Jay hadn't seen Chloe for weeks. Their encounter where he'd seen her in her window and she had come over and fucked him had been forgotten. He wasn't surprised that she hadn't mentioned it to her brother Aaron who was also Jay's best friend. He guessed that she was probably just embarrassed. Her absence hadn't stopped him looking out of his bedroom window over into hers. Sometimes he saw her silhouette undressing behind the curtains and his member would begin to stiffen at the memory of her bouncing on him. He often masturbated to this memory. It had felt more to Jay than just a fuck though. Although the approach was very forward, Chloe had kissed him tenderly and caressed him as if they were lovers. It had left Jay confused.
In the weeks that he and Chloe had had sex, Jay had begun to date a girl called Fran. She was pretty, petite and blonde. She was not his usual type but Jay didn't mind because she made him laugh and was great to spend time with. They had not yet had sex but they had got to the oral stage and Jay knew that the time was coming soon that they would sleep together. To his surprise, he wasn't excited. He had fortunately slept with many other girls before Chloe as he had been blessed with a handsome face and toned body that made girls swoon for him. Yet, Chloe had by far been the best he had ever had. He wondered if it was under the circumstances as she had been in control. No, he thought, he'd done the whole dominating role play before and it had never been like it had been with Chloe.
One night after dinner, Fran led Jay to her room. This was routine, she often led him up there and would give him head and then he would be on his way. They sat down on her pink bed and began to kiss deeply.
Jay's hand moved from Fran's back to her front as usual and began to cup her breasts in his hands. Fran unzipped Jay's jeans and pulled down his boxers to reveal his large cock. Again, this was normal. He expected her to go down on him for a few minutes. But then Fran whispered in his ear: "I want you to be my first Jay...please?" And then she looked at him with her pretty, doughy blue eyes and bit her lip. Jay had not expected this.
He began to kiss her passionately in his excitement leaving her lips and kissing her neck and then her chest. Jay unbuttoned Fran's shirt revealing a lacy white bra that he quickly undid to show her breasts. He sucked on her pink nipples as his hands moved down to her groin to finger her but her hand stopped him. "Please Jay just do it now we've had weeks of foreplay. I want you." Jay tore off his jeans and boxers and his cock sprang out. He hoisted her skirt up and pulled down her lacy white knickers and then filled Fran with every inch of him. She yelped at his size as she took him. It hurt but she took him in her. Jay stared down at Fran. Her face was contorted in pain as he pushed his way into her as her vagina tried to retrain him. It was then that he realised that he was in no way attracted to this cute, pink and fluffy girl lying in front of him, impaled on his cock. He wanted Chloe. He began to imagine that Fran was Chloe and that he was fucking her beautiful, curvaceous body instead. Jay imagined her large breasts bouncing as he thrust hard into her. He imagined that Fran's screams of pain were shrieks of joy from Chloe. He imagined Fran's pained face was Chloe's face as she began to orgasm. With this Jay let out a grunt and released himself into Fran.
As he began to calm Jay looked up at Fran. She was in tears. He had obviously hurt her and not slowed when he was in the midst of his fantasy. Her first time, he thought and he had not even been thinking about her. He got up and began to dress. Fran looked at him wide eyed and asked where he was going. Between her legs looked raw and used and he felt awful that he had done that to her. "I'm so sorry Fran." Jay said and he left Fran's house without another word.
For days Jay ignored calls and texts from Fran in a hope that what he did to her would go away. One day he told his parents he would pop out to pick up some groceries. He jumped in the car and headed out. He was a mile away from his house and then he saw her. Chloe. Her long dark hair was up in a pony tail. She wore jeans that accented her rounded ass and a spaghetti strapped top that barely contained her breasts. She lugged along two bulky shopping bags, she slowed to put one down and wipe her forehead of sweat. Jay watched her from his car window and could not help but call out to her. Chloe's head whipped round and her unusual amber eyes clocked Jay in his parent's car. She sighed. Chloe had been avoiding him because she'd been so embarrassed at how she had acted. She'd not had sex in 6 months before their encounter and had been desperate for it. She hadn't planned on staying at her parent's house much longer but her application to her other university had taken much longer than planned.
Jay drove up beside the curb and leaned out of the window. "Hi." He said simply.
