prom-night-for-the-misfit-club
FIRST TIME SEX STORIES

Prom Night For The Misfit Club

Prom Night For The Misfit Club

by jilliannes
20 min read
4.53 (9800 views)
adultfiction

(All characters are over the age of 18)

It could have been any Spring Saturday night in the early eighties, but it wasn't. This particular Saturday night was the Senior Prom, that magical moment in the journey toward adulthood where the innocence of youth masquerades under a mature veil of tuxedos, lavish dresses, and expectations for romance that often supersede whatever amorous experiences a young student might have enjoyed by that point in his or her short life.

It was a night of celebration and affirmation for the attractive, the socially outgoing, and the popular to dress up and experience new levels of adulthood pleasures, often for the very first time, while for the less confident, the shy, and for those on the fringes of the high school social structure, Prom night was an in-your-face reminder that they were the "less-than's" -- those parked outside and often ignored by the elite inside the circle. For them, it was a school-sponsored and PTA-endorsed painful confirmation that they just weren't as desirable as so many of their classmates were. For them, Prom night sucked.

But for those on the inside of the circle, Prom provided tacit permission to enjoy a night of new experiences. For those with more progressive or perhaps clueless parents, hotel-room after-parties -- usually just for two -- were commonplace. For the others, back seats and isolated parking spots would have to suffice as their private sexual playgrounds. For so many, however, Prom night would be a rite of passage, a night never to forget, a night where sexual limits would be pushed farther into adulthood than they had ever been pushed before. The Prom Committee would do its part by creating an environment of romance, sensuality, and maturity, promoting and conjuring amorous emotions and carnal desires for those in attendance. Dresses would be carefully selected to highlight the girls' physical assets, often with plunging necklines and other revealing features designed to entice the young men strutting about in their tuxedos. Undergarments for many of the young temptresses would be carefully selected to seduce, or for some, would be left at home altogether, their absence fully noticed by their horny dates. Sexual reward at the end of the evening would be pretty much a given as the hormonally charged couples would exit the warm-up of the venue and move on to the main event of the evening, where they would elevate their game with each other to levels not previously explored. All around town, tits and asses would be exposed and erect cocks would be released to the air as dresses would fall to the floorboards of cars and hotel rooms and tuxedo zippers would be lowered to give the horny girls unrestricted access to reward their equally horny dates for taking them to the Prom. For many of the more novice dry-humpers among them, fingering and hand jobs would be explored for the first time. For those farther along in their sexual journey, hand jobs would elevate to blow jobs, and for many, virginity would become a thing of the past. It would be a night of orgasms across the town -- at least for the guys. For the girls, perhaps not as much, but for nearly all of the couples, some new element of their sexual innocence would be relegated to history before they returned home, a little or a lot more experienced than they had been only hours earlier.

"I've had a crush on Steve Carlson since we were in sixth grade," Debbie lamented to her friends. "I really thought that he liked me too -- at least a little. But then he goes and asks that slut, Brenda, to Prom! Why couldn't it have been me? What's wrong with me?!?"

"Nothing's wrong with you, Debbie. He doesn't deserve someone as good you!" Debbie's best friend, Julie, tried her best to console her friend, but it really wasn't helping. "I hope he gets the clap from that bitch! She's had so many guys inside of her that she's probably totally toxic!"

"That's not a nice thing to say, Julie." Secretly, Debbie kind of liked the idea too, but she knew that thoughts like that were kind of mean. Besides, her heart was still pining for Steve, and she didn't really want anything bad to happen to him.

"At least you don't have to deal with asking a girl out and risk getting shot down -- or worse! It took me sixth months to get up the nerve to ask Judy Miller on a date and she laughed at me over the phone. And the next day at school, her friends laughed at me too!" The pain on Trent's face made it very clear that this rejection had created a core memory that he was unlikely to ever forget.

"I can't afford Prom. You know how broke I always am." It seemed to be confession time, and it was now Neil's turn. "I work two jobs but everything I make goes to my mom to pay our bills. I checked once and the cost of a tux and tickets and a corsage -- holy shit! How do people afford it? I guess when your parents have money you can, but that'll never happen for me."

"I can't see how any girl would ever want me," David said, barely audibly. "I know I'm a loser. I'm really glad that you guys are my friends, or I'd have nobody."

