πŸ“š stay away from her Part 8 of 9
stay-away-from-her-pt-08
GAY SEX STORIES

Stay Away From Her

Stay Away From Her

by Acerbicscribbler
19 min read
4.55 (1700 views)
mmf threesomebisexual mandudebrowanderwondermfm
Loading audio...

I heard you like sex in your erotica, so I got you some sex in your erotica. You sickos are the absolute best.

October

"Fresh new kicks! And pants, you got it like that so you know you wanna dance," I rap, bouncing Seth in my arms. "So move, out of your seat, and get a fly girl and catch this beat--"

A snort makes me whirl around, which Seth loves.

"Don't let me stop you," Todd laughs from the hallway. "You were killing it."

"Shut up," I reply automatically, but I'm in too good a mood for him to ruin it. MC Hammer and I are keeping my son happy amidst the woes of an ear infection. Seth beats my chest and throws his head back trustingly. I catch him as he plunges toward the floor, and Seth shrieks.

"Moh," he demands, squirming happily. "Moh, moh, moh."

"Your choice of music is...not The Wiggles," Todd comments as he watches me catch Seth again.

"I know what my kid likes," I retort.

He grins. "Next you should teach him 'Splash Waterfalls.'"

"Nah, bro. 'WAP,' because Seth is a feminist."

"Oh for sure."

"Heh. Why are you home?" I catch my thrill-seeking kid again.

"A site visit got canceled, so I don't have to be back at the office until three. I came to see if Seth wanted to go out for lunch. You're allowed to come if you want."

My first reaction is to make a billion legit excuses. Not without Chrisette. Seth is still mostly on baby food; we'd have to pack so much. A restaurant high chair situation is unpredictable. A lot of men's restrooms still don't have changing tables. What if Seth is fussy and we bother everyone else. While I'm still picking which excuse to give, Todd jumps in.

"Listen, I'll be here as backup. The diaper bag is already packed, Chrissy wouldn't care, and if things get too messy we'll pack things up to go."

My brain starts forming even more potential chaos, but Todd throws a stuffed animal at me.

"Come on. If I take Seth alone you'll have me arrested for kidnapping. I want sushi."

"Sushi does sound good," I admit.

Todd claps me on the shoulder like a buddy. "Boys' trip to Fuji Kaitenzushi!"

It occurs to me once we're there that this might be a trap. Here, surrounded by other people, trying to handle feeding ourselves and a baby, we seem normal. Like we get along. I don't know if we look like a family, but it kinda feels like when my parents were still together and they would take me to get a burger if I had a good report card. That little hour when they seemed to like each other because they were proud of me.

Seth mushes rice into his mouth, babbling loudly at anyone passing by.

"He starts so strong," Todd laughs. "He says 'Oh! Hi!' like real words are coming after, and then it's gobbledygook."

I agree. "But he's gotta talk to everybody. I thought babies this age were supposed to have stranger danger." Honestly, this could not have gone better. Seth has been having the time of his life with the chopstick wrappers, I had sushi for the first time in years, and Todd was being extremely neutral. Sure, his foot was touching my foot, but maybe he thought it was a table leg.

Our server, who was really just there to bring drinks and count plates, kept coming back to say hi to Seth. He was fascinated by her, so it gave her a good excuse. At one point she goes, "You're gonna be so much trouble for your dads, aren't you!" and Todd looked so fucking pleased that I didn't correct her. I even had the server take a picture of us to send to Chrisette. She texted back My handsome boys! with a heart eyes emoji.

It isn't until we're almost home that Todd goes, "Thanks for coming with me. It's my mom's--my last foster mom--her birthday, and I didn't feel like being alone all day."

"Oh, uh, sure man. Anytime," I say awkwardly.

I guess last year he would have been with Sasha, and with Chrisette constantly working late maybe I was the only available option. I'm pretty sure Todd has friends. Or maybe he didn't recover from when he and Chrisette imploded their friend group after Sasha caught them together.

"Do you, like, do anything special to remember her?" I ask because 'I miss my dead mom' is kinda heavy to end on.

"Sort of. I try to live like her. Her main thing was making sure we felt stable and loved, so..." he trails off as we get out of his truck.

"Ah, so Seth's first real restaurant experience, shit like that?"

"Yeah, shit like that."

Seth fell asleep in his car seat, and I'm about to pick him up when I allow myself to think a little bit about what Todd was saying. "Do you want to take him inside?"

