In the light of day, I couldn't believe what had happened.
I'd let an old friend back into my life and he immediately turned it into an opportunity to mess with my mind, calling me a slut and getting me naked and making me grind on his thick, hefty cock.
And then he left me high and dry!
By the time I'd woken up the next morning - after stroking myself to an orgasm that completely coated my chest in pent-up cum - I knew that I couldn't show up at the gym that day. If I did, Peter would just push me even further, turn me into another one of his conquest stories; another dumb slut he'd seduced and fucked the brains out of.
But I wasn't going to let that happen.
As soon as I'd taken some Tylenol and a few glasses of water (It must have been the alcohol, I thought, that's the only way I'd let myself act so... like that), I sent Peter a text.
"Hey, man, I don't think I should go to the gym today. Last night got way out of hand, and I don't think we should see each other again."
I hit send. About fifteen minutes later, I started to feel a bit guilty. It wasn't all Peter's fault, after all. I'm the one that kept thinking that I should end it, I should have just spoken up for myself. And Peter hadn't done anything wrong, really; he thought I was into it, so he encouraged me to keep going.
And, really, I liked hanging out with Peter, even when I wasn't... sitting on his cock, feeling it throb against me... He was a nice guy, when he wasn't calling people sluts.
I wrote out a second message, trying to be more careful this time.
"Sorry, I shouldn't make that sound like your fault. But I do think we went too far, and we should just hang out as friends. I'm still recovering from stuff with Trevor, and I don't think I'm ready to get too sexual."
I sent that message, and felt a little bit better. Not go to the gym and see Peter's throbbing hard cock better, but I was giving Peter a chance to be a friend. And I could use all the friends I could get, really.
I went back to bed for a while, lying down and idly playing with my cock. I was still feeling horny after last night. Too much pent-up energy lately. Plus, it was pretty hot. It's a night I knew I'd be thinking about when jerking off for the next few months, at least, and as a one-off it was a pretty good one. Though I wish I'd had the chance to actually see Peter's cock properly... I could remember the feel of it against my lower back, and the way it throbbed, but I still didn't know if he was cut or uncut, what it looked like, what it tasted like...
Wait, no, not that last one.
I was curious. And like Peter had said, isn't that one of the great things about having gay friends? A bit of flirting, that comfort with sexuality... Maybe it wouldn't hurt anything just to see Peter's cock. Not in a situation like last night, of course, that would be extreme. But there was one way I could get some answers.
After all, Peter had to shower after the gym, right? And he'd mentioned something about the sauna... I'd never been in a sauna. I wondered if it would be all hairy, fat old men. Did people really go naked, or did you keep a towel wrapped around you the whole time?
And there was that other thing. The Beast, he'd called it. The words kept ringing in my head. The Beast.
It was about ten in the morning by the time I sent Peter a third text.
"Maybe you are right about getting more comfortable being naked, though. I mean, it's pretty ridiculous for a guy to be in his late twenties and still not comfortable getting naked with guys."
I winced, but sent it anyways. I was basically asking for him to get me naked again, but maybe it would be worth it. And I was starting to warm up to the idea of... well, not a slutty phase, per se, but getting out there more. After all, half the problem with Trevor had been that he was too boring. A more exciting sex life might be just what the doctor ordered.
Finally, my phone buzzed with a reply.
I snorted as soon as I opened it. Fucking Peter. "Hah, knew you wanted to kick off your slutty phase. Be at the gym in twenty minutes. Bring a jockstrap to change into."
Fucking horn dog. No way I was missing the fact that he was expecting me to change into a jockstrap - he was making sure he got me naked. It was so obvious.
I would have been more comforted by seeing through the ploy if I hadn't found myself throwing a nice black jockstrap in with my gym clothes and driving over to the gym five minutes early. It wasn't that far from home; I probably could have walked, but some insane part of me didn't want to get all sweaty before I even got there. I'd actually toured the gym once, since it was so close, but I'd wussed out. I really was nervous about getting naked around people... the previous night notwithstanding, of course.
Thinking about it made my heart race a little - and my cock to thicken - and I found myself wishing I'd changed before coming over.
When I finally worked up the courage to go in, Peter was leaning against the front desk, chatting with the receptionist. Peter was already dressed in basketball shorts and one of those ridiculous tank tops that was cut so low in the sleeve that he might as well not have worn anything - because of course he was. The second he saw me, Peter left the conversation in mid-sentence, walked over, and pulled me into a big hug.
I was a bit astonished, actually. Maybe things weren't going to be weird after all.
"Hey Geoff," he called back to the receptionist, "This is my little buddy Matty! He's coming for a workout with me today. That's cool, right?"
The receptionist gave me a look up and down that I couldn't quite read. He was a bit scruffy looking - I always thought of gym employees as all being those clean-cut, ex-jocks who ended up making the gym their job when nothing else fit. And the guy was clearly jacked, but he also had a kind of patchy beard and a bunch of tattoos peeking over the collar of his uniform shirt.
"Whatever you say, man," he said with a shrug.
"Thanks! Little Matty's been just begging me to work his ass into shape," Peter went on, giving my ass a firm spank for emphasis.
"Peter!" I whispered, scandalized.
He ignored me and went on, but it didn't escape my notice that his hand was still resting on my butt. "He really appreciates the free tour."
I bit back my complaint, and realized I was being a bit rude to this Geoff guy; he could probably get in a lot of trouble for letting me in without signing up for a membership. "Yeah, thanks, man. I do appreciate it."
Another shrug. "No worries."
Geoff was a man of few words, apparently.
Before I had a chance to try and stumble my way through some small talk, Peter was using his hand on my ass to guide me further into the gym. I didn't have a chance to look back, but I sure hoped Geoff was too bored with existence to pay any attention.