My Gay Harem of Hot Brothers

I know some readers have been waiting a while for this chapter. The thing is... I received a fair bit of hate messages about this series, which was discouraging... But I wrote this and have a rough outline for the next 3 chapters at the moment, which I'll write depending on how it goes...

All characters are above the age of 18.

Character key at the end.

*

"My favorite. Thanks, Jordan!" Reese rejoiced. He was majorly salivating.

"First slice is all yours, bro," Caleb cut him a big slab of roast beef and poured the red sauce over it. It smelled delicious. The potatoes were perfectly done, too. I might've also been salivating.

It was a Friday night, so everyone went around the table to review their week. The brothers called it their "happies and crappies." Haha! Good things and not so great things anyone wanted to discuss.

Reese started, "Happy, this dinner. Crappy, hmm, my part time job at the mechanic shop is eating into a lot of study time, but I enjoy working there. I might reassess some of my hours at the end of this month."

"We can help review your shifts and schedule," Asher.

"'hannksh," Reese replied with a stuffed mouth. He was really enjoying his dinner! He could be on a food commercial.

Caleb went next. "Happy, Ollie's lips."

I choked on my food. That was so embarassing! The brothers laughed at me. I was double embrasssed.

Caleb smiled wide. "Crappy, not enough nights with Ollie in my bed."

"Caleb..." I knew my face was red.

He laughed joyfully again.

Jordan mentioned winning a tough case we had all been following. We congratulated and toasted to him with our water and soda glasses.

The twins combined theirs as usual.

"Happy, we scored high on our science quiz because of Liv!"

"Crappy, we second not enough nights with Olive in our bed."

"No repeats." Jordan lightly teased.

"Fine... Crappy, not enough naked time with Olive."

I choked again. These brothers loved to tease me!

I opened my mouth to retort, but Reese cut me off, "Little one, your turn. Happy and crappy."

"I'm happy to have dinner with you guys almost every night. Crappy... Can someone, um... Could one of you teach me how to drive? Please?" I couldn't afford to get my license before, but living here, I was able to save up from my part time job.

Jordan answered first, "You don't need to learn. I'll drive you anywhere you want to go."

Asher scoffed, "Dude, come on, Olive wants to learn."

"Let's do it!" Caleb and Avery said at the same time. They whipped their heads towards each other and automatically started a game of rock paper scissors.

Caleb won. "Hell yeah!"

"Best two out of three?" Avery tried.

"Nope," Caleb popped the 'p.'

The twins couldn't help giggling despite losing.

Big, bad Reese, on the other hand, was very nervous. The next morning, he got up early (wow) and took Caleb's car to the shop to double, no triple, check the breaks and air bags and oil and everything. Also, before I left the following morning, he went over a million scenarios and gave me way more snacks and supplies than I needed for a few hour lesson.

Caleb took me to an empty home depot parking lot. He was a patient and detailed teacher! He simplified everything, and I felt comfortable the whole time with him. He said he'd help me apply for my permit and that he or Avery would take me out on the roads next time.

When I returned home, I found Jordan zoned out in his bedroom, lying in bed, in the middle of the day! He usually never was during the day. Ever.

"Jordie? Do you want to talk?"

"Oliver," he smiled sadly. "I'm okay. You should be with one of the others. I'm not good company right now." He threw an arm over his face.

"Jooordieeee!" I jumped on his bed and hugged him. "What's wrong now? Your brothers and you seem to be on good terms again. Did something else happen?"

"No, we're good..." His throat worked.

I often had the most trouble prying out Jordan's feelings. He always seemed to be carrying too much weight on his shoulders and too many thoughts in his head and too many emotions in his heart. I straddled him and started massaging his shoulders.

"What are you doing?" He finally quirked a small smile.

"I want you to relax. And tell me what you're feeling."

His face became serious again. He said, "I'm jealous and nervous."

"About what?" I kneaded more deeply.

"You."

I stopped moving. "What? Why?"

"You get along with my brothers so well, which usually I love."

"But?"

"But they have a certain ease around each other that I can't seem to match. For example, you wanted to learn how to drive, and everyone besides me helped you in some way to start doing that. All I did was... nothing. What if, one day, you find your relationship with me irrelevant? What if you end up choosing one of the others? What if you only don't want to be with me anymore?"

I listened closely to everything Jordan had to say. I could feel how fragile this usually strong man was, so I wanted to answer carefully, but...

I laughed! I couldn't stop.

Jordan looked baffled.

