One Saturday afternoon, I got an IM from a guy who was new on internet hookup sites. He said that he was newly divorced, about my age and a total bottom. We chatted a bit and he told me that even though he'd been fucked in the past, he had an unfulfilled fantasy for a totally anonymous scene where he was on his bed blindfolded and someone came into the room, climbed on top, fucked his ass into oblivion and then dressed and left without ever talking or introducing themselves. I told him to get naked and get blindfolded...I'd be right over.
He gave me directions and half an hour later, I was entering his unlocked front door. All of the blinds were drawn so the house was semi-dark and I followed his instructions through the house to his bedroom. I opened the bedroom door and there he was, on the bed with a single candle lit beside.
He was a small guy, only around five feet or so with a slim, boyish body. He had a scarf tied around his head so that his eyes were fully covered and was laying face down with a couple of pillows under his hips so that his ass was raised and spread. And WHAT an ass! Nice plump, rounded buns (he'd told me that he was a daily jogger) and a hairless crack with a tight, pink puckered hole.
I stripped off my clothes and climbed between his spread legs. His whole body jerked as I rubbed my cock head up and down his crack and pumped the dry head against his hole. He spread his legs even further so his ass spread open and I lay down on top of his back and dry humped my cock in his crack. He pressed his ass back against me, wanting fucked like a bitch in heat.
Instead, I swung around to the head of the bed and grabbed him by the hair. Pulling his head back I sat on the pillows facing him and rammed my hard cock into his mouth. He was bobbing his mouth on my cock and I used my handful of his hair as a handle to guide his head up and down on my cock. The hair pulling was turning him on and he started throating my dick even faster and I could feel his tongue sliding over my shaft. It felt fantastic...even TOO good, and I was afraid that much more and I'd be shooting my load down his throat so I pulled his head off of my dick and rammed my balls in his face. He immediately started licking them, then sucked my loose sack and popped each of my big balls into his mouth. He had a real mouthful but knew just what he was doing. His tongue moved back and forth over my balls as he lightly chewed on them, then pulled his head back and extended the sack so my balls were pulled tight in his mouth and away from my crotch. Slowly, he let each ball slide out of his mouth ...I thought I was going to cum right then from the sensation!
My legs were already over his shoulders and he continued licking my balls, slowly working lower till he was tonguing my asshole. He reached up and spread my cheeks wide so that he could lick my hairy crack and sink his tongue into my hole. He was loving it, eating my ass like a starving man and sticking his tongue as far as he could up my hole. I loved it, too, but I was really anxious to slide my cock up his ass.
I pulled his face out of my ass and climbed back down between his legs. He reached over to the night stand and handed back a jar of good ole Vaseline, the ass fucker's friend! I slathered a good load over my hard cock and positioned my cock head against his asshole. I didn't even need to slide it in...as soon as he felt it in position, he started raising his hips and sucking my cock into his hot, tight hole. He was the kind of bottom who loves sucking cock, loves eating ass but ADORES having his ass fucked! He pumped his hole up and down my shaft and I could feel him flexing his ass muscles, grasping my cock tight in his hole each time he slid back to take the length balls deep in his guts.
I grabbed his hips and pulled him up into doggy style position and started hammering his hole with my cock. He was groaning and moaning, lost in the sensation of my dick sliding in and out of his ass. I could look down and watch as my dick disappeared in his hole and then slid back out into view and I could see his hole tense around the shaft each time I started the slide back in. His hole felt like hot velvet riding over my hard cock and, needless to say, I couldn't last long.
When I started getting close, I pistoned my cock in his ass as hard as I could and he slammed back against me to get every inch inside of him. I could feel my balls drawing up and then the cum spurting out of my piss hole into his ass. He pressed back and clamped his guts around my cock like a vise grip and I could feel his hole working, drawing every drop out of my balls and into his tight ass.
I pushed him flat on the bed and lay on top of him, letting my cock go soft inside his ass and marinate in the juices. When I slowly pulled it out of his hole, the head came out of him with a pop like a champagne cork from the built up suction inside his ass.
Never having said a word to each other, I climbed off the bed and dressed, let myself out and drove home. I kept thinking of how I'd last seen him, laying on the bed face down with his blindfold still in place, his well fucked ass raised and spread with Vaseline and cum dripping out of his hole. As soon as I got home, I messaged him to tell him what a fine, fuckable ass he had and to ask if he was into 3 ways. His answer was, "Of course!" and we made arrangements to get together again the next weekend with a 3rd party.
That week I talked to Paul, my anonymous fuck hole, about our 3way planned for the weekend. I already had the perfect 3rd lined up. Tim was a guy who I had been fucking for about the past year. He identified himself as straight but was open to just about anything sexually. He was extremely shy, owing to having been in a car wreck that left his face badly scarred.
He worked in a foundry and had a tight little muscular body with a nice fat 7 inch dick with big loose balls and a cute little hairless ass. He knew that his scars didn't faze me, since I spent most of our time together with my tongue buried in his asshole! We'd even developed a standard routine-he'd meet me at the door nude, I'd come in and sit down and he'd turn his back to me and touch his toes to present his ass for eating.
After tonguing his hole to my heart's content, we'd proceed to the bedroom where he's sit on my face while sucking my cock, and then I'd fuck his ass and finally flip him over and suck him off. He was really hot sex and always blew a big load of cum down my throat. We'd been discussing the fact that he'd never had a 3way or fucked a guy's ass and the idea of a masked bottom that couldn't see his scars really appealed to him.
I picked Tim up that Saturday and took him to Paul's place. When we got there, Paul was face down on the bed as last time, his ass in the air and a blindfold over his eyes. Tim couldn't take his eyes off of that welcoming ass and I went over and pulled Paul's cheeks wide to show him the puckered hole.
"This is for you." I said. "You can fuck it for as long as you want!"