It was official. Craig was in a love triangle.
Over the next few weeks as he healed from the fight, he consistently texted back and forth with both Brittany and Madison. Never in his life had he seen so much attention from girls at once. Not only that, but word about the incident spread like wildfire across campus and his little secret was not so secret anymore.
Girls everywhere would give him a second glance. Girls that would have never paid any attention to him before were now openly checking him out and whispering to each other as he walked by. He felt like the most popular guy on campus and it was all because of his big cock.
Steven was suspended. Craig opted to not press charges and instead let the University determine punishment. He had not seen him since he laid him out on the dorm room floor. He felt divided over the result. Steven punched him because of something
he
did. If he hadn't hooked up with Brittany, none of this would have ever happened.
Meanwhile, his mind was plagued with what to do about the girls. He had not been intimate with either of them since the parking lot and hospital. He didn't think it was right. He had to choose. He decided to confide in his friend Gary for advice. They met each other for lunch one day.
"Dude, you're gettin a ton of looks from girls, huh?"
Craig shoveled lettuce into his mouth, staring down at his plate. "Tell me about it. It's been nuts."
Gary looked around the cafeteria as girl after girl would glance in Craig's direction. He winked at one of them, pointed to Craig and then laid his forearm out on the table. The girl laughed out loud as she walked away with her friends. Gary cracked up and looked back at Craig who was not amused.
"Aww, c'mon man. Can't you see these chicks are into you because of your friggin mammoth dong?"
"I'd rather they not be," Craig said, unfond of the recent attention.
"Shit man, speak for yourself. I'd love to have what you have with all these chicks wanting to see your dick," Gary said as he slurped on his Pepsi. "Fuckin Big Dick Rick over here," he joked.
"Dude, I need your help," Craig said, changing the subject. "I don't know what to do about Brittany and Madison."
"The computer chick?" Gary asked, confused.
"Yes, dude. I've told you all this. Jesus, were you that drunk?"
"Ahh, no, no, I remember. Your little love triangle, huh?"
"I can't keep seeing them both."
Gary held his hands up, flabbergasted. "Dude? Why the fuck not? Go get 'em with your friggen lead pipe!"
Craig shook his head as he moved vegetables around on his plate. "No... no, no, no. I'm not that guy. I am not hurting someone again."
"Again? You mean Steven? That dude was a fuckin loser, man. He's a little dick jealous loser." Gary was never one to hold back with colorful language. He also despised Steven and most jocks. "So, tell me. Which one do you like the most? Brittany's fuckin hot, bro."
Craig laughed for the first time. "She is. She really, really is."
"So there's your decision. And she seems to love Craig Jr., so go get it my brother," Gary said.
"That's the thing though. I think she only likes me for my dick."
Gary held his hands up again. "Dude. So. The. Fuck. What?"
"Madison and I have a connection man. She's sweet. Caring. Brittany didn't even text me in the hospital."
Craig looked across the room at a group of girls that were whispering something looking back at him. He turned back to Gary. "Wait a minute. Neither did you!" They both cracked up laughing.
"Sorry man. I'm a shitty friend."
"But listen," Gary concluded as he stood up with this empty tray. "You gotta go see them both. One at a time. Then figure it out. You'll be fine, bud."
"Ok," said Craig with a long face.
"Oh and don't be such a downer man. You got a nine inch rod that every one of these babes knows about now. Go own it. I'll see ya later."
As Gary walked away, Craig stared back at the group of girls. They were still looking in his direction. He smiled at them and waved. They smiled and waved back. Craig picked up a large breadstick from his tray and held it up for them. He gripped it from the base and wagged it a bit. The girls all squealed in delight as they covered their mouths with their hands. Craig laughed and stood up to put his tray away.
He needed to see Madison.
--------------------
The campus bar was known for serving just about anyone regardless of age. The drinking age was 21, but that didn't stop everyone including freshmen from tying one off. Craig invited Madison to meet him there for really no reason except being normal. He wasn't a big drinker, but assumed this was what you're supposed to do with a girl.