Between breaths, I said, "Omg! Jordie, you're so silly!"

"What?"

I calmed down a bit. "I love you because of the way you are! I love each of you, because of your different personalities but continued care and... adoration. All in different ways... but I feel it all the same."

"You love us? Me?"

"Y-yes." I touched his jaw slightly. "Yes, I do, Jordie."

His mouth parted. He kissed my hand and said, "My brothers have been my whole world for so long, I didn't have time to open my heart to a partner, but you came crashing into our lives, and you've fit in seamlessly. There isn't enything else I could wish for. Except for you to keep loving me like I do you?"

He pulled me to his lips and kissed me again and again and again. It was unhurried and languid. A beauitiful evening to relax without time constraints.

I veered off course, nipping his jaw and kissing down his neck with big sloppy kisses. His breathing deepened. I loved the effect I had on this strong, older man.

I pushed up his shirt, which he graciously pulled off. I kissed all over his chest, licking and soothing his skin. He was burning up, and I took pride in the fact that I could make him like this.

I licked and sucked each outline of muscle on his torso. When I got to the V of his abs, I gave him the attention they deserved. By the time I reached his waistband, Jordan seemed like a muscled live wire ready to snap.

I gripped his waistband. He lifted his hips. I salivated when his big, beautiful cock appeared.

When I licked him base to tip, his breath whooshed out of him. I nuzzled his base and gave every inch of his huge member small, teasing kisses. He already had a drop building at his tip. I quickly licked it and hummed in satisfaction.

Jordan stroked my cheeks and pet my hair, almost reverently.

I mouthed his shaft and finally sucked the head of him in my mouth.

"Oliver..." he groaned.

I tightened suction but sloooowly moved down his girthy length and equally as slowly back up. I made sure my tongue slid against him with all my movements.

The wet sounds of my mouth and Jordie's uneven breathing filled the space. I loved the feel of his meaty girth filling my mouth, his weight on my tongue.

I wanted him to feel how much I cared for him. I ran my hands up and down his thighs and abs. I popped off intermittently to give him praise and open mouthed kisses on random spots on his skin. It was a little difficult breaking out my shell like this, but I wanted to do it for him.

Still sucking him slowly up and down, I pushed my shorts and underwear off. My dick brushed the bed covers, sending whispers of sensation throughout my body. I couldn't help shifting my hips to get more friction.

I pulled up to focus hard suction on his cockhead. I swallowed more drops of his salty precome. Hmm, my reward tasted good. I didn't realize I had closed my eyes to savor it. When I opened my eyes, I lifted them to look at Jordie, who was tight lipped and watching me unblinking. I licked up and down his shaft teasingly. The muscles on his neck strained. Heat blazed through me at his reactions. I gripped my dick and stroked in time with my suctioning lips traveling up and down his length again.

He opened his mouth to say something but froze. I sucked harder and increased my pace incrementally. He tried again. His mouth opened and closed. I paused, breathing against his wet member.

"Oliver." The only thing he said.

I bobbed my head as fast as I could with a tight suction and one hand gripping the length of him I couldn't reach. He tipped his head back, his entire body arching and shouted a cry of pleasure as he spurted shot after shot down my throat.

I took him as deep down my throat and swallowed every drop. Even as his body relaxed, I continued warming him with my mouth as my hand blurred over my dick. Not a few seconds later, I shot on the bed, moaning around his softening cock. My body jerked in time with my spurts of come juice.

I lazied on Jordie's thigh until I fell asleep. I woke up later in his arms as the slowly setting sun shining through the curtains woke us up.

We cuddled and kissed leisurely for another half hour before the other brothers barged in to grab us for more weekend activities.

...

It was another night with the twins per the family sleep schedule.

"What? You thought we'd let someone else take our virginities?" Avery casually said. We were relaxing in their room, music playing in the background.

"What's it feel like?" I asked. I experienced the least amount of embarrassment asking sex questions to the twins, since they were so open and casual about everything. And maybe the most adventurous!

"Hmmm, well, like having sex with your self. It's like... masturbating for us," Asher replied.

Typical twins, Avery continued the thought. "We found out we both prefer topping. It would've been great if one of us liked bottoming."

"Sooooo, Olive, there's something we want to try." They both sat up a little straighter.

Uh oh.

"How do you like topping?"

"Um, I don't think I'd be very good at it."

"You never know until you try!"

"Umm, but what about..."

"Don't worry, Liv. You're ass will still be filled. There are two of us aren't there?"

