manipulation-into-blackmail
FIRST TIME SEX STORIES

Manipulation Into Blackmail

Manipulation Into Blackmail

by thestefansinadinoviclore
19 min read
4.57 (6400 views)
adultfiction

Stefan stood in front of the full-length mirror in his cramped bathroom, shirt clinging to his chest, sweat from his evening workout still trickling down his arms. His gym tank had ridden up a bit, exposing lines of his lower abs and the V-shape that always got attention when he wore anything remotely fitted.

He rubbed his palm down the side of his neck, eyes drifting to the steam-fogged mirror. His phone buzzed again from the edge of the sink.

Snapchat.

From Jovana.

He froze.

That name hadn't popped up in 3 months.

His stomach gave a weird little twist. Not quite panic, not quite excitement something between a gut punch and nostalgia. She had left Belgrade for a job in Germany three months ago. Bold move. She was always chasing bigger, louder things more people, more options, more life. Stefan hadn't blamed her. But when she suggested they try long distance, he didn't even pretend to be interested.

He was too physical for that. He needed touch. Needed thighs around his hips and a mouth moaning against his neck. Not jerky video calls and voice notes at midnight. He wanted her in his bed, not her face frozen on screen.

Still, he'd thought about her more than he cared to admit.

He wiped his hands on the towel and checked the notification.

The Snap opened to a black screen, with one word written across it:

"Missed you."

Just that. No emoji. No extra punctuation. Short. Mysterious. Straight to the center of his chest.

He stared at it longer than he should have.

Then replied:

"Didn't expect to hear from you."

A moment passed.

Buzz.

Black screen, new text:

"Bet you still think about me when you're hard."

That crooked smile crept onto his lips. It was so her. Teasing, blunt, sexy like it was casual.

"You sending me a memory or an invitation?"

"Maybe both."

The next Snap caught him off guard. Not new at least, not obviously. A shot of her waist in black lace panties, face cropped out, lying on what looked like her old bedsheets. He couldn't be sure if he'd seen it before, but it felt... familiar.

His heart beat a little faster.

She followed it with a text:

"Do i still make that big dick hard?"

His dick twitched instantly. His sweats suddenly felt tighter.

"Why don't you find out?"

From there, the old rhythm returned like slipping back into a bad habit he'd secretly missed. The messages were flirty, a little dirty, but always just enough to pull him deeper.

"I used to stare at it when you slept. Big thing just lying there, half-hard, like it was daring me."

He laughed, ran a hand down the front of his joggers.

"Could barely keep it in your throat."

"I dream about how you stretched my jaw."

Then came the Snaps again black screens, always black, with her words in white text:

"I bet it's hard now."

"Send me a pic. Just the tip."

"Show me that fat shaft."

He obliged. No hesitation.

Snap: his cock outlined through thin grey boxer briefs, thick and rising.

Snap: waistband lowered, the head exposed already glossy.

Snap: gripped in his hand, slow stroke.

"Fuck," she wrote. "Still so fucking beautiful."

His ego drank it in. She always had made him feel stimulated for sex. The way she used to beg for it, suck it like it was air. He'd missed that.

Then she sent something new.

A link to a porn clip.

Short, grainy. A woman deepthroating a thick cock, drooling, moaning loud.

"Watched this last night," she wrote. "Thought of you the whole time."

His cock throbbed.

"You always loved throatfucking," he replied.

"Still do. But none of them hit as deep as you."

More Snaps followed.

One was a still from a blowjob scene saliva running down a girl's chin, balls pressed tight against her face.

"I remember doing this in the car that night on Zeleni Venac," she wrote. "You nearly crashed."

He chuckled, slow stroking now.

Then another.

"This made me cum last week."

A short video of a guy standing while a girl licked his balls, her eyes locked up at him, hands behind her back.

"Used to love doing that to you when you were half asleep."

That one hit hard. He remembered that clearly. Waking up to her warm mouth on his cock, tongue under his balls, her fingers barely grazing his thighs. She loved sneaking head in when he least expected it.

He typed back:

"You used to get off on it. Like you needed it."

"I did. I still do. Show me what I'm missing."

Another Snap. Again: just text.

"Pull your balls up. Let me see them when you stroke."

He blinked. That was new. Specific. Different.

"Since when are you this bold?"

"Since I've been fantasizing about you for months."

He didn't question it.

He pulled his balls up, took a snap angled from below, dick rigid and heavy, veins thick.

Sent.

The next one came fast:

"God I'd suck you dry right now. On my knees. Let you use my throat until you fill it."