"Stop it, David! You're a great guy!" Debbie truly was his friend and they had grown up together almost like siblings. He had always had a bit of a crush on her, but she definitely thought of him more like a brother!

Julie's body had matured early, and she had always been very self-conscious about it. Perhaps self-loathing was a better term. Every time she looked in the mirror all she could see were flaws. Why couldn't she be perfect like the girls in the magazines, or the cheerleaders, or all the popular girls at school? In her mind, nobody would ever find her attractive enough to want her, and consequently, Julie closed herself off to any suitor that tried to win her attention, not realizing that she was actually quite beautiful, both inside and out. The guys in their little group had secretly lusted after her for years, but due to their own issues, none had risked trying for more than friendship. In an accidental way, they were confirming what she believed about herself even though nothing could be farther from the truth.

"The worst part is that we're all going off to college in the Fall, and none of us has ANY experience with dating or...sex," Debbie whispered the word, a little ashamed to be saying what she was thinking. "I was in the locker room a couple of days ago. Some of the 'popular' girls were talking about Prom and didn't know I was there. They were going on and on about what they were going to do to their boyfriends after the dance. Tammy Perkins said that she planned to give up her virginity to Brett. Tammy! Her dad would kill Brett if he knew! She acts all innocent at church, but she was going on and on about how they've done everything except fucking and she plans to change that as soon as they leave the dance. She was even telling the girls about how much she likes sucking on his cock and how he goes down on her every time they go out, whatever that means. She really has her parents fooled." Debbie paused and her gaze drifted off somewhere into the distance, her words not directed at anyone. "I want that, too!"

The basement rec-room got very quiet as the five virginal eighteen-year-olds pondered Debbie's proclamation. They had been friends since they were kids. Kind of a 'misfits club.' Debbie was a pastor's daughter, shielded from the world by her very hovering parents. Expected to be of the highest moral character, being taught from the youngest of age that any type of sexual expression was to be strictly reserved for marriage and that even the slightest inclination toward the amorous was the beginning of a slippery slope straight to ruining herself for her future husband. All of her normal human sexual urges were to be solidly suppressed until she had said her "I do's" at the altar. Debbie had learned in private, however, that a little rubbing against her pillow produced some feelings that were very, very pleasant, even though a part of her feared that she might be humping herself straight to Hell.

Julie struggled. Not just with that body image crap, but with who she really was inside and who she wanted to be. Usually, she found herself interested in the boys. But sometimes it was the girls who caught her attention. The net result for her was social paralysis, causing her to experience neither, and instead spending many restless nights staring at the ceiling while fantasizing about whichever guy or girl had caught her eye that day, and allowing the fingers of her right hand to find their way inside her panties as they provided surrogacy to her aching pussy.

Like most teenage guys, each of the three knew exactly what their cocks needed to give themselves some brief relief from their raging hormones -- often two or three times a day. Their minds were always on fire, often at the most inconvenient of times, and the release that comes from orgasm was about the only thing that could settle them down, if only for a short while. They had each experienced the embarrassment of an unwanted erection, such as when Ms. Nelson wore one of her really hot outfits to school to distract them as she taught Pre-Calc. She seemed to enjoy calling guys up to the front of the class at just the right moment, smirking subtly along with the other giggling girls as the guys tried, usually unsuccessfully, to hide the bulge protruding in the front of their pants as they walked to the chalkboard. Then there was the dreaded gym class. Pretty hard to hide those boners as they lusted at the girls while they jumped about in their skimpy T-shirts and shorts. The guys couldn't wait to get home at the end of the school day where they could finally close their bedroom doors and unload the day's frustrations into a handful of tissues. Being a teenage boy without a girlfriend sucked!

"So here we sit while everyone else at school is getting some tonight..." Again, Debbie let her words hang in the room. The guys shifted in their chairs, erotic thoughts of exactly what she might be suggesting just starting to sink in, along with more than a little terror that she might actually be serious. "My parents won't be home for hours. What if we just... explored a little...? Guys, I really want to experience some things, too! Don't you?" There was desperation in her voice, and it was clear that she wasn't kidding around.

πŸ“– Related First Time Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

And there it was. Debbie had just said out loud what each of them had fantasized about but never dreamed could actually happen. No one said a word, but the non-verbal's were flying around the room like lightning. One thing was absolutely clear -- no one really had a clue what to do next, and definitely, everyone wanted someone else to go first!