My mouth fell open. What were they...

"I lost our most recent bet, so I'm the bottom of the pile, today." Asher wiggled his brows.

Pile?

Didn't they just say they both prefer topping? "I- I don't want to do something you don't want."

"No! I do. We've been wanting to try this for a while, and it'll be hot since it's you."

"If you're sure... Also, I think this is a good as time as any..." I looked them both in the eyes, back and forth. "I love you, Asher and Avery."

"Thank fuck, Liv. Finally."

"We were starting to get nervous that you didn't say it back."

"Back? Uummm, you've, um, never told me you love me. I think I'd remember that."

"Seriously?" They looked at each other in bewilderment. "We started talking to each other about how much we love you, like, the first week you moved in!"

"Shit, did we forget to tell Liv?"

"We thought you knew!"

They both started cracking up. I laughed, too. They were ridiculous men living in their own world.

They gave me quick kisses and started undressing me. I was starting to get used to the amount of time we spent nude together. And being seen nude. And being touched...

I was already almost fully hard. Everything they did turned me on.

Aaaand now I was fully hard. They were fully naked, too.

They gave me a hug from either side, squishing me tight. I giggled. Naked hugs were the best!

Asher turned around towards the bed and crawled on top. Avery moved us forward to follow.

Asher lubed his finger and twisted to prep himself.

"Wait!!" I yelled.

"What's wrong?"

"I... can do it."

Asher was on all fours with his gorgeous butt popped up, but why was I the one who was embarassed? Maybe, I thought I was nervous about making them feel as good as they made me feel.

"Yeah?"

I nodded my head.

He leaned down. I lubed my fingers very generously.

I started by rubbing around his rim. He was tense. I ran my other hand down his back to sooth him. He seemed to appreciate it.

I quickly got distracted and fondled his perfect ass cheeks. It should be a crime for him and his brother - all the brothers - to look as good as they did.

Avery saddled up next to me. He had a clear view of what I was doing. "Fuck that's hot. I almost feel like you're touching me, Liv. Must be the twin sensation thing." He slipped his hand between my cheeks and mimicked exactly what I did to Asher. Oh wow, kind of like real time feedback.

I slipped one finger in and found Asher's prostate. I rubbed it how I liked. Avery somehow knew when I did and copied the same for me.

While Asher gave little huffs of pleasure, I moaned and gasped.

"Does... that feel good, Asher?"

"Yeah, Olive!" He smiled back at me.

"H-how can I do better? My body is all tingly. I can hardly focus, but you're..."

Avery bit my ear as Asher answered, "You just have a sensitive prostate."

Avery broke from the pattern I was going with Asher by thrusting in another finger and rapidly pumping aginst me with increased speed.

"Aahh!! Soooo good," I mumbled, partially incoherently. I gripped Asher's hip for purchase. "Is something wrong with me?"

"Nope, just luck of the draw." Avery's fingers slowed, allowing me a breath.

"Fuck, Olive's hot."

I slipped in two then three fingers and slowly eased Asher open.

"Okay, okay, I'm ready! Come on!" Asher reached back to pump my dick, pulling little sounds from me, and wiggled his booty invitingly. I slipped out and squeezed both his cheeks.

As soon as Asher let go, Avery grabbed on to guide my dick, as he continued fucking my hole with three fingers. His hips also pressed against mine, pushing me towards Asher's entrance.

Avery rubbed my dickhead against Asher's slippery hole. Ooohh my body's muscles fluttered all over. He pushed harder as Asher beared down.

"Oh!!! Oh Asher! Avery! Oh wow!" My dickhead felt like the life was being squeezed out of it, encompassed by the warmest seduction that kept pulling me in. Avery's big fingers continued to pump in and out of me. Don't come, don't come. Ooohhh. I wasn't even passed the ring yet.

Snick! The rest of my dick slid in slowly and smoothly after that.

Asher was panting below me.

Avery twisted his fingers in me wickedly. My hips twitched an inch or so out then back in without my control. "Sorry!" Avery rubbed my prostate, and my hips thrust again. "Oh gosh, Avery, I can't-" He did it again. "Asher, are you okay- ughh!"

Asher's hand worked his dick furiously. "Yeah, Olive, you can keep going," he giggled.

Avery flicked and rubbed my nipple. "Ahh! I'm going to-" Abruptly, he pulled me out of Asher, removed his fingers, and stopped all contact with me. I doubled over and groaned. I had been about to fall of the edge, but he didn't let me!

