12
At school that week I had a lot on my mind. Not anything scholarly, mind you, as graduation was at the end of the week, so the amount of care and attention spent on classes was minimal at best. No, my mind was occupied with thoughts of Steph. Specifically thoughts of her tits, her mouth, the single finger she used to make me cum...her semen-streaked face as she showed me her mouthful right before swallowing. We had come a long way from even a few weeks ago when she was just my step sister's hot best friend who would tease me from time to time.
And that's not even to mention Christine. Up until yesterday she was just my friend from church--the pastor's daughter who would commiserate with me over her love life, over her struggle between her desire to stay godly and pure...and her desire to give in to the pleasures of the flesh. That is, up until yesterday, when she humped herself to orgasm against my leg before sucking my soul out through my cock. I wasn't sure where she and I stood, but I think she wanted it to happen again.
And then there was Tara. I had no clue what was going on there. We had had a tense conversation where we each admitted everything that happened on prom night, yet there was still so much left unsaid; It was that chasm of things unsaid that kept us apart. She had lost her virginity to Bud Pepper, I had had my world royally rocked by Steph's mouth, and we were both jealous and stubborn for reasons we were too afraid to admit. She was my best friend and I hurt her. I missed her desperately.
But my mind kept coming back to Steph. Specifically the story she told me last night as she cranked my dick toward an epic orgasm. She had told me the story of how she lost her virginity to the gym teacher, Mr. Ridley, while at a volleyball tournament, and it was epically hot, and dirty, and taboo, and...possibly a lie? It had been a tale straight out of Penthouse Forum, and while I didn't doubt that a girl as hot and lusty as Steph could have had such an experience, there was a certain tenor to the way she told it. A certain sadness.
I had become intimately familiar with Steph, with her orgasm, with her arousal, and despite the fact that I had tasted her pussy, and cum in her mouth, there was still a distance between us. She was aloof. Protective. Possibly afraid to admit she liked what we were doing. Possibly afraid to admit she liked...me.
She had been the one in control--my cock belonged to her, after all--but I wondered if that wasn't all just a defense mechanism. Which is why her story, at least the way she told it, had a certain falseness to it. A certain sense of fantasy. Maybe the only way she could tell me what she really wanted, what really turned her on, was to do it while she was still being dominant.
Like I said, a lot on my mind.
A slight distraction came in the form of being a "volunteer" to help set up for graduation on the field behind the school. I say volunteer that way because it wasn't so much a request as much as a command. It was fine, though, one of the other volunteer's was Sarah, the girl who lived next door. The girl I had a crush on for as long as I could remember. The girl I saw get properly fucked through her bedroom window. It was a testament to everything that had been going on with my life lately that even after all those things, Sarah was actually toward the bottom of my list of girls I was thinking about.
Even so, she was great to hang out with, and after leaving my stuff in Ms. Dorman's room, Sarah and I paired off quickly and went to work on our tasks.
It was also beneficial because Sarah had a certain intimate connection to Steph, and might be able to help me make sense of what was going on with her.
After finishing our allotment of chairs, she and I took a break on the bleachers. We chatted about nothing, really. I wasn't sure how to steer things in the direction I wanted, but luckily I didn't have to.
"So, how are things with Steph?" she asked, knocking back a bottle of water. I admired her pale thighs extending out from the seat of pink short shorts, as well as the swell of her large breasts that pushed up as she arched into the last drops in the bottle.
"I have no idea," I said, snapping out of my gawk. It was the truth. "She keeps me at arm's length constantly, and she's clearly terrified of my step sister finding out anything happened between us...it's just really confusing."
"So," she began as a slight smile crept over Sarah's face. I think she thought my love troubles were kind of cute. "Have you...I'm assuming you guys have hooked up?" Her voice had an upward lilt that told me she was sorry for prying.
"Yeah," I offered back, not sure of how much information she really wanted. If it were Tara, she'd want every detail down to the last drop of semen...but this was not Tara. "We haven't slept together, but...yeah." I qualified.
"More than once?" She offered back again, fairly quickly. I nodded in the affirmative. "Well all I can tell you is, Steph generally isn't a repeat offender, so if she's coming back for more...well then I think maybe she likes you, Tim."
Normally this kind of revelation would be liberating, but honestly it wasn't that much of a relief. It made the whole thing that much more fragile.
"From what I understand she got hurt pretty bad once, so she has a tendency to pull away sometimes," she said, wiping the sweat from her brow.
"I didn't realize you guys were so close," I said. Sarah didn't know it, but I knew full well how close she and Steph had been. Very close. Mouth-to-genitals close.
"Girls tell each other things, what can I say," she nervously chuckled.
"Did she ever tell you..." I began, pausing to debate finishing my question, "...how she lost her virginity?"
Sarah's eyebrows shot up. "Well now, aren't we nosey?" she teased, but then evened out when she saw that I was serious. "Yeah, she told me...a couple times."
"A couple times?"
"Yeah...the story is different every time she tells it. It's kinda fun, actually. I have no idea what the true version is. Why do you ask?"
"No reason," I lied, badly. My mind started to wander at this revelation. Sarah picked up on it and managed to snap me right back to attention.
"I actually lost mine right over there!" She said, pointing to a section under the bleachers that was obscured by a big banner.
"Oh yeah?" I said, my ears, and cock, perking up.
"Yeah, with Andy Fiorentino after a football game." My mind immediately conjured up an image of Sarah, bracing against the legs of the bleachers, getting fucked from behind. I would never have guessed that this girl--top ten in the class with honors, AP classes--got down as lustily as she did. I wasn't jealous like I had been with Tara...with Sarah I was just impressed. "It was awful."