This story is for mature readers only. The events described below are all entirely fictitious and intended to be just fantasy.
I remained motionless, sprawled across my wrestling coach's desk, feeling a rivulet of cum starting to trickle out of my stretched hole, coming to grips with having Coach Thomas commit my first homosexual act on me. I started sensing motion around me, noticing my four teammates crowding in on my naked body, feeling several fingers start to probe the remains of my previously virgin asshole; pressing one all the way in, feeling a long, slender finger press knuckle-deep against my sore anal ring.
"Shit dude, coach really wrecked Jakey's ass!" one of them said as I felt two more fingers join the first inside me, increasing the trickle of semen dribbling out, passing between their invading fingers. "Fuck... it really does look and feel like a pussy now. Definitely starting to bone up just playing with Jake's sloppy pussy. We been holding in this load for far too long... how do we figure who gets Coach's sloppy seconds, boys?"
I recognized the voice to be Liam. He was part of my freshman orientation tour. After I got back from disappearing with those two chicks, he extended a hand for a fist bump, knowing what had happened. From that interaction, I kinda figured he also was the type to never turn down a chance to get his dick wet.
I soon felt the fingers retreating from my hole and then replaced by something a lot larger than a finger, pushing hard against my sore, swollen hole. Recalling the feeling of Coach Thomas's massive mushroom cockhead invading me, I quickly realized that one of my teammates was now pressing their dick into me. I struggled to crane my neck up off coach's desk to see what was happening in the room. Coach Williams was sitting fully naked in Coach Thomas's chair, stroking his dick. Liam had completely undressed and was now standing nearby with his massive, pale dick bobbing freely in front of the team. Victor and Caleb were stripping down. I couldn't see Andrés.
"Shit dudes... also feels like a pussy!" the voice behind me said as I felt his invading cock slide past my ring, pressing balls deep within seconds. "Coach even got it wet and lubed for us. Let's try to get Jakey pregnant. Only rule, no pulling out tonight boys."
Based on what I had seen and the voice coming from behind me, I understood that Andrés was now balls deep inside me. My mind brought up the image of him laying on his bed in our dormroom, waving his erection at me. My mind recalled images of precum starting to glisten off his cockhead that first night as I started feeling every vein lining his shaft grind across my insides. Without a pause, he began vigorously pumping his dick in and out of my body. I'm figuring that after three months without sex, all four guys will be eager and primed to fuck me as hard as they can... I know I would.
Andrés pulled me up by my hair. "Liam looks like he's ready to let you practice your cocksucking skills some more. He's almost as big as coach and I want to watch you suck that ginger's pretty cock."
Liam stepped up in front of me, occupying the spot Coach Williams had stood during the first challenge his dick entering my field of view. Andrés was right, Liam was almost as huge as Coach Thomas. Jutting out from a fiery red bush was a huge eleven-inch, pale cock.
"Just like coach, chicks complain about how big it is," Liam muttered through a malicious grin. "But unlike coach, I always find a way to squeeze every last inch in. It's kinda hot and fun watching them squirm as that last inch gets pressed in. And now, I'll help you learn how to deep throat before I get a turn with that pussy."
I had opened my mouth to protest and beg Coach Williams to intervene. Without slowing down his vigorous pounding of my hole, Andrés pressed my open mouth directly onto Liam's outstretched dick. "Don't be shy Jakey," Andrés whispered into my ear. "We saw how much you seemed to enjoy sucking Coach Thomas and Coach Williams, but it looks like you aren't that good. You know you need the practice... and honestly, we know you need it too in order to become the best slut this team needs. But don't worry, Jakey baby, we're here for you to help you... and help keep your secret. We don't need anyone outside the team finding out one of our best wrestlers is a dickless cocksucker."
Andrés kept his grip on my head steady so that with every movement of his hips and dick, his arm sawed my throat back and forth onto Liam's dick, treating my mouth like a fleshjack.
"See how easy it is to suck dick, Jakey? I think you're starting to get better." Liam grunted, his cock pressing deep in my throat, his lose hairless balls colliding with my chin. "Most chicks love the taste of my dick once they get my cock drooling on their tongues. Taste that precum. You're gonna get hooked on it and begging to suck my dick daily."
Both jocks coordinated their thrusts into a rhythm as the began to fuck me from both ends, plowing me with long, hard thrusts. Liam's cock had started heavily leaking precum, I could feel his goo coating my throat and my tongue. I couldn't tell about Andrés and his precum. Coach had shot so much of his cum into me, my hole was constantly squelching and drooling cum with every pump of his dick. I could feel a steady trickle of semen running down the back of my ballsack.
"Fuck dude..." Andrés groaned, grinding his hips against my ass. "Jakey's brand new jockpussy's getting me close to busting! Coach's cum has made his pretty little virgin pussy feel flooded with a fucking ocean of sperm. I'm about to drown this jockpussy with three months of mine. Fuck... fuck I can feel Coach's load getting my dick all slick and wet."
Andrés picked up his pace, tightly gripping the round mounds of my jockbuttt while he pounded my hole. I continued struggle to accommodate Liam's massive cock in my mouth. Even though my throat had been stretched wide by Thomas's python, I was having difficulty taking a single breath with his dick's near-constant plugging of my throat.