It started out with the two of us having a laugh. I showed Reece some photos on my phone of our mates doing stupid shit with their cocks out and he said we should go one better and pretend like we were doing gay stuff.
So that's how it started and it seemed really funny at the time. Grabbing each other's wangers in the first few shots and then making it look like we were sucking each other off. After we'd creased up laughing at all those, he said I should stand behind him and act like I was knobbing his arse.
That turned out to be priceless.
He had the back of his trousers and keks pulled down and was bending forwards with my rod pushed into his butt-cheeks.
If you'd seen it, I swear you'd have pissed yourself laughing.
"Trouble is though, Jordan, your dick's too limp," Reece had said. "You need to get it bigger to make it look more real."
So I'd had to wazz off a bit before we'd taken the next photo to get my knob a bit harder and it had seemed kind of weird to be rubbing my prick in front of a mate. But Reece had just made some joke like, "I knew you was a wanker," or something, and I'd pretended I thought it was funny while I was stood there feeling like a total retard, my fist slapping up and down on my pecker and my bollocks jiggling around.
When I had a semi that was big enough, he turned around and bent forwards a bit.
"Shove it between my cheeks this time. It's gotta be believable."
I pulled the skin of my cock right back so I could slide the red part into his butt-crack and I was surprised at how nice it felt once it was in there.
I know that sounds gay, but it did.
I mean, his arse crack was hairy which felt kind of nasty at first, but his cheeks were warm and sort of gripped my helmet, so my dick grew a bit bigger just from where I was pushing it.
"Lower down, you dumb-head!" he called out.
"What d'ya mean, lower down?"
"You've got to push it in lower down, Jordan. Where my hole is."
"I'm not pushing it down there, you div."
I'd noticed he had a few skid-marks on his undies. I didn't want my knob-end anywhere near those had come from.
"Come on, it isn't gonna look like your bodging me if your todger isn't in the right place."
I moved it a bit lower, hoping not to go too close to his pooper, and again I was surprised at how good it felt. Now it wasn't just warm and tight, it was a bit slippery too. I felt my cock getting harder at the feel of where it was and he laughed and pushed back against me: "Yeah, that's it, push it right in!"
I snapped a few photos of us stood like that, the two of us grinning like total planks with my prick pushed into his arse-crack. We fell about when we saw them - Jeez, it looked like we were a right pair of bum-boys - but then Reece said we shouldn't be smiling in the photos, but should look like we were gasping and about to cum.
"And you need to push your cock into me further," he went on. "You can see your bell-end in that shot - it's obvious you're nowhere near actually bumming me."
"It's only supposed to be joke, Reece."
"Yeah, but to be funny it's gotta be convincing," he insisted. "It can't be obvious we're just messing about."
He squatted further forwards and shoved his arse back towards me.
"Go on, push it further in, Jordan. So you can't see your jeb-end."
"I'm not gonna shove my dick inside your butt-hole, Reece," I said. "It'll be fucking well shitty!"
"Come on, mate, it's not like I'm asking you to get proper gay with me," he chuckled, "Just another half inch should do it!"
I did as he wanted me to but by now my rod was getting pretty stiff and when he pushed back against me I could swear the end of it slid inside his hole. It felt hot and really wet and I could feel his brown ring squeezing around my red-end.
I could smell it too: smell his slimy arse as it opened up to take my cock. Not a shitty smell, well not really; just kind of raunchy like a pair of boxers get when you've worn them for a few days and the back of them's gone a bit skanky.
I took a few more photos and we pretended like we were in sexual ecstasy or some shit. Making faces like the two of us were horny for each other, both of us well into it and ready to spunk off at any second. And all the time he kept pushing back against me, so that the hot wetness around my bell-end was slowly working down more and more of my shaft.
At one point I said, "You do know I'm bodging you for real, Reece, don't you?"
But he got really pissed off and shouted, "Fuck off, Jordan! Like hell you are! I mean, fucking hell, are either of us queer or something?"
"Of course we're not!" I tried to laugh.
"Well, we can't be proper bodging then, can we? Only queer fellas do that kind of stuff for real. Jesus, I thought everyone knew that!"
I wasn't sure I followed his logic but if he was okay about having my beef-pole up his butt, it felt nice enough from my side that I wasn't going to complain.
When I looked at the next set of photos I couldn't stop laughing: we really did look like biggest pair of butt-munchers you could imagine. But then I noticed Reece had a great big fuck-off hard-on and that while he was pushing back against me, making that dumb-ass face of his, his knob was standing upwards with its skin pulled right back.
"You've stalked right up, you fucktard!" I told him. "Jeez, mate, look at the size of your prick - you look as if you're built like a fucking donkey!"
Reece grabbed the phone off me and looked at the photo. He chuckled at how turned-on his great big donger looked and said, "Well it's only convincing if I'm running a boner!"
"It's deliberate, you mean?" I asked, still standing there behind him with my own smaller stiffy slowly being nibbled by his hot, wet hole.
"There's no point me doing all this 'ooh-aah, I'm cumming' stuff if my cock's just dangling there looking about two inches long."
I laughed, "Oh yeah." It was pretty obvious really.
We took a few more photos of the two of us acting like we were gaying it right up, him pushing his arse out and me grabbing him by the shoulders. By now the top half of my dick was plugged deep inside his hole and I knew full well when we kept laughing about how we were 'pretending' I was butt-fucking him, it was pretty much bullshit; what we were doing was the genuine article.
Our mates would find the photos hilarious, that much was given, but for me the funniest part of it would be that, while they were giggling away at how stupid we looked pretending like we were bumming, they'd actually be looking at me with my knob up Reece's arse for real.
But he didn't seem that bothered that he had a good few inches of my wanger inside him. As long as neither of us were gay, a bit of bum fun was okay for him; as long as it was just the two of us having a laugh, it didn't really count.