In the days before the internet, sexual images were scarce, especially for young people. Of course, the guys had all seen and jerked off to images in magazines like Playboy and Penthouse if they were ever lucky enough to get their hands on one, but beyond that, especially for the girls, they were all pretty ignorant when it came to the birds and the bees. Sex Ed class covered everything except the fun parts. They all knew about sperm and eggs and fertilization and menstrual cycles, and certainly knew all about abstinence, but the only knowledge any of them had about the pleasureful side of sex had come from overhearing chatter from the "loose" girls in the locker room or the class "studs" as they bragged and embellished about some latest conquest. In truth, they were all pretty ignorant.

Debbie took a deep breath of 'confidence' air. "Okay, full confession. I've never seen a naked guy before, and I don't want to be totally stupid when I get to college. I want to know, guys." Her voice was shaking, almost pleading for her friends to help her.

The rec-room was silent again. No one uttered a sound. Finally, Neil broke the tension. "I don't think any of us has any experience, Debbie. I've seen pictures, but I haven't seen a naked girl in real life either." Neil was more than a little self-conscious about admitting his naivetΓ©, but he knew that it was highly likely that he spoke for all three of the guys. A long pause, and then after a deep breath, "What do you want to know?"

The floodgate opened and the questions came pouring out of her. "What does a penis look like? How big is it? What direction does it point? What do balls look like? What do they feel like?" And the big one, "Remember when Mrs. Fitch taught us in health class about puberty and... ejaculation? Have you guys ever done that?" That last question stunned them all.

"Uh, sure," Neil said, and the other guys hesitantly shook their heads in agreement.

"What does it feel like? When the semen shoots out?"

"Wow! Help me out here guys!" Neil begged.

"It feels really... good?" Trent said, hesitantly. "Like a tinging in your whole body and then you feel really relaxed afterward."

"Kind of a pumping feeling," David added to the surprise of them all. "It feels really good!"

"Does a lot come out?" Julie asked.

"I don't know if it's a lot. A few squirts. Then it's done and you have to wait a little while before it can happen again." Neil couldn't believe the words coming out of his mouth.

Debbie looked directly at Julie and unspoken thoughts were exchanged. Finally turning back to the three guys, "Will you show us?"

You could have heard a pin drop.

"You... you want one of us... to jerk off for you?" Trent asked, stunned by the boldness of her request, his dick quickly swelling in his pants at the mere thought of it.

"No, I...we... want all of you to. I want to watch so that I can learn how to make it do it. Maybe we can even help you!" With that, Debbie pulled her shirt up and over her head, revealing her lacy bra to the group. "You too, Julie. It's only fair." Julie hesitated, part of her desperately wanting to run away, but a bigger part of her wanting to watch too.

"Okay. Here goes! Nobody laugh." A lifetime of body-insecurity flooding her mind, Julie took a deep breath and pulled off her top. The guys sat stunned as their penises swelled in their pants, the two sets of beautiful breasts only a bra away from being naked in front of them. None had ever seen real breasts in person before, and this time, the core memory that was forming in their minds was a very good one!

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

"We definitely aren't going to laugh at you, Julie! You're beautiful! Both of you are!" Trent said, his eyes darting between the chests of his two friends.

"Your turn, guys. Off with them!" Debbie ordered, her voice shaking a bit and her erect nipples protruding through the thin material of her bra, betraying her excitement. Moments later the guys sat bare-chested. "Now, about those pants of yours."

"Wait, wait, wait!" David said. "If we're gonna show you our dicks, you've gotta show us more than just your bras." The others nodded in fierce agreement. "If I'm gonna show you mine, I want to see what you have too."

Again, the girls looked at each other. "So, if we strip naked, you guys are gonna let us watch you cum. Promise?" Julie asked, not sure which answer she was really hoping for.

The guys looked at each other. "Deal, but you have to let us see you naked first," Trent negotiated for them all.

"Okay, on three we all get naked. One... Two... Three!" Hesitantly, bras and belts were released, pants and underwear were removed, and soon the five young adults sat before each other on the basement carpet, fully naked, three cocks pointing directly at the ceiling. It was the first time any of them had seen under the clothing of members of the opposite sex, and the first time any of the guys had seen another with an erection. The group just looked at each other for several moments. The girls' nipples were as erect as the guys cocks, and all five were a strange mix of embarrassed and enthralled.

