Samuel is sexy and he damn knows it, showing off his banging body on social media and in the gym any chance that he gets. Oliver knows that he should not agree to let the vacant room of his apartment to a straight horny jock, exhibitionist on top of everything else. This might only create problems and frustrations... Right? Although, how could he resist?! Sam is WAY TOO HOT!
MY ROOMMATE IS (WAY) TOO HOT!
Chapter 8: Way too curious
Here we were.
Kitty and I on all fours, giggling like idiots, presenting our bare asses to Samuel who had a black pair of boxer briefs poorly tied up on his upper face.
This was the only thing we had found to make him blind.
To be fair, we were a bit tipsy.
Sam could only use his nose and tongue to recognise our respective buttholes. Those were the official rules we had agreed upon.
"Wait before you dive in!" Kitty intervened, hysterical. "We'll switch places with Oliver and then, we'll shut up so the game is fair."
"Go ahead, I'm ready! But shouldn't I win something if I recognize the right hole?"
"What do you want, a prize? A medal?" Kitty mocked Samuel.
Too happy to be included, I was merely giving my point of view.
I thought that whatever was happening was something close to a miracle, a strange planets' alignment which had brough me there.
Of course, Oliver would recognize my ass right away! My dick was hard and dripping a few inches from my hole...
But that did not mean that I did not want to play the game.
"If I recognize your asshole from Olivers', we do a threesome with one of your girlfriends. One of the hot ones, okay?! If I get it wrong, we do a threesome with one of my buddies to satisfy you." Samuel proposed to Kitty.
He clearly had been thinking about this for a while.
"Sounds fair." She replied. "Let's play now! Oliver, are you good?"
"All good." I blurted out.
Kitty pretended to switch place with me but in the end, we remained exactly where we were.
I knew Samuel was naΓ―ve but I was not sure this strategy would fool him. Not that I cared much anyway.
"Can I go for it?" Samuel asked.
He was semi-laughing too.
Crazy how this sort of sexual games was normal and light-hearted to some people, while my rare nights with my friends mostly consisted in playing board games.
Everyone is different, I suppose.
Kitty got his face very close to mine to throw Samuel off and she howled:
"Game on!"
It had been decided that Samuel could not even use his hands to feel our asses. He had no other choice but to go face first.
This led to some ridiculous attempts. He was leaning forward with his tongue out but was only reaching the void, or bumping into my thigh instead of my asshole.
Honestly, this was pretty hilarious.
After a few fails, nothing happened for a little while until I noticed that Kitty was biting her lips on my left. I turned my face and, lo and behold, Samuel had reached destination and was seemingly already deep inside her ass.
Shit! If he would recognize her, did that mean the game would be over before he would get a chance to taste me?!
He took a big sniff. The place must have felt familiar to my roommate... He was very used to be smothered under that bubble butt.
"Damn, it's hard to say, we've just taken a shower! Seems like a girl's bum to me but now I'm confused!" Samuel complained.
We all laughed.
"Dig deeper!" Kitty begged him.
"I think I smell some pussy around here but where's the second asshole I had to taste?!"
Sam pulled his face back from Kitty's ass but went further on the left, meaning that his face hit a chair. He understood that he needed to go back on the right instead.
There, he fell right into my ass-crack.
I had to refrain a gasp.
SAMUEL HAD HIS TONGUE AGAINST MY HOLE!
More than that, he was fully going in, making me wet and searching my insides like a good dog.
"Fuck, that's the exact same taste. That's because of the damn body wash's scent we've all just used!"
"You have to go deeper, babe. Take your time."
I did not say a word but I could not agree more with Kitty.
Yes, Sam, take your time shoving your tongue in my butthole and French-kissing my ass.
He took another big sniff and proceeded to tongue-fuck my hole. Interesting technique, I assumed that he wanted to compare with what he had done to Kitty before.
Although I had nutted about a half hour earlier myself, my dick was dangerously throbbing as Samuel was rimming me.
I wondered if he could feel it, how close I was from cumming again.
To help him out, I thought I could push my ass further back and smothering him. Maybe he would get a better sense of whose ass he was eating that way?
In any event, he was very good at this, and not shy at all!
He spat in my hole and stayed in there for a good five minutes until...
"Shit! That's some hair!" He finally pulled back, laughing like crazy. "Pouaaaah..."
He spat the hair back on the floor.
Damn, if I had known how the evening would turn out, I would have shaved! What an idiot.
I was not very hairy down there, especially compared to Sam, but eh, I was a man!
Kitty removed the blindfold from Samuel's eyes playfully.
"So, what's your verdict, player?"
"Second one was Oliver's! No doubt! Freaking hairy ass!"
"Eh, I ate you ass and you're way hairier than I am!"
"Who cares? I won!"
"Well played." I simply stated.
"Dude, you're hard as a rock!" Samuel complained, pointing his finger at my stiffed cock.
"So are you!" I snapped back.
"Oh well... I've been getting hard, slurping another bro's ass! Who'd have thought?!"
He was very much amused by the situation.
Every time I thought he would get upset, I was wrong. My roommate was just not the kind of guys to get worked up over silly things, and especially not over an unwanted erection.
"You're sure you'd not prefer the threesome with another dude?" Kitty teased him. "You seem to like the two guys one girl combo very much!"
"Pretty sure I like pussies better, but that was an interesting experimentation. You've got a nice ass bro!"
Samuel ended his sentence by slapping my ass.
Once again, I was afraid to say anything which might make the situation awkward.
Since everybody was taking things lightly, -- while I was freaking out inside and being seriously horny -, I decided it was better not to overthink.
After a few more jokes, Kitty and Samuel eventually left to go sleep in the same bed. Lucky them!