He gave Tony's cock a squeeze and whispered back, "I want you inside me, Tony". Tony pretended not to hear and it didn't take long for Dom to catch the hint. He gave Tony an innocent, pleading look and said, "Fuck me, Tony. Please...I need this," while giving Tony's cock another squeeze with his hand. Satisfied with his answer and sufficiently turned on, Tony grabbed the lube bottle as Craig threw him a condom. He eased the condom over his cockhead and rolled it down before lubing his cock well. Tony lay on the bed holding his cock so it was pointing straight up and gestured to Dom to join him. Nervously, Dom moved down to sit on Tony's mid-section, feeling Tony's cock lining up in the cleft of his ass cheeks.
Tony brought Dom's head down to his level and lightly kissed him, "Are you sure you want this? It's not too late to back out if you want." Dom appreciated the offer but eagerly gave his consent. "Remember you're in charge, take your time and keep breathing." Dom sat up slightly and saw Craig move in to help behind him. He felt the head of Tony's cock tap at his asshole and Craig placed a hand on his ass to encourage him down onto it. Dom got into a regular breathing pattern and then bore down, impaling himself on Tony's cock. He winced at the slight pain of it starting to open him up. Much like Craig had done with his fingers earlier, he waited until every out-breath to flex his ass muscles and take it even further. "Fuck, you're so tight," Tony said as he felt Dom's ass clamp down on him.
Dom moved back up until Tony's cock popped out of his ass. After taking a brief rest, Craig lined it up again and it plunged back into Dom's hole, going even deeper this time. It wasn't long until Dom was working the head in a steady rhythm and looking deep into Tony's lustful eyes. "How does it feel, Dom?" Tony asked. Dom couldn't even reply, just whimpering as his body got used to a new kind of pleasure. Craig moved up towards the head of the bed and made out with Dom in-between his moans. Tony wrapped a hand round Craig's ass and pulled him closer. Already overwhelmed, Dom felt even more turned on at the sight of Tony sucking on Craig's cock. He could've sworn his horniness made his hole open to accept more of Tony inside him.
Tony removed Craig's cock from his mouth and tapped Dom to give him the signal to move. As he could tell Dom was getting used to anal, he lightly pushed Dom over until he lay on his back with his head slightly over the edge of the bed. Tony re-lubed his cock, placed Dom's legs either side of him and pushed his cock back into Dom's ass so they were fucking missionary. Tony's sudden forceful entrance made him gasp but he quickly focused back on his breathing. He felt Tony's hands grab his hips and he felt a prickle of hair against his ass which told him he was nearly taking it all. Craig stood at the edge of the bed until his cock was hanging ominously over Dom's head. He brought it tantalizingly close to Dom's mouth and felt Dom's tongue just about touch the underside of his shaft. He finally relented and let Dom suck on his cockhead, with Dom's gentle moans sending vibrations up it.
Tony's breathing had started to become more laboured and Craig realised he was getting tired. After a few more minutes of fucking, Tony took his cock out of Dom completely and spread his legs to see his asshole gape slightly. "Is it my turn?" Craig asked. Both Tony and Dom agreed and Craig did his best Mad Hatter impression yelling out, "Change places!" It made Dom giggle with laughter. Craig rolled a condom over his cock and lubed it up, eager to try out Dom's ass. He suggested they change to doggy style so he could have a clear view of Dom's ass swallowing his cock. Dom flipped over onto all fours and presented himself to Craig as Tony moved off the bed. Craig's slick cock started nuzzling against the hole and he was surprised to see Dom try and back up on it already. "Easy, tiger," Craig chuckled.
Dom felt the cockhead slip into his hole and instantly felt the difference in size between him and Tony. Dom grimaced as he felt his ass stretching to accommodate Craig's girth. Tony found a seat in a nearby chair while recovering but he still offered words of encouragement, "Mm, I bet you can feel that. It might take you a while to get used to it but you can take it." Tony whipped his condom off and started jerking off at the scene. A deep growl left Dom's lips as Craig pushed himself in further and started to fuck Dom's ass. He could hear Dom was struggling so he slowed down into shorter strokes until he was accustomed to it.
Once he had recovered a bit, Tony moved back to sit near the head of the bed and Dom readily started sucking on his cock. Craig's strokes started to become deeper again which pushed the cock further into Dom's mouth. Tony quickly became more vocal as he felt that familiar building feeling, "Fuck, I'm gonna cum." As Dom greedily took more of the cock, Tony started to grunt louder and louder until his cock finally exploded in Dom's mouth, coating it with cum. He watched as a few white dribbles slipped out and ran down Dom's face. Tony's cock finished pulsing and he laughed, "You know, you're getting pretty good at that." Dom licked until he'd hoovered up most of the cum and swallowed it.
Tony saw Dom's eyes roll back into his head as Craig started hitting it hard from the back. Without warning, one of the jolts from behind knocked him off balance and his chest fell to the bed. Craig took the opportunity to move forward until his chest made contact with Dom's back. Tony moved away from the bed and saw Craig's ass jiggling as he ferociously forced his cock in and out of Dom's hole. Dom's hard cock was now trapped between his body and the bed. "Oh, shit!" he cried as his cock started spurting onto the bedsheet below. His orgasm made his asshole tighten which was too much for Craig. Craig flung an arm around Dom's neck, held him close and groaned as he bottomed out inside him. He could feel himself throb as cum left his cock. It took a minute or so before Craig was ready to move and his spent cock slipped out of Dom's ass.
Dom lay there recovering for a minute with a contented grin on his face. After he'd caught his breath back, he shuffled to the bathroom to clean himself up. He came back in the room and they shared a three-way hug. "Thank you so much, guys. That was...unreal," Dom said gratefully. He looked over at the clock near the TV to see it wasn't long until he needed to check out. "Fuck, I need to dash." He quickly dressed himself and gave them both a goodbye kiss. As he reached the door, Craig stopped him. He rummaged around in a bag to find one of his business cards. "Take this," Craig said. "If you're ever in the area, feel free to stop by our place...we'd love to have you." With that, Dom thanked them both again and headed out the door.