Stefan's breath caught. He stood in the mirror again, cock gripped tight, tip leaking steadily. He stared at himself while she sent another message.

"What if I just showed up? Got on my knees. No questions. Just my mouth around your cock."

"You wouldn't even need to stop jerking. I'd just take over."

Then another porn clip a cumshot across a girl's lips, tongue out, eyes closed.

"Reminded me of that night on your couch. Remember how much I swallowed?"

He sent a voice note. Low groan. "Fuck, baby. You really want it that bad?"

Her reply:

Black screen. Text:

"Desperately."

He didn't like the toxic part but also he enjoyed this new feeling she gave him.

But deep down, something felt... off.

She wasn't this bold before. Jovana liked being slutty, sure but in person. In real space. Online, she was shy. Teasing. Never this aggressive.

No real-time snaps. Just black-screen text, maybe the occasional recycled selfie. And these porn clips too specific and most oral.

Still, the fantasy was too good.

He kept playing into it. Stroking, filming, sending.

She asked for a mirror video next full frontal, naked, hand slowly working his thick cock while he flexed.

He sent it.

She replied:

"You're a fucking dream. I could suck you for hours."

📖 Related First Time Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

"You wouldn't last five minutes," he wrote back.

Then came the Snap.

Black screen. Text:

"What if I sucked you while your eyes were closed... and you didn't know it was me?"

He paused.

Frowned.

"Weird question."

"Not really. Would it matter? Mouth's a mouth when it's that good."

His cock throbbed again. Against his better judgment.

"You saying you'd sneak it?"

"Only if you didn't stop me. Only if you moaned."

"Sounds like you've thought this through."

"Every night. You jerking off right now?"

"Yeah."

"Close your eyes. Pretend I'm on my knees. Pretend you can feel my lips on your tip. Just my tongue, my throat, my spit all over that fat cock."

He did it.

Closed his eyes. Gripped harder.

His moans filled the room.

Then silence.

No new messages.

No reply.

He stared at the phone for a minute. Cock still wet in his hand, heart thumping, mind spinning. Waited texted her but no reply.

Until something happened later in the week.

But for now, the only thing Stefan knew was this:

He never thought Jovana would message him since the breakup.

He hadn't cum that hard in months while sexting someone let alone Jovana.

He needs to find a new place to rent.

His paycheck is running late.

And the time is running out, he needs to figure something by the end of the week or he will be kicked out and sleep on the street.

Two days later, his phone lit up.

Ivica.

Stefan blinked, thumb hovering over the screen. He hadn't spoken to him since the breakup Jovana's brother had always been cool, if a bit too observant. Smart guy. Sarcastic. Knew how to read people fast. When they'd all hung out, Ivica was the one always tossing little jabs that landed too close to home, the kind that made Stefan laugh and smile.

But this text was simple.

"Hey, you got a shirt here. Jovana said it's yours."

Stefan squinted. An old grey fitted tee? Maybe. He hadn't even remembered it.

"Oh yeah? That was forever ago."

"Yeah. You can come by if you want. I'm home now."

The timing was suspicious, though. He thought he would see Jovana there or something.

Stefan had been in a rough spot lately. Late payments from his freelancing gig, rent overdue, and the place he was staying felt more like a storage unit than a home. He'd been dodging calls from his landlord and browsing listings he couldn't afford. The idea of crashing on someone's couch was starting to sound like an actual solution.

So, after a minute of hesitation, he replied:

"Alright. Be there in 30 minutes or so."

Ivica's apartment was almost aggressively clean. Sleek lines, dark furniture, everything coordinated. Minimalist, yes but it felt curated. Like someone had designed it to look like no one lived there, but lived there intensely.

The smell hit him first. Not cologne more like sandalwood and spice. But there was something underneath it. Something faint.

Familiar.

Jovana's old perfume. Stefan didn't want to admit it, but he could almost hear her voice in the hallway.

Ivica opened the door with a smile that didn't reach his eyes.

"Stefan," he said warmly, stepping aside. "Come in."

He walked in, trying not to feel weird about it. He didn't know what was off, but something was.

"Thanks," he muttered.

Ivica handed him a smoothie of all things.

"Protein, banana, oats," he said. "You look like you just worked out."

Stefan raised an eyebrow. "I didn't tell you I was coming from the gym."

Ivica just smiled. "Lucky guess."

They sat. Stefan on the couch, Ivica opposite him in an armchair, legs crossed too elegantly, watching.

