I shyly, but also determinedly, perused the dildos and sized up what I should get. I also noticed a few older guys that seemed to be wandering and looking at nothing specific in the store. They would walk by me slowly, and I didn't realize at the time they were trying to pick me up in some way. I had no interest in them. (That would change another time in the store.) A few more minutes there and all the sex stuff was arousing me. I wanted to go back to Glen as my cock started up and I felt my inner cheeks start to get wet with excitement.
In order to not show the small tent in my jeans, I quickly decided to buy a 7-inch dildo that was 1.25 inches wide at the head, with no balls or suction cup -- my first dildo! I thought it looked like a good size, and definitely bigger than me, but it seemed to be the most popular size they had; what did I know about dildo size and my backdoor? I went to pay and made stupid small talk to the clerk, like I was buying a gag gift for a bachelorette party or something. I'm sure he didn't care, and I was just talking out of nervousness. I hid the dildo in a bag in my car trunk's wheel well, went home, and waited to try it out during the next week.
Mid-week arrived, and I was on my way home from a break in my class schedule when my thoughts of using the dildo caused my ass to heat up. It was time to try the dildo! By the time I got home I was sporting a chubby and got fully hard getting the items from the trunk. I got into the apartment, grabbed the KY I had stashed, some paper towels, and almost ran to the bathroom to unwrap my new toy. It smelled weird so I washed it off and started to jack it like my own cock. This jacking had an unexpected effect on me, making me want to jack off Glen. But it was the pre-cum making my boxers damp that brought me back to what I wanted to do with that robust rubber penis.
I put down a layer of paper towels on the floor next to the tub, undressed completely, and sat down on the towels with my back against the tub. Not thinking of prepping my hole, I put some KY on the dildo, which looked huge, and lined it up to my hole. I hurriedly tried to push it in, but it wasn't going. Then I tried wiggling it, which felt great on the outside, and still no luck with some stretching and throbbing pain appearing; not unbearable though. God, I wanted it badly and didn't have the patience, but had to succumb to what my body was telling me. I set the dildo aside and lubed my fingers.
First finger went in with no problem due to the KY and my now flowing ass lube. I only went in about an inch and I noticed I was tighter than the previous week. After a few minutes of relaxed fingering, I snuck a second finger in with relative ease, but with a bit of anal ring tautness. A few more minutes of flicking my two fingers back and forth, my hole relaxed enough for me to try a third finger. This was a bit tight as well but after a minute I was so worked up that my natural lube was causing some squishing sounds and making it much easier for my three fingers to pump away in and out of my hole. I also didn't feel the stretching of my first anal ring, and the internal ring was also giving way. I sat up on my three fingers and felt past the internal ring and that really got me going! I started to rock back and forth on my fingers while my dick bounced helplessly in time. Holy shit, what a feeling I had going. I had to try the dildo again!
I again lubed up the dildo with lots of KY and scooped some of my leaked ass lube to slater it on my rubber friend and my hole. I leaned back against the tub and lined up the dildo with my hole and the head slipped in, with little pressure, stretching my outer ring. This caused my inside ring to constrict, and I stayed this way trying to breathe through the stretch. This was the largest, most solid thing I had inserted but somehow knew I could take more if I relaxed.
"This position may not be working," I thought and got the idea to squat over it. I rose on my knees, my rock-hard dick pointing straight up against my belly, and lowered myself to hover over the dildo. I lined it up and steadied it with one hand while I lowered myself to the point where I felt it at my hole. I used my hand to wiggle it back and forth over my hole sending new feelings radiating from my back entrance to my insides. The dildo just didn't want to go in. I tried to try to wedge it in which helped, and it slipped about a half inch beyond the entrance. After a couple more gyrations of my hips, the head slipped in, and I felt a comfortable tightness. I stayed in that position for a minute or so and started to relax and feel the new hugging of this solid object. I started to breath more slowly and the rubber cock seemed to start getting sucked into me! But this also hurt, and I had the urge to push out the invader. As I pushed out and the dildo started to come out, I shifted and missed sitting on my heels evenly.
HOLY SHIT - I basically sat down on my haunches and I felt the cock thump pass my internal ring as it slid in about 3 inches. Instantly it felt great, and I laughed with pleasure as it slid in, but I stopped the next half-second when my anus constricted and there was a throbbing pain. I stopped and tried to bear through it and did so for a few seconds before I started to rise off it. Raising off the dildo didn't feel as good, but my ass wanted it out quickly! As it exited and fell bouncing onto the floor, my violated hole started constricting and opening on its own. If I pushed out it felt better, but when I let it constrict, it throbbed in a bit of pain.
I started to massage my hole with my fingers adding KY to the mix of my anal lube to pet myself and rub my sore hole. This felt good even though my hole was on fire. I still wanted the fake dick in me and was so focused on jamming it in that my dick had gone limp and shrunk to its "cold" position. The massaging of my hole made it feel better and I checked for blood and there was none. Whew! I decided to end this session and distract myself for a while. I partially cleaned up and started doing some homework. A couple hours later, with a lot of time before Susie got home, I felt I could try again.
I returned to the bathroom and sat once again with back against the tub. I really wanted the dildo in me and was going to take my time so it would work. My horniness wasn't going to be stopped from some of the pain I felt a couple hours before. I prepped the dildo with KY and stuck a couple fingers into my already slick hole to get some anal lube. There was just enough to spread on my hole and the dildo.
This time, my ass seemed very sensitive and slightly more open as I was able to start with two fingers, and a part of a third going in me. This looked so hot as looked over my dick and watched my fingers disappear into me, over and over. My hole started to open on its own like it was trying to suck on my fingers. I obliged to get all 3.5 inches of fingers into me without issue. I started attacking my hole with abandon with that sloppy sound turning me on and causing a frothy mess on my ass. I was so turned on my dick sprang to life and started leaking after a minute or so. The paper towel under me became soaked with lube and juice. I almost forgot about the dildo when I grabbed my cock with the other hand and started stroking while my fingers were pumping my willing ass. I leaned forward again and sat on my fingers and this time, with no pain, I tried to wiggle them inside. Wow, I was able to move them around with no pain and yet had new feelings that weren't great, but still felt naughty!
Pulling my fingers out I focused on stroking myself to completion adding the lube mixture to my cock for slickness. I paused a moment and sat back against the tub and grabbed the dildo lying next to me. With my hole already open as if it was waiting to receive something, I lined up the dildo to my hole once again and it slid easily in about four inches before it was halted by a constriction. I was so hot, flushed, and aroused at the sight of this rubber dick entering me that far that I let go of it and stroked my dick twice before it hit me like a brick - slam! There was no build up, I just started to shoot cum onto my chest and my shoulder. I closed my eyes as my sphincter contracted around the dildo with each pulse of my surprising orgasm. I stopped everything while the orgasm seemed to go on and on. I wanted all these feelings in my cock and my ass to never stop. I started seeing flashes of sparks through my closed eyelids while my mouth was open with a breathy groan that wouldn't stop. Though my orgasm seemed to be a bit stunted with my hole open around the dildo, I had never experienced an orgasm with what felt like a small log that was stuck between my insides and the outside world. I felt each pulse around my ass hole as my dick twitched. After the orgasm stopped and I calmed down, I wanted to cum again but needed to regain my senses first.