Slowly, almost reluctantly, Claude withdrew his cock from my hole. He did do that circular movement thing with just his cock head logged in my hole before he pulled out entirely, and this nearly made me shoot off. But I was glad I didn't, because I had formulated a plan for my own time with this captured and bound black burglar dude.
The first thing I did was squat down in front of the dude and say that I figured he was straight, but that after today I knew he'd have a whole new perspective. Then I picked up his torn shirt and rubbed Eric's semen off his back. I rubbed gently, in massaging motions, until I could feel him lose some of his tension. Eric and Claude pulled over the other bench press to in front of the dude, and Claude sat down and Eric sat on his lap. Claude ran his hands all over Eric's torso, arms, and thighs and eventually played with his nipples with his left hand, while slowly jerking him off with his right hand, all where the burglar dude could see them. When Eric had finished, he took the head harness off the dude, but I was interested to see that the dude was still looking up, on his own, eyeing what Claude and Eric were doing.
I went into the other room and returned with the tube of fuck lubricant and some salve. I rubbed the salve on the dude's reddened bottom, using sensual circular motions, and I was gratified to see him slightly raise his butt and go with the motions. I cleaned up what Crisco I could get to with his torn shirt and then applied the fuck lubricant, without going too deep. I was happy to see that his cock seemed to be growing a bit. I leaned over him from the back and massaged his shoulders and back muscles some more and spent some time tracing the swirls of his tattoos. Then I folded my body on his, letting him feel my hard cock against his butt. My cock was lodged in his big butt crack, and I did some stroking there up toward the small of his back. His butt was so bulbous that I could fuck him right where I was and think I'd entered him. While I was stretched out along his back, I snaked my hand under him and found his nipples. I started gently kneading them and running my hand around his chest and down to his belly. I was happy to see that he lifted his chest and belly a bit off the bench, to the extent he could, to give me more room to fondle him. I brought my lips to the side of his neck and kissed him there. Then I gave him a few love nips there and whispered, "It's OK, baby. It's going to be OK. You're going to enjoy this." His body gave a slight shudder, and then I could feel him relax under me.
Eric got up out of Claude's lap and walked up to in front of the dude.
"I'm going to take this gag out. But if you scream or say anything at all, I'm going to put it right back on. Do you understand?"
The dude nodded his head. Eric ripped the tape off around the dude's head, which made him tense up again underneath me. He then took the jock strap out of the dude's mouth, and he ran his tongue around his lips. And we noticed then that he had quite a large mouth, and full lips. Eric couldn't resist.
"Okay, now I'm going to give you a kiss, and you're going to take what I have here between my legs for you. Right? Or the jock strap goes back on."
The dude tensed up and started to say something, but all it took was Eric to raise the jock strap to shut him up. Then Eric put his lips on the dude's and gave him a kiss. But he pulled right back. "That ain't any good," Eric said. "You aren't leaving here until I'm convinced we've queered you. Convince me." He went to the dude's lips again, and this time the dude opened his mouth to him, ever so slightly, and I could feel him starting to relax again under me. I was still working on his nipples and belly, but I could see that Eric had taken the dude's lower lip into his mouth and was sucking on it, and then, when the dude opened up more, Eric's tongue went in, so I pulled back my right hand and scooted back a bit along his body until I could get my hand between his legs. Success. His cock had swollen and was coming to attention. I encircled it with my hand, and he tensed and shuddered and then, as I began to stroke him, he calmed down again.
I came off him and knelt behind him. I could see that the lubricant was doing its magic and his hole was loosening up. I continued to stroke his dick, giving him a loose hand job, as I rolled and pulled gently at his humongous balls with my other hand.