"Old shirt's in the bedroom," Ivica said casually. "Grey one. Tight fit. You used to wear it when we watched matches. I always remembered how it hugged your chest."

Stefan forced a chuckle. "Didn't know you paid that much attention."

"Oh, I notice things," Ivica replied, sipping his own drink. "Especially when people think I don't."

Silence settled for a beat. Stefan looked around the apartment again. The smell, the lighting it was all curated, like Ivica had been preparing for a guest.

That's when Ivica leaned back, still smiling faintly.

"You've been... busy lately."

Stefan's stomach tightened. "How do you mean?"

Ivica's gaze held his.

"That little Snap streak you've had going."

Everything in Stefan's body went still.

The smoothie suddenly tasted sour. His chest tightened.

"What?"

Ivica tilted his head slightly, voice still calm. "Jovana hasn't used her snapchat in weeks."

The words hit like a sucker punch.

Stefan's jaw clenched. "What the fuck are you saying?"

"I'm saying," Ivica replied softly, "you haven't been sexting with my sister."

Stefan stood without realizing, fists curled.

"No fuck off. That's not possible. She sent me photos. We talked about things only she would"

"She sent you porn links. Black screen Snaps. Old pictures you'd already seen. And she never sent a voice note. Did she?"

Stefan hesitated. The voice notes. No moans. No new selfies. Just... text. Porn. Snapchats with captions but no face.

It hit him all at once.

Cold washed through his skin like ice water.

"You've gotta be fucking kidding me."

Ivica stood. Calm. Quiet. He walked to the bedroom door and pushed it open.

"That shirt's in here."

Stefan followed slowly.

His heart was pounding. Not from fear yet but from confusion. Betrayal? Something darker?

The room was dim, filtered sunlight cutting through dark blinds. Neat bed. Small desk with a laptop glowing on the screen.

Stefan stepped closer.

Then stopped.

His own face stared back at him. Frozen in a video frame. Jaw slack, mouth parted, one hand wrapped around his big fat cock, the other gripping the base. A Snap message under it: "Show me how it leaks."

He scrolled.

There were dozens.

Snaps. Videos. Voice messages from him.

All archived. Saved.

From his phone.

Sent to...

Ivica.

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

The realization landed like a thunderclap. Stefan turned, eyes blazing.

"You sick fucking"

Ivica didn't flinch.

"You enjoyed every second of it."

"You tricked me," Stefan growled. "You fucking pretended to be her."

Ivica stepped forward, voice low. "No. I just played along. I just didn't tell you it was me."

Stefan's hands clenched into fists.

"I should fucking knock you out."

"But you won't," Ivica whispered. "Because you liked it. You liked being watched. You liked being told what to do. You loved the praise. Come on does it matter it wasn't Jovana but me"

Stefan's mouth opened to yell but nothing came out.

Because part of it some shameful, horny part of his brain agreed.

And Ivica saw it.

He smiled.

"You want to know why I did it?"

Stefan said nothing.

Ivica's tone dropped into something deeper closer to confession than conversation. His eyes shimmered, not with guilt, but with hunger finally being unchained.

"I've wanted your cock in my mouth since the day she showed me your first picture," he said quietly. "You think this started recently? Nah."

He took a slow breath, his voice laced with the weight of memory.

"I remember exactly how it happened. We were sitting on the couch. Just a normal night. Netflix playing something forgettable. She was tipsy, maybe a little high. Her phone buzzed, and she got this devilish grin so casual, like it was just another dirty pic. Like it was a fucking meme. She turned the screen to me and said 'Look at this dick. I swear to God it's like baby arm.'"

Ivica laughed bitterly, shaking his head.

"She laughed. I didn't. Not even a little. I couldn't."

He stepped closer to Stefan now, eyes burning with obsession.

"She passed me the phone and just went back to scrolling like it was nothing. But I couldn't stop staring. It wasn't just the size. It was how thick it was. How cocky you looked holding it. Like you knew the power it had."

He exhaled hard, eyes locked on Stefan's.

"I saved it. She left her phone unlocked that night. I sent it to myself. Then every other photo she had. The ones with you in front of the mirror. The one where you had her lipstick smeared on your balls. The video where you were stroking in the shower and moaning her name."

Ivica's voice trembled slightly now not from nerves, but from how hard he was getting just saying it all.

"I didn't care that you were her boyfriend. I didn't even care that you were straight. I started watching those videos every night. Not just jerking off. I'd replay your moans. Slow them down. Close my eyes and imagine it was me making you sound like that."

Stefan stared at him, stunned.

