It was a dark and stormy night. More specifically, it was a mid-June whopper of a Tennessee thunderstorm. The leaves of the trees where I saw them in my car's headlights were flipped silver side up by the wind. Somewhere, I was sure, there was going to be a tornado. The rain fell in buckets and as I made my way home from work I could see that the power was out in my neighborhood. For being so close to the high tension lines, we lost our electricity a lot.
No power meant the garage door opener would not work, either. A short, but drenching dash to the door, and another few seconds unlocking the door were sure to follow. I girded my loins for the rain. At least I would not be in wet clothes for very long, though: I had to get naked as soon as I got inside.
I did not see GreedySteve's truck. He had spent the first two nights, since our agreement started, here and used every chance he had to fuck my ass or have me suck his cock. He came by for a morning blow job yesterday, but I had not seen him since. Maybe I would get a full day and night off.
I parked as close to the door as I could, opened the car and sprinted the ten feet to the house while torrents of rain fell. I was pretty satisfied with myself as I unlocked it and stepped inside within a couple of seconds of being out of the car. Before I had a chance to be too proud, someone standing next to the door grabbed my shirt and yanked me in. The door slammed and locked behind me.
I was tossed off balance into someone else in the shadows. Before I could see who he was, he had a blindfold tied around my eyes. I tried to pull it off, but my hands were grabbed by someone behind me and held while the guy in front of me quickly and expertly tied them together. A gag was tied on before I could do anything to stop it. The hands and the knot felt familiar, so this was probably Steve. But Steve and who else? And how many?
I tried a blind kick behind me and missed. My leg was caught as it went past and pulled. I got off balance and would have fallen on the cement, but was grabbed by my shoulders and legs and lowered to the ground. I struggled, and a man sat on me while ropes were tied to each of my ankles then the ropes tied together.
I was tied, blindfolded and gagged. As helpless as I could be. At least I was still dressed.
"We should have gotten his clothes off first," I heard a voice that was definitely Steve say. I relaxed a little, if he was here at least I was getting out of this alive.
"I don't see a problem," another voice said. Who was that?
He grabbed the collars of my work polo. With one strong pull he ripped my shirt open down the middle. He reached a hand down and rubbed my chest and stomach then finished ripping my shirt off of me. I heard the remains softly hit the ground beside me. That was a work shirt, too.
"Let's get him to his feet and get to the good stuff," Steve said.
They lifted me to my feet. Steve stood behind me and got me in a full nelson with my bare back against his bare chest. I could feel that his cock was hard beneath my shorts. The other man stepped in front of me, put his hands in the front of my shorts and jerked.
I heard the button land somewhere far off and the fabric split. A couple of more tears and my shorts joined my shirt in the pile on the floor. I was left in my boxers.
"No more underwear," Steve ordered softly in my ear. "It slows things down."
Not for long, because they were ripped to shreds faster than my shorts. I was naked with no wearable clothes and two horny men. And I was tied up, bound and gagged, too.
"Nice cock," the other man complimented me. I heard him moving in front of me. Then to my astonishment, I felt his mouth on my cock. Steve had never done more than masturbate me, I didn't realize some tops liked to give head.
"You're lucky," Steve whispered in my ear, "Jim here likes sucking cock, too. You might get something out of this night."
I squirmed, which only served to rub my naked butt against Steve's bare shaft. He moved with me, his precum leaving streaks on my smooth cheeks. The hot wetness of his mouth on my aching cock felt so good. Being held, tied up and helpless just amplified it. I was on the verge of cumming when he stopped and stood up. I let out an audible moan of disappointment.
"Who goes first?" Jim asked. At least I could put a name with him. The voice sounded vaguely familiar, too. Another cafΓ© regular?
"You," Steve said. "I'm going to leave a mess."
"Why don't you wear a condom, too?"
"Because I don't have to. He's mine, I can do what I want. You get a tasty piece of ass to fuck, you can make me wear one. But this one's mine and I say suit up and dive in."
"Fine," Jim said. "Let me get him ready."
I was pushed face first against the door. Steve released the full nelson, but kept a strong hand on the back of my neck to keep me from going anywhere.
The lights suddenly came back on. Even through the blindfold, I could tell it was light again. The rain outside seemed to be letting up, too.
"He does have a great butt," Jim said. I felt him squeeze a little lube in my ass and start to rub it in. He smacked one of my cheeks and added more lube.
"Wait 'till you get your dick in him," Steve said with a laugh. "Then you can really appreciate it."
Jim moved in behind me. I felt the tip of his cock slide up and down my crack before it caught on my anus. He paused there for a second and placed both hands on my hips. I was about to get fucked by only the second man in my life. I gave a yell out into the gag as he grabbed my shoulders with both hands and roughly pulled himself into me, burying his cock in my helpless ass in one quick stroke. I tried to rise up on my toes to make it easier, but his hands on my shoulders held me in place.
"Damn, this is nice," Jim said to Steve. He pulled back and rammed in again hard. "You own this for six months?"
"For all practical purposes," Steve said from somewhere beside me. "He agreed to three months, then screwed up and got it doubled to six. Thanks to Tom."
"Niiiice..." Jim said and thrust inside of me again and again as hard as he could. "Are you a good little buttbitch for Steve?" Jim asked me and ran his hands up and down my back. "You like getting your ass pounded?"
I didn't answer. I was gagged and didn't see much point in nodding.
He started fucking me hard, slamming in each time. Amidst the arousal, pain and pleasure of this, I noticed some differences between Steve and Jim. Steve definitely had a bigger cock. I still hurt with Jim, but was not stretched as much. Jim was rougher, more violent with his fucking, too. Steve always just wanted to get the most pleasure as he could from me, satisfied that I was already conquered and submissive. Jim seemed like he had a point he wanted to make, that he was in control and I was not. I have to admit that it kind of scared me and I was glad GreedySteve was there to keep me relatively safe.