Todd is clearly surprised. "Take Seth? Yeah, of course." He hustles over and gently unbuckles the car seat. I'm pretty sure he hasn't done this part before, but he looks like a natural. Seth barely stirs when he's picked up, just nestles into Todd's arms like a little angel. I follow them inside with all the baby gear, dumping it on the dining table before a detour to the bathroom. Todd does know how to put Seth down for a nap. I don't need to hover.

I don't have to work, but I grab my tablet anyway and plop down on the couch. Todd does his own thing for a while, at least until he comes out to bother me while he puts his shoes on.

"Some time ago you told me why you stay, but...what if you took Seth with you?" are literally the first words he says since we walked inside.

I twist on the couch to look at him. He's in his I-have-a-meeting clothes, which gives me funny feelings after that one time in the shower. Kinda takes the sting out of my are you stupid glare. "It's my house."

"You have equity," he points out. "Sell it or rent it out."

"Tell me how I'm supposed to leave my wife." That's not exactly what I mean. What I mean is for him to tell me how to leave Chrisette. Live wire Chrisette, intoxicating Chrisette, the first woman who really saw value in me, who invested in me as a human being, who married me, who bore my child. How do I turn my back on her? When she needs me the most, how do I walk away?

And when she's gone, and Todd with her, like,...those early weeks of solo parenting were some of the hardest of my life. I can admit that I'm scared of doing that again

Todd, however, shakes his head. "Be honest, Jesse. If you want monogamy, Chrisette has made it pretty clear that she's never going to be that person."

"Was she cheating on me the whole time?" I ask before I can stop myself.

"Do you mean like, did Chrissy have another boyfriend, or did she just hook up with a random guy once in a blue moon?" Todd clarifies, though that tells me everything I didn't want to know.

"There's nothing wrong with wanting monogamy," I mutter bitterly.

"No, but if that's so important to you then why not look for someone who feels the same way?"

I thought I had. "So if I'm gone you and Chrisette can fuck everyone you want, together. That's real precious."

Maybe because he's determined to keep the good mood of sushi lunch going, Todd doesn't match my anger. "For one, being polyamorous is not the same as pansexual. It's how you prefer being in relationships versus whom you're attracted to."

"Bullshit."

"Are you thinking about us?" He says it so casually that I flush. "I'll admit that early on, I was most interested in knocking you off your high horse."

"Ha."

He did, that's for damn sure. More importantly, I don't like hearing "us" come out of his mouth.

Todd sighs as he stands. "You know, I got held back in school. Twice."

What does that have to do with anything?

He goes on. "The first time was kindergarten, which is not uncommon, but the second time I was in junior high."

"What happened?" I ask in spite of myself.

"New foster family that wasn't working out--some of them don't give a shit as long as they get their stipend from the state." Todd shrugs. "I got suspended for skipping, I stopped trying, I dunno. I think I'd been in survival mode with no coping mechanisms and it all just caught up to me. The only reason I even graduated high school is because of my mom."

πŸ“– Related Gay Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

"Why are you telling me this?"

"Because I see you drowning, man. I want to help, but you're determined to stay underwater."

I can't believe my ears. This motherfucker--

"That came out wrong," Todd apologizes, giving me the old calm down hands. "What I meant is that I am trying really hard to change the way you and I relate to each other, and I wish you would let me."

Whatever my face is telling him, Todd laughs a little. "We can at least be on the same team. Team Seth and Chrisette."

"Okay," I agree grouchily.

He shakes his head, but he's smiling. "Jesus. You might be the most stubborn man I've ever met."

"Oh, I'm stubborn? Me?" I gesture so wildly with my stylus that I nearly poke my eye out. "Todd, why are you here? You could have literally anyone you wanted, but you're fucking with my marriage."

He gives me a smarmy little grin. "Anyone I wanted, huh?"

"No, dude," I groan. "I didn't mean it like that, obviously. I'm saying that you're calculating enough to, like, weasel your way into whatever relationship you want."

"Maybe this is exactly what I want."

"Bullshit."

"Almost," he says, looking sideways at me.

Even across the room he feels too close. I lean away.

Todd smiles. "You couldn't tell?" His tone is soft, warm, gentle. It gives me goosebumps.

"What are you talking about, dude?" I ask nervously. "You're being fucking weird."

Rolling his eyes, Todd walks out of the room, calling, "Sure, Jesse," over his shoulder.

October, still

It's well after midnight when I hear the front door open. Before I have the chance to roll over and check, Todd grumbles from the far side of the bed.

"The fuck is that?"

I sigh. "I'll go look."

