A Twin in Plain Sight - Sebastian

Just some time ago a Kathrine ran into me in the gym with Luke. She stood us side by side that day. She saw it, she saw that I was a physical copy of him. She compared, touched and laughed.

Suggested what fun we could have with David (Lukes' partner) if we'd blindfold him, sad that there was no way she could have that fun with us now that she'd noticed. Not that Luke would have agreed anyway.

He and I even sounded the same, just different accents, one british, the other australian-ukrainian.

And then we saw it as well, only the skin, eye and hair colours, tattoos and beards were different, otherwise physically we were almost identical. We'd been friends for a year or so and we'd never noticed. We were like interracial twins.

We laughed and imagined how puzzled David would be. Even though he worked together with me, we both doubted that he had noticed the similarities, because at the same time Luke and I were so different.

But I wasn't really interested in men, yes I fucked them, but it was rather domination that did it for me and not at all that they were men. And Luke appreciated a rather conservative lifestyle, so Kaths grand plan was put to the shelf.

Luke wanted to see me one day months later, inviting me to his place. We often worked out together or just hung out, but that day seemed out of the ordinary.

We sat down in the living room of their townhouse, David was working that day and Luke served me whiskey at noon - something had to be up, he never day drinked. And we always had a reason to meet, we never 'just hung'.

"So Seb, I realise this is out of the ordinary." He said sitting across from me and I cracked a good laugh.

It was like having a real elephant in the room and he'd be pointing at it saying that there's an elephant in the room. Oh you don't say? "Did someone die? Do you need help hiding a body?" I laughed.

He laughed with me before setting his glass down and tried to make a serious face "You know I really don't appreciate the lifestyle you live." he said without a hint of his recent laugh.

"I do, but if this is an intervention, then you're not really good at it."

"No, uhm, it's just that David... he has some taste for it, fantasies and so. At one point I'm going to have to compromise."

"I really am not the one to go to for relationship advice."

"No, you definitely aren't. But Kath has a point, we could use our unmistakable similarities to toy around with David. Nothing too wild, just blindfold him and let him guess."

"You want me to fuck the man of your life? Together with you? Me?"

"Yes, that was the idea."

"You do realise that I'm straight, right? And remember who I am?"

"You fucking John every other night sounds very straight indeed."

"You know fucking well, that it's not like that and we are not talking about it."

"Sure, fine, I don't care what you do with them, I'm sure Kathrine's been up to weirder things than sharing her husband with you, but seriously - I want to give David what he wants."

We agreed to surprise David one night after work. Luke would blindfold him as he got home and then we'd let our fantasy run wild.

It was one unsuspectable thursday night. He got home as early as thursdays allowed and Luke greeted him in the hallway, telling him he's got a surprise for him and blindfolded him.

He stepped back and gestured me to join them. We wore the same type of clothes and both had trimmed our beards to the same length. The only things that could betrayed me were the scars on my face and we both hoped he would hopefully skip over them.

We touched him together, running our hands over his torso and touched his face.

He followed both hands, discovering that they came from different bodies. "Luke?" he questioned.

"Which one?" Luke asked back.

"Yes, which one?" I asked mimicking Lukes soft british accent.

David grinned wide and stepped closer to touch our bodies. He glided his hands over every possible part of our bodies, comparing and wondering. He traced our beards, trailing over the lips, felt our hands and torsos, our butts and penises, thighs and balls.

He shook his head, his grin not fading. "I don't know..."

"Surely you can recognise me?" I said, sounding as Luke like as I could.

"Did you clone yourself?" he asked, still running hands over us.

"Try now." I said as I moved in and kissed him, giving the kiss over to Luke.

"Oh god, what is this sorcery?" David asked as the kisses only confused him more. And how aroused he was...

They'd been together for five years now and he couldn't pick his partner out blind.

We kissed him back and forth, sripping him fully. He was already dripping precum from his fully erect penis. David was a seriously slender guy, all work out he did in his life was sex and holding a wine bottle, if you don't count playing the double bass.

"Kneel." Luke instructed him and we poked our manhoods in his face.

"Which one?" I asked him again and he took us in his mouth one by one, feeling us up with his tongue and lips. He sucked us constantly swapping our dicks, unable to figure out his man.

"I don't know..." he said again, kneeling with his face between our penises.

"Five years David." Luke said mockingly.

"And you can't recognise me?" I teased. God I loved this.

"Luke, I... How? Who?" David asked, shaking his head, a playful grin on his face..

We laughed in unison and pulled him up.

I tied his hands behind him and we guided him to the couch, with his ass up in the air and face on the seat. Luke positioned himself under his head and made him swallow him as I lubed up his ass and fucked him.

Luke came fast in his mouth, letting his head rest on his lap.

David moaned and whimpered under me and I swapped myself to his mouth feeling close to cumming and gave his ass to Luke.

We swapped, fucked him and came in his mouth again and again. Prompting him to guess which one Luke is every time.

He couldn't tell.

We moved ourselves to the bedroom, laying David on the bed, his tied up arms under him.

We took turns fucking him, stroking him at the same time. Few times Luke took him in his mouth as I fucked him. We made him cum on his stomach, milking him to the last drop every time.

He cried and whimpered non-stop, begging us to tell him who I was, but we just kissed him one by one and kept him guessing.

After his third orgasm, he was crying of real agony and we stopped torturing him. We flipped him around and untied his arms.

Turning him back Luke asked "Ready?" tugging his fingers under Davids blindfold.

"Please, yes please." he begged.

His face was priceless as the blindfold came off. Luke and I laughed our hearts out.

David immediately covered his face with his hands. "Holy! Oh my! Oh lord! No, no, no..." and peeked from between his hands at me, "How did I not see this?! You of all the... Oh my!"

"Oh, David, David, David..." I teased as I couldn't stop laughing.

"Luke, Sebastian?!" He exclaimed.

"Complaining?" Luke raised his eyebrow at him.

"Hell no! God... How?"

"Alright, Luke have fun explaining this, I have a life to get back to." I said getting up and redressing myself. David just looked back and forth between us two with wide eyes and the two of us kept on laughing.

"David, this doesn't change anything between us." I declared as I exited.