"So that's what they look like," Julie said out loud, mostly to herself, as she and Debbie admired the guys' erections. They were all about the same size. Neil's was a little longer, Trent's was a little thicker, and David's had some curvature to it, but overall, the guys had each been blessed with a very nice, very normal penis. Having two beautiful, naked women staring at his junk was almost too much for David, and his arousal was more than evident as pre-cum began to appear at his tip, with a little dripping down the side of his erect shaft. The girls took their time admiring each of the cocks standing proudly before them, their stares unrelenting.

"Can we touch them?" Debbie asked, already knowing the answer. Reaching for Neil's, "Wow! It's really hard, but it's soft at the same time! And it's a whole lot bigger than my vagina! How is that thing supposed to fit inside me?" Debbie's finger traced up the length of Trent's shaft causing it to twitch. Both girls giggled and watched as his started to ooze pre-cum as well.

Then Julie remembered Health class. "What's that stuff? Is that what an ejaculation looks like, Trent?" she asked, totally clueless about what she was seeing.

"No. That stuff starts coming out first. It's really slippery." Julie's finger wiped the sticky droplet of pre-cum from his cock and rubbed it between her thumb and finger. Trent groaned and his cock twitched again.

For the next several minutes the girls went from cock to cock -- asking questions, touching, feeling, occasionally stroking -- and with each movement, the boys' dicks responded to their attention. Soon all three were leaking significant pre-cum and the guys were clearly becoming more and more uncomfortable in their arousal, each becoming desperate for release.

"Okay, okay...our turn," Neil commanded, hoping to check out what the girls had before his dick couldn't take any more from them. Debbie and Julie hesitantly leaned back, their legs spreading somewhat, and allowed the guys to have a look. They had made a deal, after all. "Wow!" Neil said for the guys, as each saw a real pussy up close for the first time.

"Sorry. Mine's kinda gross," Julie voiced, her negative body-image once again attacking her mind.

"Are you kidding, Julie? It's awesome!" David replied. "Both of you -- beautiful!" Again, his dick twitched and another drop of pre-cum emerged from the tip, slowly dangling as it made its way to the floor. "Can we touch you too?"

As awkward and unromantic as it was, the girls agreed, admonishing their good friends to be gentle as they slowly spread their legs wider for them. They were both very turned on from touching the guys' cocks, and their swollen labia were struggling in vain to contain their wetness. Trent's finger traced Debbie, and Neil's explored Julie. David was fascinated by their pussies as well, of course, but the four naked tits and erect nipples before him were equally arousing, and his hands just had to feel them as well. As he moved behind the girls and his hands cupped their nubile flesh, feeling their taut nipples against his fingers, his dick twitched again and continued to drip. David confirmed at that moment that he was definitely a tits-guy!

As Neil's finger gently traced her sex and David's hands massaged her tits, Julie audibly moaned. "That feels SO good! Don't stop, guys!" Neil didn't need to be asked twice. His fingers gently explored her vulva and when he brushed over her swollen nub, Julie's head fell back against David's naked chest and her entire body spasmed. "Oh yeah! Right there! Just like that! PLEASE don't stop!" she pleaded, her nipples being gently teased by one friend as her clit was rubbed in just the right way by the other. The guys obeyed and marveled at their friend as her body responded to them. Julie was on a direct path to her climax, and her hands flailed as she climbed her mountain.

Trent had heard somewhere that the clitoris was the most sensitive part of a pussy. He just had no idea what or where it was. Debbie took his hand and guided him to her prize, showing him her preferred pace and pressure. "Right there! Just keep going, okay?" Trent was a fast learner, and soon his hand was soaked by her fluids as her arousal quickly progressed. This was WAY better than humping her pillow! Soon, Debbie felt her muscles taking control of her body and she began to spasm -- HARD! At first Trent thought he had done something wrong but somehow knew to keep going. "Oh Fuuuuccckkk!!!" Debbie screamed as her first powerful orgasm given to her by another human being completely overwhelmed her senses. She shook! Liquid flowed from her body! Her skin flushed bright red! Over and over her abdomen contracted as her arms and legs flailed about. Finally, just as she thought she might pass out from pleasure, her right hand instinctively pushed Trent's fingers away, and she fell back on the floor in front of her friends, her body occasionally jerking as she came back down to Earth, splayed out before them with her sopping vulva still fully on display.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like