Ivica stepped closer.

"And every time you came over wearing those tight joggers... fuck. You'd sit on my couch, legs spread, phone in hand, completely unaware that your cock was printing a perfect outline down your thigh."

He licked his lips.

"You'd adjust it sometimes. Scratch under it. No shame. And I'd have to leave the room just so I wouldn't start drooling in front of both of you."

Stefan's face tensed, disgust and something else some tight, burning shame curling through his gut.

"I thought about it every time," Ivica said, stepping closer again, his voice now low, deliberate. "I thought about dropping to my knees while you were distracted. Pulling your waistband down. Waking you up on the couch with my throat already around your cock."

He stared right into Stefan's eyes now.

"I imagined you groggy. Still half-asleep. Groaning a little. Not even stopping me. Maybe saying Jovana's name. Maybe just grabbing my hair and fucking my face like it belonged to you."

Ivica's jaw tightened, his breath shaky.

"She used to talk about it, you know. When we were stoned late at night, just the two of us. She'd joke that no guy she ever met came close to you. She said your cock ruined her. Said she couldn't even fuck other people properly because all she thought about was how much smaller they were."

He chuckled.

"Once, we were watching porn together don't ask why, it just happened and this guy came on screen with a thick cock. She looked at me and said, 'He's close... but still not Stefan.' Like you were a fucking standard she couldn't shake."

Ivica's eyes glazed a little, lost in the memory.

"She even joked once that she didn't know who enjoyed your dick more her pussy or her throat. I laughed. But inside I was going insane. All I wanted was a chance to feel it. Taste it. Worship it the way she never really could."

He paused.

"You think this was a plan? This was survival. This was... compulsion. Every time she talked about you, it just got worse."

Then his voice dropped to a whisper.

"You weren't just some straight guy dating my sister. You were the obsession we shared. She got the body. I got the fantasy."

Ivica stepped back finally, chest rising and falling, like he'd just finished confessing to a priest.

And then he smiled dark, calm, unashamed.

"And now... I get to live what she only ever talked about."

Stefan backed up half a step, but Ivica didn't stop.

"So when she left her phone unlocked one day... I helped myself. And when she changed numbers... I used that window."

Stefan's head spun. "You're insane."

Ivica nodded, calm.

"Maybe. Or maybe I'm just... honest. I know what I want."

He stepped back, giving Stefan space. Then walked to the kitchen, grabbed his drink, and took a long sip.

Ivica circled back, voice quieter now, but sharper--more deliberate.

"You're homeless in what... a week?" he asked.

Stefan's body tensed, jaw flexing.

Ivica didn't wait for confirmation.

"I saw the eviction story on Insta. Your landlord tagged you in a rant. Something about rent being four weeks late? Told everyone you'd been ghosting his calls."

Stefan's shoulders slumped slightly. He didn't speak.

Ivica stepped closer, not smug, not gloating just... focused.

"You're fucked, Stefan. Be real about it."

Silence stretched between them.

Then Ivica dropped the hook.

"I have another apartment. Across the hall. Number twenty-two. Fully furnished. Two bedrooms. Clean. Quiet. Rent-free."

Stefan's eyes flicked up.

Ivica nodded, voice casual. "I own both. I stay in sixteen. You'd have your own space, your own key. No roommates. No drama. Just peace."

Stefan hesitated.

"...Why?"

Ivica smiled faintly.

"Because I want something in return. A favor for a favor."

Stefan's stomach turned. He didn't need to ask.

Ivica gave it to him anyway.

"Your lovely dick. No fucking. No kissing. No touching beyond that. Just your dick. My mouth."

Stefan's breath caught.

"You're kidding."

"I'm not."

"That's fucking blackmail."

Ivica shook his head calmly. "It's a trade. A clean one. You say no, you walk out. Nothing happens. I'm not leaking anything. I'm not making threats."

He paused, then softened his voice, almost sympathetic.

"But if you say yes... you get time. You get privacy. You get a real shot at writing like you've always talked about. No rent. No stress. Just your cock. In my mouth. Once in a while."

He tilted his head.

"Tell me that's not a fair exchange."

Stefan stared at him, breathing harder now. He wanted to argue. Wanted to throw something. Wanted to leave.

But deep inside, something was turning.

Something cold and heavy and honest.

He was cornered.

And the worst part?

The idea of it the simplicity, the control, the perversion wasn't as disgusting as it should've been.

He didn't say yes.

He didn't say no.

He just stood there, still, heart pounding.

And Ivica smiled. Quiet. Patient.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like