An Unexpected Hoo Up

"Oh fuck Eddie yes!!! I fucking love your cock!" Sarah screamed out while pushing her slender body against my hard cock. The small dorm room was filled with the sounds and smells of our hour long fuck session. Sarah was probably one of the most vocal partners I'd ever had. Her moans and the way she called out my name always drove me crazy. And, normally it was enough. Normally the way she pushed back against my cock while bent over on the small bed and her ass raised for me was enough.

Tonight though, was different. Tonight I couldn't stop thinking about the red head I was with the night before. The way he tasted. The way his cock filled me up and satisfied me.

It didn't seem like Sarah could tell anything had changed. We weren't dating, but up until now we had been fairly exclusive. Up until now I hadn't thought of anyone else when my cum exploded into the condom.

I collapsed on top of her breathing heavily with my shrinking cock still inside her. My arms wrap around her and hold her close. She lets out a contented sigh. "I've been needing this all day." She finally says. "I ended up getting myself off when I got back last night."

"yeah, me too... I guess we still got to bed faster that way." I answer, too embarrassed to tell her what actually happened last night. i really didn't think she would judge, she introduced me to Allen after all. Yet until I had time to process everything, it seemed best to hide it.

Sarah rolled away from me with a groan when my now mostly flaccid cock slid out of her. Then I got a full view of the brunette's flawless nude body as she walked to the bathroom.

I roll on my back and think about relationships. Sarah had been the best thing about college so far I realized. It was nearly a perfect relationship of supportive studying and matched sexual energy. I would hate to lose it..., but Allen. He was really something. We'd texted and continued to flirt all day. I needed to know where it would go.

I sit up on the edge of the bed. The clock said it was nearly midnight. Sarah comes back in pulls out the oversized shirt she normally slept in. "I'm going back home for the weekend by the way, I don't think I told you."

I answer that she hadn't. "So I'll have to kick you out since imp leaving early but I'll see you Monday?"

I get up and stretch before getting dressed. "Deal, I can't wait" I say truthfully while giving her a hug.

She hugs me back tightly and gives me a soft sweet kiss. "Me either... I'll miss you." She says and then pauses as though there's more she wants to say.

"I'll miss you too." I say before kissing her and leaving the dorm feeling guiltier than i should have.

While walking back to my building I pull out my phone and see a snap from Allen. It's a shirtless mirror selfie saying. "About to shower, wanna join?" I grin at the screen. It had been about an hour since he had sent it to me.

I send back a text. "Sorry, I was hanging out with Sarah." Somehow that makes me feel even more guilty.

"It's cool, you can still come over and watch a movie or something if you want or it's cool if not." He replies.

I mull over my options while my feet subconsciously head me towards his building instead of mine. "Only if we can cuddle." I send back.

"That's a Texas Sized 10-4" He sends referencing a line from Letterkenny that makes me grin even harder.

It doesn't take long to make the walk to his dorm. Before I know it I'm knocking softly on his door. Which he quickly opens.

i step inside and he gives me a hug and a kiss. It all feels much more relaxed than the impassioned night before. "I'm a little nerdy and the new Star Wars movie is streaming now, which the new knew suck so and I don't know if you're into that or not." He says blushing in a way that perfectly accents his red curls.

I laugh a little a sit next to him on the bed. "I'm a huge nerd too, so it's definitely cool with me!" I say grinning.

"I knew there was a reason I liked you!" He says still smiling. He starts the movie and we lay down next to each other. His left arm drapes around my shoulders and my right hand drifts over to his thigh while we continue to chat about the finer aspects of Sci-Fi.

Finally he asks something we'd avoided before. "So... are you and Sarah like a thing?"

I cringe a little and turn to meet his pretty blue eyes. "Not really... we just sorta hang out but we hook up occasionally." I answer truthfully. "We agreed we weren't looking for a relationship so its casual." I say blushing and feeling embarrassed and guilty all over again. I had sex with her less than an hour ago and here I am explaining the dynamics in someone else's bed.