There has to be a word for the feeling of being completely shocked and immediately unsurprised. Of course it would be Chrisette with a strange man. Some college-aged dummy who is as drunk as my wife, struggles to unzip his pants while Chrisette tosses her shirt across the room. She sees me, giggles, waves a condom packet around, and goes back to removing her clothes. I head back to bed.

"Is it Chrissy?" Todd mumbles tiredly when I climb back in.

"And some guy. Looks like a frat boy," I reply.

"You gotta be fucking kidding me."

I let out a sigh. "Nope. This is what it's like."

"Sorry, man. Sorry."

At that moment, at least, I completely believe him.

November

"I want Todd there."

My response is immediate. "Absolutely not." On the first date night we'll have since Seth was born?

"I need him," Chrisette insists, yanking the fitted sheet over a corner of the mattress. "Just for when we get home. With you, I've had trouble letting go of all this heaviness and negativity, and that is preventing me from achieving orgasm."

Oh, come on.

"How is Todd going to solve that problem?" I ask sarcastically, tossing her one side of the flat sheet. "Hypnosis?"

"He has naturally positive energy--"

I point at his side of the bed. "The Todd that I know? He does not."

"

And

," Chrisette finishes, "there hasn't been a time when we've had sex and I didn't come at least once. So even if he's just there to give encouragement, that'll be enough."

I put my hands up. "Hang on. Were you faking it with me? Am I total shit in bed?"

She folds her arms. "Don't make this about you, Jesse."

"I'm half the equation here! Just tell me, please."

"No, you're not shit, it's just..."

"Do I need to munch more on that sweet puss?" I ask, wiggling my eyebrows to disguise how soul-crushing this conversation suddenly got. Thankfully, Chrisette laughs.

"That's never

not

what I'm saying," she chuckles, "but it's seriously a mental block. It's not your fault, baby, but when we're together the weight of our responsibilities really hampers my sex drive. And I want to be able to enjoy you."

On the one hand, I'm confused about how bringing in Todd will help with that libido-sucking mental load she's carrying. On the other hand, she called me baby and is offering me sex.

I frown, but agree. "For you, one time, and never again."

Chrisette winds her arms around my waist. "My good little Grumpy Dimple Boy," she sings, and kisses me. "And shave the beard. This is going to be really good for us. I promise."

I'm too chickenshit to ask what she's hoping it'll do for me in particular. Or to ask Todd how he's handling the whole thing. In fact, I manage to extra avoid him right until date night.

"Seth is getting a bath tonight," Todd says as he walks in the living room. "I think he has broccoli in his hair."

"Oh, okay. Thanks."

I don't know why I'm so nervous to go out with the woman I married. Maybe because I can see my chin for the first time in a year and it's weird.

"Is this tie-shirt combo okay?" I ask Todd worriedly. I've never been to the ballet before, but Chrisette wants to see it. There are a lot of opinions online about what to wear to the ballet, and none of it was helpful.

"It's good. You look..." He scans me up and down and then gives me a pointed smile. "...edible."

πŸ”“

Unlock Premium Content

Join thousands of readers enjoying unlimited access to our complete collection.

Get Premium Access

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

I flip him off. Todd snaps his teeth, which for some reason makes me laugh.

"You're fuckin' stupid sometimes," I say.

"Sometimes you're the best of us, Jesse."

Just as I'm about to tell him to fuck off I realize that he's being sincere. "Wait, what?"

Chrisette walks out of the hall at that moment and I have to catch my breath. If that dress were cut any lower I'd be able to see her belly button. It clings to every single curve on her body, the modest black doing nothing to hide the roundness of her breasts. Her hair is in some simple updo that shows off her graceful neck, her full lips are red, and her dark eyes are soft and welcoming. "Hot damn," I exhale, and she grins at me.

"You like?" she asks playfully, turning around so I can see the sparkly zipper that goes all the way down the back of her dress.

"I don't know if I can make it through dinner," I reply, and Chrisette laughs.

It's like old times. The good times, when we had things to talk about that weren't us, and funny stories that we'd saved until we could tell them to each other in person. When I would look at her and be so fucking grateful that she chose to spend even a second of her day with me.

We're almost finished with dinner when a line of servers approaches our table with melodicas and tambourines. "What the hell?" I say under my breath to Chrisette. She bites her lip, trying and failing to hold back a mischievous grin. She's pointing her phone at me...oh no.

"Happy birthday!" shouts our waitress, producing a plate full of Italian cream cake. The rest of the servers burst into song, the restaurant's version of "Happy Birthday To You." There's a paper crown involved.

