"I know you're hurting, but why did you have to turn into such a bastard!"
I pressed a hand to my stinging cheek. Ever since I'd broken my arm, my girlfriend had been sympathetic and helpful bordering on smothering. She really didn't deserve my bad attitude, but I couldn't help it. I suddenly felt like the whole world had turned against me and the only way I could cope was by withdrawing into a protective shell.
"Oh? So you're going to deny sleeping with my best friend behind my back?" I asked in a tone that conveyed absolute certainty in my belief, despite the fact that I had no reason at all to believe such a thing.
"I have
never
and I will
never
cheat!" She roared indignantly.
"Don't give me that! He told me all about it!"
She slapped me again. "He did not because it never happened! But you know what? If you
were
going out with a girl who would cheat and she did it with him, I wouldn't be at all surprised! You call him your best friend, but I don't think you've EVER let anyone into your heart enough to be called a
friend
much less a BEST FRIEND!"
Hmm... she might have a point. I considered my best friend my best friend simply because he was my neighbor, we're the same age, and we've basically hung out ever since we were little kids. And for that same reason, he might actually be the only person I even call a friend, but even I have to wonder sometimes why we hang out at all. We were basically opposites and had nothing in common.
But since I knew my accusation wasn't true, I supposed that I just had to ride the burning flames of deceit all the way to the bitter end. I glared at her as if she had just murdered my favorite dog.
"Trying to turn this around on me as if this is somehow
my fault
just proves that it's true," I pointed out with a soft growl. "Dimitri is the sort of guy who can have five or six different girls in one night and still manage to keep them all happy and they never suspect for a moment that he's playing them all. Do you even KNOW how many times I've gone over to his house to hang out only to walk in on him in bed with some girl? So, when I found YOUR underwear in his room, I asked him how long he'd been screwing you, and he told me all about it!"
She looked utterly shocked. "Those
can't
have been mine! You only think they were because I wear plain white panties! But they're the same sort of underwear that EVERY girl wears at least a couple of times a month! I am NOT a cheater! I thought you knew me well enough to know that!"
"Listen Amanda, who would you believe? Your best friend that you've known for your whole life, or someone you've only known for about three years?"
She had moved from sheer fury to silent tears by this point. "So you're going to break up with me with no proof simply because you've known him longer?"
I felt like that was a trap. I could practically see her mind scrambling to figure out how she could prove the accusation wrong and fix this mess. I had absolutely no desire to drag this out any longer than necessary.
"Oh no, not at all. Who said anything about breaking up? If you just come clean with me and tell me honestly what happened, I'll forgive you. Didn't I already tell you? Dimitri has at least five or six girls a night; he's slept with my girlfriends in the past and I've even had his sloppy seconds when I was in the mood."
This took her aback so much that she literally took a step back. "But... you said I was your first girlfriend... your first kiss -- your first EVERYTHING!"
This was actually true. She had been my first everything, and the three years that we'd been going out now felt like a wonderfully perfect dream. So wonderful that it was now suffocating me.
"I lied," I lied with a careless shrug. "You really think I haven't had others? Come on!
Every
girl wants me!"
This successfully reignited her rage. She slapped me for a third time before punching the cast on my right arm before shoving me so hard that I hit my head on the edge of her bed as I fell to the ground.
"FUCK YOU! FUCK THIS SHIT! YOU DON'T WANT TO BELIEVE ME? WELL FINE, FUCKING DO WHAT YOU WANT! BUT DON'T YOU
DARE
ACCUSE ME OF CHEATING JUST BECAUSE YOU TURNED INTO A BASTARD AT SOME POINT AND FUCKED AROUND BEHIND
MY
BACK!"
Having gotten exactly what I wanted, I immediately stopped pushing her. Instead, I simply got up and grabbed my bag, fully intending to leave without another word.
"DON'T YOU EVER COME BACK HERE,
BENJAMIN,
OR I SWEAR I'LL STAB YOU IN THE GUT WITH THE DULLEST PAIR OF SCISSORS I CAN FIND!"
She continued to rant even as I left. I know I had just hurt her worse than I ever wanted to, but it was better to get it over with now rather than months or even years from now when she finally realized that she couldn't love me anymore. After all, I'm never going to be who I was supposed to be. I can no longer be the man I was planning to be, the one who loved her and could make her happy.
From her house, I drove directly to Dimitri's. He saw me enter his room and gestured for me to sit without saying a word. More than that, he kindly let me lay on his bed and brood in silence while he continued to play his game. Eventually, I felt like talking.
"I told Amanda that you confessed to helping her cheat on me."
"
WHAT?!?!
" Dimitri burst out in extreme shock and confusion.
"Then I told her that I've been coming over here to cheat on her with your sloppy seconds."
"WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU DO THAT?!?!" Dimitri roared, clearly still very much shocked and confused.
"Because I can't be with her anymore. Better to let her think I'm a bad guy than a pathetic loser," I admitted.
Dimitri rolled his eyes and shook his head. "Come on man, you only broke your arm!"
I sat up and glared at him. "You say that like this is a temporary condition that I'll recover from and go back to
normal
!"
"That's because it
is