Madison walked in, looked around, and then spotted Craig at a table in the back. She smiled and waved as she maneuvered around the crowds of drunk students on her way to him. Just as she nearly made it, a meathead looking kid bumped into her. He was carrying two full pints. "Ha, sorry," he said as he moved along. Madison frowned as she sat down. "This is why I can't stand these places," she said.
Craig laughed out loud. "Me too! I thought this was where we're supposed to go."
"Supposed to? Are you following the handbook or something, Craig? C'mon, let's go." Craig tossed a ten dollar bill on the table for his beer and followed Madison through the crowd and out to the lawn in front of the Campus Center.
"Much better," said Madison as they walked at a slow pace together. It was a warm and crisp spring night.
"Agreed."
They found a spot on the grass and each sat down. With a comfortable silence between them, Craig held her hand. His was sweaty but hers was cool.
"Do you know that everyone looks at you?"
Craig nodded. "I kind of got beat up recently."
Madison shook her head. "It's the girls looking at you. And I think you know why." Madison turned to him.
Craig nodded again. Madison smiled and looked away. "I like you, Craig. Did you know that?"
Before Craig could respond, Madison laughed. "Of course you do. Your penis was in my mouth." They each cracked up laughing so hard, they nearly fell over together.
"I like you too Madison. I think I have for a while."
She turned to him and took his other hand in hers. "Then let's do this. Let's be a thing or whatever."
Craig smiled. "I would love that." He leaned in for a kiss, but Madison turned away.
He knew why. "It's Brittany," he said.
She nodded while still looking away. "Do you like her too?"
Craig took a deep breath. "No... We were just having fun. I want you to know that. She helped me come out of my shell. And I'm grateful for that. But no, we're not a thing. I like you."
"Will you tell her?"
Craig nodded. "Of course. Absolutely, Madison."
She leaned in and they kissed passionately. A whistle could be heard from a student walking by with his friends. As Madison and Craig separated, she blushed and wiped her mouth while the student clapped. "Go get that dick, girl!" he teased. Craig's gift was well known by all.
"Not sure I want to deal with
that
all the time!" Madison said. Craig smiled and hugged her. They cuddled on the grass before parting ways for the night.
The next day Craig would have to see Brittany.
---------------
Despite his newfound campus fame, confidence, and ability to please women, Craig still felt a usual sinking anxious feeling as he rode the elevator up to Brittany's floor. He didn't really formulate a game plan. How could he break things off with the hottest girl on campus? What would everyone say about that? Did Madison really want to be exclusive with him? What if she changed her mind?
As Brittany's door opened, her familiar smell wafted out like fresh flowers. She was smiling sweetly. She wore tight black yoga pants and a loose-fitting t-shirt. Her blonde hair was draped down one side of her head.
"Craigy!" she said happily as she threw her arms around him. He half-smiled and hugged her back. They had not seen each other since the incident.
"Come in, come in. I'm so happy you're here. How are you feeling?"
"I'm better, thanks. Got some bumps and bruises, but I'm alright." Craig walked inside and noticed Leah sitting at her desk. She wore short shorts and a tank top. Her legs were neatly pressed against her chest as she typed on her computer. She looked up and smiled. "Hey you," she said flirtatiously. Craig waved awkwardly. He pictured Leah blowing him.
Brittany led Craig to the couch where they both sat down. She faced him and held his hands. "I'm so sorry about what happened," she said with a tone that Craig couldn't decipher if it was sincere or not. "Steven and I were already finished when you and I had sex. You didn't do anything wrong."
Leah entered the room and sat on the other side of Craig. She smiled and crossed her gorgeous tan legs. Craig determined there was no way he could have the conversation he thought he was going to have today. And he was easily becoming distracted by the two beautiful girls on either side of him.
"You're such a sweet guy. What he did to you was so wrong," Leah added. She placed a hand on Craig's thigh and squeezed ever so slightly. It was obvious things were heating up fast and Craig's cock responded with a twitch.
Brittany slid closer to him. She put her head on his shoulder as she rubbed his other thigh. Craig's hands were positioned over his crotch as he felt an erection forming.