"What have you done?" I mouth at my wife, who is outright giggling at this point. My face is so hot you could fry a fucking egg on it.

The servers wrap up with a big hooray, and the entire fucking restaurant starts applauding. I'm going to have to leave a bigger tip than I planned.

"I wanted free cake," Chrisette says with a shrug, dragging the plate towards her.

I knock her fork away with mine. "This cake is the product of my humiliation." It tastes damn good, though.

"I told them they weren't going to see your ID because you don't drink. I made this happen," she argues, and nabs a bite while I'm preoccupied with the heaven in my mouth.

"We could have just ordered dessert."

Chrisette shrugs cutely. "But...free cake."

There's a little whipped cream on her lip when I kiss her. "You're fucking adorable," I growl at her.

"So you've said," she says with a grin.

We go to the ballet after. Maybe it's the glass of wine she had with dinner, maybe it's the tight pants on all the dude dancers, but Chrisette is handsy with me the whole time. She strokes my thigh, plays with my hand, runs her fingers over the back of my neck...I will go to the ballet every day with her if this is how she's gonna behave.

She's even bolder during the car ride home, tracing my cock through my pants until I have to beg her to let me concentrate. When I pull up to the house my erection starts to go down a little. I can't believe I forgot that the exciting part about this whole night for Chrisette might be this threesome of her design.

Her fucking boyfriend is hanging out in the living room like he's chaperoning us naughty kids. Todd smiles at Chrisette as we walk in. "How was it?"

"Hot," she says, and kisses him. It stops me in my tracks. They've been so careful not to be all lovey dovey in front of me, except for that one time when they thought I was asleep after I had that panic attack. Or maybe he was careful and Chrisette went along with it? Because Todd seems a little uncomfortable for half a second.

Or maybe I'm just seeing what I want to see.

I agreed to this. I agreed to all of it

, I remind myself as Chrisette gets out a set of shot glasses and pulls the good vodka from the freezer.

Holy shit, this is really happening.

I join her in the kitchen and Todd leans on the bar, asking about dinner.

Fuck fuck fuck.

Chrisette describes the ballet in detail. I only remember her hands. My system is so overwhelmed that I don't know if I'm excited or terrified.

Todd glances at me before asking, "What do you want, Chrissy?"

Chrisette hands him a shot glass. "Play nice," she instructs us.

Todd raises his shot to her and downs it. "You sure you don't want one of these, Babe? You look a little anxious."

I say nothing. Of course I'm anxious. This is more nerve wracking than my wedding day. And I ended up getting fucked then, anyway.

Chrisette smacks her lips together and pours another drink. "One for my little piglet," she declares, holding the glass to me. "We'll take care of you."

Todd puts his hand over the shot. "I was kidding; don't give me those cow eyes," he teases me.

I give him a look that I hope says

Help get me out of this

, but either he doesn't understand or he doesn't care. Should I take the shot? No, I'm already worried about my performance. Has it really been a year since Chrisette and I had sex? Maybe even longer, since she wasn't even up for it during that last month or so of pregnancy. The last thing I want to do is be compared to Todd in the sack and come in second place.

Chrisette's soft lips on mine bring me back to the present. "You're so tense, baby. Can you focus on me for a bit?"

"Always," I say with a smile, because after all that teasing I still really, really want to fuck.

Chrisette slings back another shot, shuddering cutely at the burn. "Will you trust me?"

"Mm hm." I glance at Todd, but he's pouring yet another round. Anyway, with Chrissy's soft breasts against me, I'm already getting more on board with whatever's going on.

"Can you follow instructions, Babe?" she presses. "Are you going to try something new?"

I feel my eyes get really wide. "Uh..." Is she about to ask me to get fucked? I'm not an actor; if she really wants to see me and Todd together I don't know how to pretend like it's the first time.

Todd cuts in. "Be gentle, Chrissy." He leans across the bar to touch my arm lightly. "Don't worry, man. Team Chrisette."

Team Chrisette. Right.

I let her lead me into the bedroom, a big part of me wanting to run screaming through the walls and the other part is like,

Hooray, I'm gonna get my dick wet!

Chrisette pushes me to sit on the bed, then whispers in Todd's ear. He laughs and points her to the bathroom.

"What's happening?"

Todd gestures toward the hallway. "Just a quick freshen up if she wants, you know, ass play."

My eyes go wide. "

She

wants it?"

"When I asked what she wanted out of a threesome, it came up," he says casually.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like