Episode Two: Jake and Lisa
November 25-28, 2024
Wednesday, November 25, dawns crisp as Jake rolls into Elmwood in his Camaro, a 2-3-hour drive from campus for Thanksgiving week. Nearly a month since the Halloween party, the torn black lace panties have festered in his duffel, a jagged secret he's carried back home--a frame honed by lacrosse into broad shoulders and a taut, wiry strength, dark hair mussed from the road, hazel eyes restless with intent. Karen--dark hair loose, brown eyes warm--bustled in the kitchen, phone cradled against her shoulder as she chopped onions. "Lisa, you owe me that pecan pie recipe after I saved your ass at last year's bake sale--don't think I've forgotten!" She laughed, then glanced at Jake over her coffee mug. "Hey, hon, your dad's stuck late at the office prepping for the holiday rush. Could you swing by Lisa's and grab my recipe book? I need it for Thursday's pie, and I'm swamped here."
Jake's stomach twists, his spoon clattering against his cereal bowl. "Uh, sure," he manages, keeping his tone casual. "No problem."
Karen smiles, oblivious--her tipsy distraction at the party a month ago still echoing in her easy trust--and returns to her call. Jake excuses himself, heart thudding as he heads upstairs to his old room. He hesitates at his bag, then fishes out the panties from beneath a pile of clothes--crumpled but intact, the torn seam a stark reminder of that night. He shoves them into the pocket of his jeans, the fabric soft and illicit against his thigh, and grabs his jacket. This is a chance--to confront the lie, to end it, or... something else. He isn't sure yet.
"Jake gripped the steering wheel of his Camaro, the engine's low growl vibrating through him as he sped toward Lisa's. The torn panties weighed heavy in his pocket, a jagged reminder of that night--her hands on him, her voice commanding, his silence deafening. He'd ached for her all week, her glances across the Thanksgiving table a tease he couldn't answer with Karen's family swarming. Guilt twisted his gut--Karen's laughter downstairs that morning, oblivious--but beneath it, a darker pulse thrummed. He wanted her again, not as Tom's shadow, but as himself. To take her this time, not be taken. His knuckles whitened. Could he do it? Face her, own it, turn the game on its head?"
Lisa's house is a short drive, a tidy Craftsman with a wraparound porch and flower boxes still blooming despite the late November chill. Jake's breath fogs in the air as he climbs the steps, his sneakers scuffing against the wood. He rings the bell, shifting his weight, the panties burning a hole in his pocket.
The door swings open, and there she is--Lisa, 34, barefoot in a fitted sweater and leggings, her blond hair loose and spilling over her shoulders. A freelance travel photographer, she's fresh from a weekend shoot up the coast, her camera bag still unpacked by the couch. Her blue eyes widen slightly, a flicker of recognition crossing her face before she masks it with a smile, jasmine-and-amber scent wafting from her skin.
"Jake," she says, her voice smooth but laced with curiosity. "Didn't expect you. Come in."
He steps inside, the warmth of her home enveloping him, tinged with that familiar perfume. The living room is cozy--plush furniture, a flickering candle on the coffee table--but the air feels charged, heavy with unspoken history.
"Mom said you've got her recipe book," he says, keeping his tone neutral as he lingers near the couch.
"Right, of course." Lisa crosses to a bookshelf, her hips swaying subtly as she moves--her slim frame taut from hauling gear on shoots. She plucks a worn paperback from the shelf and turns, holding it out. "Here you go. Tell her I said thanks for letting me borrow it."
Jake takes the book, his fingers brushing hers for a split second. Her skin is warm, and her gaze lingers on him, searching. He swallows, the weight of the panties pressing against his leg like a dare. He could leave now--drive away, keep the secret buried. But something in her eyes, that glint of knowing, pushes him over the edge.
"There's something else," he says, his voice low, steady. He reaches into his pocket, pulling out the balled-up lace, and holds it up between them.
Lisa freezes, her breath catching audibly. Her blue eyes lock on the panties, then flick to his face, wide with shock. "What--where did you--" she stammers, her composure cracking. Then realization dawns, her lips parting as color rushes to her cheeks. "That night... it was you?"
Jake nods, stepping closer, his broad-shouldered frame towering over her 5'6" one. "Yeah. It was me."
For a moment, silence stretches taut between them. Then, to his surprise, her shock softens into something else--relief washing over her face, her lips parting in a shaky, thrilled smile. "Oh my God, Jake," she breathes, her voice trembling with excitement as she steps closer, her hands hovering near his chest. "It was *you*? I--I hoped it was, that night, the way you felt... I'm so glad it wasn't Tom." Her blue eyes shine with a wild, fleeting joy, but then her expression falters, the color draining from her cheeks as realization crashes in. She stumbles back a step, her hand flying to her mouth. "Wait--if Tom or Karen ever found out... what happened, what I *wanted* with Tom all those years... they'd never forgive me. Karen's my best friend, Jake. I'd lose her, Tom, everything--I'd be ostracized, a pariah in this town." Her voice cracks, panic edging in as she grabs his arm, her grip tight. "Please, you can't tell anyone. Not a word--promise me, Jake. This stays between us, or it'll ruin me." Her eyes search his, desperate, pleading, the weight of her vulnerability laid bare.
"I couldn't," he says, his voice rougher now, edged with something darker as he meets her pleading gaze. "Not that night--I was too caught up, too lost in it. But I'm saying it now, Lisa, and I won't tell a soul. This stays ours--your secret's safe with me." His words carry a weight that matches hers, a promise forged in the heat of their shared truth.