Chapter 7: Out of a Storybook
An astonished cry that was meant to be "Jane!" escaped my lips, but it was muffled by the tape over my mouth. She walked over to the bed where I could see her in a better light. I was still dizzy from being knocked out, but a closer look told me the truth. This was not Jane. Sure, it was the same long, flowing hair, the same warming eyes, even though those eyes now helped to transform her face into a twisted grin, the same figure that filled out her nightgown, but the mannerisms weren't the same. She didn't stand like Jane, she didn't move like Jane. And the way she looked at me, Jane had never, could never, look at me like that.
My eyes went from being wide to narrowed, from astonishment to scornful realization.
Laura, Jane's twin, caught the change and chuckled. "Tsk tsk tsk," she clucked her tongue, "Evan, is that any way to celebrate our reunion? I thought you would be happy to see me."
A low groan and my best attempt at thrashing around were my only responses.
"Oh, don't try to escape. You'll only hurt yourself in the process. I made sure that these knots were secure enough to hold you. The only chance of getting them undone is to cut them. I wasn't a Girl Scout for no reason, you know."
What the fuck was this? Some sort of bondage fantasy that Laura was trying to live out? She reached out and began stroking my hair and face. I did my best to move away from her, but there was nowhere to go.
As far as twins went, it was difficult to find two sisters who were less alike than Jane and Laura. A lot of that came from the fact that they didn't like being automatically categorized as stereotypical identical twins, so they worked their hardest to define separate identities. They both developed different interests: Jane did a lot of art and dance activities whereas Laura tried out more sporty things. They had different friends even in grade school, which is why Laura and I weren't as close. For a while, they both contemplated changing their appearances, but they never did since they both already were satisfied with the way they looked. This isn't to say that they weren't close because the truth is that they did love each other like sisters, but they each wanted to be her own person.
"Poor, poor Evan," she said. "I bet you don't even know what's going on? Well, I'm sure by now you can guess that I'm here on Jane's behalf." She leaned in close to me and whispered into my ear. "You hurt my sister, there is no way that I'm going to let you get away with that." She stood up and went to the foot of the bed and started again. What is it with villainous people finding the need to say everything that's on their minds? They never seem to shut up.
"I bet you don't even know what you've done." I couldn't say anything, so I simply waited for her to continue. "Jane didn't want to break up with you, you know. She saw the way things were headed with you and that fag over there. God knows why, but she gave up and let you go on to commit all sorts of crazy acts of sodomy." I tilted my head over to Brian. His head had dropped again and he seemed to be sleeping. Jane crossed over to him and yanked his head back. "Ah, ah," she said, "you need to see and hear every last word of this, you sick creep. How dare you try to ruin our family's happiness." Jane released Brian's head and turned back to me, but I was sure that she was keeping an eye on him to be sure that he was paying attention.
"Do you know that Jane tried to commit suicide after she broke up with you?" My eyes filled with horror as she continued. "She was so upset that she couldn't make things work with you that she tried jumping out of her window. Thankfully, I had come up for a visit and was able to stop her. I've had to stay in New York ever since worrying that the same thing could happen again." I shifted my eyes to Brian, who was still staring in our direction, but he was wiggling a little in his seat. Fortunately, Laura hadn't noticed. "Jane has never been this hurt since our dad died. And now I understand why. She considers you family, Evan. Your moving away from her, trying to break up our family, it was almost too much, it would have been too much for her to handle had I not saved her. Now it's my turn to save her again. You're going back to Jane, you're going to marry into our wholesome Catholic family so that she can be happy, and you're going to make my mother disgustingly happy with little Catholic grandkids running around."
Laura climbed onto the king-size bed, over my wide spread legs, and straddled my torso. "I'm going to show you the right way, the straight way, and when I'm done with you, you'll never want to go back to your boy toy over there. Of course, you're not going to be able to go back to him after he's dead, but I think I should keep him alive long enough to let him watch you enjoy this shouldn't I?" She leaned forward and whispered into my ear again. "You loved women once, you loved my sister once, I'll make you love her again."
She crawled off of my torso and backed up to the space between my legs. She turned around and said to Brian, "You better make sure your queer eyes are locked onto every last moment of this or I'll make you suffer even more before you die." I could see Brian's icy eyes trying to burn their way right through her. If only that could have worked. He turned his hard stare on me. I didn't know what he was trying to communicate to me, but the look he was giving me caused me to shiver with fear. Did he think that I wanted this? That I didn't love him? No, he knew I did. That look was for something else. But for what?
Laura focused her attention on me again. "Since you've made this easy for me by living all the way up here alone on the top floor, I don't think there's any worry of someone hearing you. Besides, I want your queer friend to hear how much you love this." She reached up and yanked the tape off of my mouth. I winced in pain, but I refused to say anything. I wasn't going to give her that satisfaction. I merely glared at her. It was all I could do. Her hand found my dick and began pumping it up and down. Next, she used her tongue to lick my balls and the base of my penis. When you're a 21 year old male, there's not much you can do to avoid arousal when someone is stroking your cock, no matter what the circumstances are. Despite my best efforts, she had me fully erect after sucking me. Laura pulled her nightgown up to reveal that she wasn't wearing any panties. She climbed back onto my torso and began to lower herself onto me. Her intention was definitely to have me enjoy what she was doing. Her fingers moved up my sides and tickled my stomach and nipples. When Laura had fully impaled herself on me, she let out a primal groan. I almost laughed out loud. What a good Catholic girl she was! There was no hymen for me to break. While she continued to tweak one of my nipples with one hand, she reached behind herself and fondled my balls with the other. Then she began to raise herself up and down, raping me.
It must have been good for her because she came twice, grinding her clit into my pubic hair and bouncing up and down faster and faster on my cock. I was fighting the urge to cum and managed to hold off for some time, but I groaned in my resistance, which Laura misinterpreted as desire and worked herself harder. And then it happened, and there was nothing I could do to stop the course of nature. I came inside of her, and even though I made no noise, I slumped against the bed and exhaled in exhaustion.
She lifted herself off of me and swung one leg over me so that she could slide off the bed. "Not bad, Evan. Take a breather, I'm going to get a drink, and then I'll be back for round two." She headed for the door but stopped herself before she left. "I almost forgot," she said in a sing-song voice. She pulled out some more duct tape from under the bed and put it over my mouth. "No talking, you two. Evan, you shouldn't want to associate with a fag like him anyway."
As soon as she left, I fixed my eyes on Brian. I was trying to apologize to him using my eyes. He seemed to understand with a nod of his head, but then he began violently wriggling his feet and legs. From where I was, I could barely see, but I could see enough that he was beginning to get out of the rope that held him to the chair. Rubbing his bare leg against the rope time and time again must have been excrutiating, but he kept up the hard writhing until he heard Laura's footsteps in the hall again.