheek before she led him into the living room. He was staring at her ass and her exposed lower back as she walked, and she smiled at him over her shoulder when she caught him staring and said, "Who's holding us up now?"
Paul gave a playful laugh and wiggled his eyebrows at her. "Sorry! It's hard not to stare."
"Save it for the bedroom, handsome."
Paul and Lily were considered a mismatched couple, but they were happy together. They met in high school, before Lily blossomed, and they had stayed together since. In college, as her grades slipped, Lily began using her newly grown curves to make money online, and Paul had stayed with her. His patience and understanding were what won her over, and they married before he graduated with a degree in general studies and no real idea as to where he was going with his life or where he would land.
That was how Lily became the primary breadwinner in their relationship, and both were happy with the arrangement. Paul helped take photos for her and helmed video editing, and when people were being too creepy on live streams, he would moderate and supervise. Lately, he had even been willing to pose with her, too.
Lily and Paul settled together on the couch, and Paul pulled up his phone and opened his Facetime app. They waited to connect with Brad and were snuggled together until Brad came on screen. He was handsome and rugged, with perfectly trimmed stubble and his muscular torso displayed with an open shirt. "Lily," he said with familiar warmth like they were old friends, and he gave a perfect, handsome smile that made her moist.
Brad was still new to the online porn scene, but he was very popular. His buff body and thick, right-curving cock were his trademarks, and while he was still building an audience, the fans he had gotten were dedicated and vocal. It was them who turned Lily onto Brad with constant requests that they do content together, and the truth wis that she has been obsessed with him since the moment she saw that dick of his.
"H-Hey, Brad," she stammered, and she blushed like a highschooler with a crush. Paul said hi, too, but Brad didn't acknowledge him. There was electricity on the call as Brad and Lily sized each other up. Paul was the third wheel, and they both knew it.
"Wow, you really are that beautiful. It's not even makeup, is it," he asked, and Lily giggled.
"I could say the same about you, Mr. Muscles."
Brad did a flex of his bicep and grinned smugly. "I'm just showing off the merchandise."
"Yeah, we can see how you make your money," said Paul, but no one seemed to notice.
"Wow, those are some big arms," whispered Lily, but Brad seemed to hear her over Paul and responded to her instead of her boyfriend.
"I'm not the only one with an impressive physique. I've seen your videos. You're gorgeous." He winked at her through the video and said, "Really, we're nothing if not compatible."
"Well, I we'll see, I guess," said Lily, and she felt dizzy with excitement. She hadn't stopped smiling from the moment she saw him, and it felt like Paul was invisible beside her. She knew he was there, but she couldn't hear him. Her ears were primed for Brad's words and voice, not Paul's.
"So, let's get to this negotiation," said Paul with some uncomfortable laughter. He did not want this, but he didn't want to say that, either. Paul loved Lily, and he had never felt jealous of another man before. In fact, he hadn't felt any sort of jealousy about her Only Fans or the requests that subscribers made until he appeared in her videos. To that point, he had been satisfied with their relationship and had even been willing to share her with various women they had met online, but his debut had hurt him deeply, but he would never tell her why.
Paul was not well-endowed. He had known this for a long time, but he had never felt self-conscious about it. He and Lily had sex often, and she said it was good. She came when he used his fingers and his tongue, and he had no reason to believe that she was dissatisfied with him. Everything he read had told him that women rarely came from penetration to begin with. He thought their relationship was normal, and when her numbers began falling, he had not hesitated to join her in videos to spice up her content and give the people the sex that they were asking for.
Then, the comments started coming in. Many subscribers felt cheated after paying, and the comments made during the live chat were...unkind to say the least. Paul was made fun of for everything from his penis size to his thinning hair, and the things that people would say were beyond repulsive. He couldn't count on a dozen hands how many comments about being bred by a proper dick were left on her page, and Paul was the one responsible for each every one of them that was deleted.