I took a few calming breaths. "Okay... Okay, I'm okay now."

Asher teased, "A virgin no longer, huh?" I guess they had taken one of my virginities!

Avery stroked my dick teasingly then guided me back into Asher. The tight warmth was almost as surprising as the first time. It took my breath away again. I dug my fingers into Asher's sides. I hope it didn't hurt him.

Asher pushed back against me, fucking himself on my dick leisurely. I just tried to stay as composed as possible.

Avery lined himself up behind me. He slipped in assuredly. Yeeesssss, that's what I needed. My head fell forward against Asher's shoulder. I kissed his flushed skin there. Oh my... the sensations from both sides were overwhelming.

I moved back and forth, chasing as much pleasure as possible from the front and back. They allowed the movement for a few minutes before taking control again. Asher started a steady pounding on my dick, and Avery gripped my hips again to hold me still or move me as they intended as he thrust into me.

All I could do was gasp and moan. I mewled and shivered and arched in rapture.

Asher squeezed his canal around me.

"Omg! Wow!!"

"Like that?" Asher teased.

"Ooohhh!! I'm going to-" *gasp* "-come! I'm going to come!!"

Avery's hips snapped into me like a jackhammer. I tried to pull out of Asher; I didn't know if I was supposed to... Asher reached behind himself to pull me to him as the beginning of my orgasm peaked.

Ooooohhhh the dual sensation of squirting into Asher as Avery squirted into me was unmatched! We were dripping. That's so hot.

Immediately after Avery and I climaxed, Asher pulled off of me and quickly rearranged me to roughly thrust into me.

"Hmm, your ass is soft and puffy. So inviting."

He pounded into my ass as it continued to spasm in aftershocks. Just a few thrusts in and he added his fill inside me next to his brother's.

He landed on top of me, and Avery threw a few limbs on me as well. They were heavy, and breathing was hard, but I wouldn't change it for the world.

Later, as they lazied in bed, I poked around in their drawers. Clothes, school supplies, gamer stuff... Oh what's this? One of their bottom clothes drawers was filled with... I pulled out a hard, round object with a fake gem on the end of it. I looked at the guys questioningly, who raised their brows in delight. I turned it around and around in my hand. I bit my lip and looked back over at them. Asher fondled his slowly growing cock as Avery caressed his own chest.

"It's a butt plug!" One of them suddenly shouted.

"Oh!!" I dropped it back in.

They snickered. "Don't worry, it's unused... we got excited thinking of all the things we could do to you and went on a shopping spree!"

"These... are for me?"

They nodded in conjunction.

Trepidation but mostly excitement ran through me. I continued snooping. There was flavored lube; I've always wanted to try that. I blushed.

I pulled out a light blue belt type thing with a metal contraption on the end. When I looked over at the twins questioningly, their eyes were full of excitement. Asher beat his fully hard cock, and Avery squeezed the base of his, almost close to coming?! They liked the idea of using this on me that much? I didn't care what it was. Their excitement excited me. They said that would be for me to try later in the future.

I placed it back for now. There was a wrapped gift in the corner of the drawer. "Is this for me?"

I went to pull it out when they shouted-

"No!"

"Wait!"

"That one's a surprise. Don't open it yet."

I mockingly pouted.

"We promise you'll like it. And so will the others. Actually, we weren't the ones to get that. It's going to be great."

"Oh? Okay..."

"Come back to bed, and help us with the problems you've caused." Avery pointed to their swollen cocks.

I giggled and jumped into bed between them.

*

Character Key:

Oliver

- Age 18.

- Gay. A bottom through and through.

- Junior in high school. Repeating a grade due to family stuff.

- Nicknames: Ollie, Olive, Liv.

Asher and Avery

- Age 18.

- Hair color: both bright red.

- Bisexual, prefer guys. They prefer sharing their sexual partners.

- Juniors in high school. Started a grade behind so wouldn't be in same grade as older brother Caleb.

- Both mischievous, Avery slightly more so.

- Avery calls Oliver Liv.

- Asher calls Oliver Olive.

- They play Lacrose. Jersey numbers 12 Asher and 21 Avery.

- Took Oliver's dick virginity.

- Have shared they love Oliver.

Caleb

- Age 19.

- Hair color: orange.

- Gay. Loves dirty talk.

- Senior in high school. Summer birthday.

- Caleb calls Oliver Ollie.

- He plays football. Jersey number 22.

- Publically Oliver's boyfriend at school. They have made love.