He nods. "That's cool... I didn't take think so, she just... we hooked up a few times last year and I always liked her so I wanted to make sure she didn't get hurt." He says sounding protective.

It actually warns my heart a little and i give his leg a squeeze. "She's really something, I haven't told her about us yet... but I think... I just want to see where this goes."

He nods again. "I do too, no pressure or anything." He says while moving his face closer.

"No pressure except when i said i wanted it every night?" I agree moving my face closer and my hand further up his thigh.

"Exactly." His lips meet mine. At first its sweet like when I first entered the dorm, but then it gets hungrier. Desperate even.

His right hand cups my face while his lips devour mine. My hand moves up to his bare chest and then slides down again. I'm still nervous but more sure now than when we first hooked up.

His lips move away from mine and start to explore my neck. My hand slides back down from his chest to the hard tent at the front of his pajama bottoms eliciting a groan from the redhead.

I shift over to straddle his lap while pulling my shirt off and throwing it on the floor. "So fucking sexy." He says while leaning in to kiss my chest and then suck my nipple.

Its my turn to moan. "Fuck its crazy how turned on you make me" I say truthfully while reaching between us to stroke his cock. My hand sliding in the waistband to grasp his hard rod. "I want to taste you." I tell him.

He grins up at my newfound confidence. "Do it baby." He says then lifts his hips to help me slide his pants down.

I take it slow. I'd never sucked a duck before but I'd eaten girls out and I knew what I liked on the receiving end.

I kiss his stomach and then make a trail to his waist. Slowly teasing around before looking up at him and dragging my tongue from his balls up to his shaft. Then around the tip where I get my first taste of precum. I savor the salty flavor of his leaking fluid before taking a deep breath and wrapping my lips around his dick and moving downwards.

I make it close to halfway before I feel myself start to gag and have to come up coughing. Allen immediately reaches out and strokes the back of my head. "You got this babe, it's hard the first time." He says reassuring me.

I go down again and try to relax my throat. I'm able to take him further this time and I'm rewarded with the sounds of him moaning. "That's it baby, fuck you're a good little cock sucker." He moans while I bob my head on his large member. Each time I push down just a little further than before.

Soon I start to really find my rhythm and the sounds of his moans increase in intensity. "Baby I'm gonna cum." He warns me.

I'm ready, I can do this. I think reassuring myself. I don't slow down. Instead I reach with one hand to grasp the base of his cock and stroke him below my mouth. I hadn't realized before then just how much drool had dripped out.

Then I feel him brace and moan out again. My hand continues to jerk him off while my mouth moves back up. My mouth is soon filled with the thick salty flavor of another man's cum. I'm instantly addicted to the flavor and swallow every drop as fast as I can.

When it finally ends, I look up at Allen and grin. He immediately cups my face and rubs a stray drop of cum off my chin with his thumb. "You missed a spot" he says chuckling before pulling me in for another deep kiss.

"I'll get it all next time." I say chuckling back before giving him another kiss and laying happily next to him.

"I can't wait." He says while kissing my forehead and wrapping his arms around me.

It's very late by that point and we both soon fall asleep holding each other throughout the night.

The next morning we both wake up early enough for round two. Or at least I wake up to the feeling of his tongue in my ass. Which is quickly followed by his cock. While I lay on my stomach with my ass pushed up, I'm struck by the thought that less than twelve hours ago I had Sarah in the same position. Only Allen doesn't have a condom and I take the third load from him after only meeting him a few days before.

After that we took our time getting dressed and head to the dining hall together. It feels natural walking with him with his cum still dripping out of my freshly used ass. Our hands drift towards each other and I blush a little as our fingers intertwine. I'm still not ready for people to know about this but It's early enough that I'm not worried about anyone seeing.

At least until... "Eddie?.. Allen?! What the fuck?!" We both snap around instantly to see Sarah standing there looking aghast.