Chapter Two: Occupied
July--August, 1776, Staten Island and Harlem
July 7th, 1776, found Thomas Hadley standing at the top of the front steps, in front of the double front door of his Staten Island estate home. He was watching the approach of the retinue, riding on horseback, of the captain of the British sixty-gun warship, HMS
Yarmouth
, Owen Sheffeld, along the tree-lined avenue. Timothy Grady stood a step below him on the right of the two lines of servants descending the semicircular brick stairs to the graveled forecourt. Perhaps the slight incline of his head toward Timothy was the cause, but whatever prompted it, Captain Sheffeld's eyes went to the young man as he approached astride his horse, his eyes narrowed, and a small, perhaps a bit cruel, smile formed on his lips. Sheffeld was an under-height, spare, almost austere man in his forties, with a ramrod-straight back and an icy stare from his gray eyes that took in everything and assessed all they saw in terms of advantage that could go to the military man.
He made particular note of well-formed young menâmen like Timothy Grady, who, when eyed by Sheffeld, signaled shared interest.
When he saw that he was being noticed, Timothy gave a little smile, batted his long eyelashes, and lowered his eyes in submission. Just as the invitation to a hunt, a stag dinner, and an overnight from Hadley to Sheffeld had been written in a code that two men of similar preferences fully understood what was being offered, the looks that went between Hadley and Sheffeld and then between Sheffeld and Timothy Grady, even before Sheffeld had stepped down from his horse, laid out and sealed a deal. Sheffeld had been invited to Hadley's Staten Island estate to hunt more than deer and pheasants. He had signaled that he was satisfied with the prey.
If Hadley was trying to claim loyalty to the occupying British forces and bidding to have his holdings on Staten Island and, eventually in Manhattan itself, preserved under British occupation, he had found and was playing a valuable negotiation chip. Sheffeld wasn't the senior British officer in the area, but he was the senior British officer with a taste for young men.
Over the past year, the augmentation of the British fleet at the mouth of New York harbor had slowly, almost imperceptibly, increased, adding to the two main warships present, the HMS Asia and HMS
Yarmouth
. Earlier that spring, the British had finally given up on any attempt to expand into the mainland from the besieged city of Boston, and, on March 17th, the British fleet had abandoned Boston and fled to British-held territory at Halifax, Nova Scotia. Not all of the ships went that far, though. Several, transporting large contingents of British and Hessian mercenary soldiers, had gathered off New York. On June 30th, they landed on New York's Staten Island, with 22,000 men, and occupied the island without opposition.
Earlier that winter the Tory sympathizer, Thomas Hadley, had withdrawn from Manhattan where he had increasingly been put under pressure for his political leanings by the colonialists, to his Staten Island estate. Immediately upon the British landing on Staten Island, Hadley had sent a letter setting forth his British sympathies to the captain of the HMS
Yarmouth
, Owen Sheffeld, and had invited the captain to a "men's pleasure" hunt dayâand nightâat his island estate. The merchant had managed to find out that Sheffeld shared his pleasure in men and had made as clear as he could within the code known by such men what sort of enjoyment Sheffeld could receive in an overnight visit to Hadley's estateâthat the night hunt could be as invigorating and satisfying as the day hunt.
Sheffeld accepted the invitation by return messenger.
Dinner in the Hadley estate dining room was rife with testosterone, an all-male affair, Hadley being long widowed and Sheffeld's wife safely left behind in England. They were fresh from the hunt for deer and pheasants on the estate, and though the roasted carcasses they were tearing apart in their shirt sleeves with their bare hands between chugs of ale from mugs that sometimes didn't make it to their mouths were not the same animals they had bagged that day, they were reminded enough of the hunt to make their bloodlust boil.
The hunt itself had been lustful. Sheffeld, a devotee of hunt weekends when at home in England, had been ship bound off the rebellious American colonies for over a year and was anxious to make up for lost hunting pleasure when he, Hadley, Timothy, and Sheffeld's attendants rode into the forest lands of Hadley's extensive Staten Island estate. While Sheffeld's attendants flush out the abundant game, Sheffeld slaughtered enough deer and pheasants that, when they were sent back with him to the HMS
Yarmouth
the next day, they fed the sailors and small contingent of soldiers on the ship for several days. Although Hadley and Timothy did some shooting, their main concern was that Sheffeld was having his full enjoyment of the hunt, and they didn't bring down much to contribute to the almost obscene carnage in the forest.
Deer and pheasants weren't the only game Sheffeld was working on bringing to groundâand in this he had help from both Hadley and Timothy. At Hadley's whispered question and Sheffeld enthusiastic response, the Tory merchant made sure that Sheffeld and Timothy were alone, astride their horses, in a stand of trees at one point.
Timothy made as if he didn't know that Sheffeld was bearing down on him, and exclaimed in pain and expressed his surprise when Sheffeld struck his arm with his riding cropâsupposedly to get his attention but just as likely to warn of Sheffeld's preferences in sex playâand then, when Timothy turned in the saddle, struck at him on the thigh.
"Down off the horse," Sheffeld growled.
"Nay, sir, I don't think that's what you want," Timothy said, looking past the captain.
"Don't tell me what I wantâor answer back."
"You can have what you wantâwhatever you want," Timothy said, "but at the moment I don't think you want to miss out on that." He was gesturing behind Sheffeld, and when the captain turned in the saddle, he saw what Timothy had seenâa twelve-point buck broke out of the trees and ran for open ground. With a yell, Sheffeld made his choice and was galloping off after the buck. Having delivered the tease, Timothy rode back to the house to ensure there would be no further encounter with Sheffeld that afternoon.