He began to seem more and more like a real person, rather than a crutch to hold my frail ego-body up.
On top of natural charisma and a sociopathic ease in manipulation, Jeff possessed an innate yet honed ability to read others, and to phrase statements and questions in such a manner that the only conclusion possible to arrive at would always be exactly where he wanted me.
"I prayed to God about a year ago, the last time I was in a church, and asked him to make a deal." Jeff told me one night. He paused whatever horror flick we had rented and switched the living room lights on, illuminating his mother's manicured and weekly scoured home littered with soda bottles, candy wrappers, popcorn kernals crushed to crumbs, and the two of us, shirts stained with spilled soda, remnants of nearly every sort of junk food available.
"You know masturbation is a sin, right?" he asked, leaving me waiting for the details of his pact with the Almighty. I shook my head in the affirmative. "To be honest," Jeff continued, any small gesture of cooperation likely able to suffice for his pacing of the narrative, "It's the one sin I can't control. I mean, I don't feel the urge to kill anyone, I don't worship pagan gods, I've never raped anyone and I'd never want to. If you think about it, you can obey most commandments just by default! But, lust and the "Sin of Onan" are literally impossible to not do. Believe me, I tried to stop, but it's like my body wants it so much that it just starts touching me without my control. In the middle of a long stretch of feeling like a worthless sinner, I was in church and I could feel some kind of connection with something BIG, so I prayed and asked God to provide me a path to follow when it comes to this specific sin. If it really was important, then I asked God to give me the strength or will or self-control or whatever I didn't have so I could beat this sin. If He really didn't care if I beat the meat from time to time, to help me ease up on my self-condemnation."
"And?" I pried, leaning even further forward on the sofa, knowing that the eternal salvation or endless damnation of not only Jeff and me, but that the salvation of ninety-nine percent of all boys out there hinged on Jeff's divine prophecy.
"I got my answer almost right away!" he proclaimed. "While I was finishing my prayer, silently, of course, Reverend Ballard had already begun moving through the steps to dismiss the congregation: final announcements, weekday bible class schedules, and that sort of thing. I was so caught up in my conversation with God that I didn't even notice the whole hour had flown by. When I stood up in the pew at the conclusion of the benediction prayer, I had to sit back down right away, because for some reason unknown to me, I had a hardon the size of Texas!"
I nearly fell off of the couch, I was laughing so hard at the idea of getting an erection while praying, in the middle of church, and then standing up and having a boner stick straight ahead, the soft, thin material that slacks are made out of doing nothing to provide resistance.
"So what?" I asked, my laughter dying as I thought again to his proposition for God. "You took that as a sign from heaven?"
"Ha, not just that," Jeff pitched back in, anticipating that the gap of silence he had placed in the story would prompt that very question. "It wouldn't go away! I sat there and thought about folding socks, doing homework, I even tried to imagine crusty old Mrs. Taylor, the algebra teacher in her underwear (yuck!), but nothing worked. So, I put my bible over my raging-hard dick and walked as fast as I could to the restroom to take care of business."
"Wait," I interrupted, feeling like he was pushing his own plot further than could even be plausible. "You're telling me you jerked off INSIDE of church? Just because people shit in the restroom doesn't mean it's not sacred."
Jeff leaned back in the sofa, bringing his hands up behind his head as if he was telling the story of the time he saved a village from a volcano or something. "My friend," he chuckled as he spoke, "Not only did I flog the dolphin inside the sacred walls of the house of the Lord, I was guided by some kind of inspiration to do things I'd never even thought of before. Different positions that make my dick spring out in different ways, using my left hand on my balls... or even other places. All kinds of stuff, man. It was hands-down the best jerkoff session in my life."
Jeff had stopped talking, but I waited as long as I could stand, knowing that he knows, from having the same English Composition class together, that his story needed a conclusion, because I had no idea what he was drawing from all of this. In return, Jeff squinted at me, furrowing his eyebrows, appearing both frustrated and amazed that I didn't naturally see where he was going with this.
"Dude," he said, departing from his narrating voice and returning to his regular goof-off tone, "God or the Holy Spirit or whatever you call it not only doesn't mind if we use our bodies for pleasure, but He or It actually encourages it. It's like, God wants us to experience as much pleasure as possible. So, I quit going to church, and you can imagine what the freed-up time is going towards now!"
We both snickered, and then fell into awkward silence. Everyone masturbates, and if they don't, that's sad. But, at 18, NO ONE ever talked about masturbating. Jeff had just crossed that line, and in doing so, he had placed into my mind the scene of him cramped in a church restroom stall, trying to get into pretzel positions while jerking his dick and cupping his balls with his other hand. I would have burst into another fit of laughter, but instead I was silently ashamed when I realized that my own erection was rising, inspired by the image of my friend, my buddy, lost in orgasm, his hand sliding up and down his shaft, his fingers swirling his tip, and then pounding all the way down again.
Needing to break the spell before my hard-on was undeniable, and irreversible, I said the first thing that came to mind, "I like that idea - your prophecy." Jeff's eyes lit up and he impatiently waited for me to tell him specifics. "I mean, it makes sense that God would want us to have all good experiences, and busting one off is never a bad thing. That makes a lot more sense than a God who creates us with dicks that can turn rock-hard in seconds, but then tells us that we can't touch it or we'll go to hell!"