(Please read Parts 1-4 before starting this one.)
Rick and I slid back into the corners of the hot tub and turned to look at Ted.
He was still hunched over, hands on knees, but his breathing had returned almost to normal and he was looking back at us.
After a long awkward pause he finally spoke.
"So are you guys gay?"
"Not exactly," I said.
I told him about how we'd started exploring on vacation with our wives -- taking up where we'd left off in college -- and that we'd been trading blow jobs in the weeks since.
"We still love our wives but we found out we enjoy doing this on the side," Rick said.
Ted took some time to process this.
"Why did you get me involved?"
"Well," Rick said, "the truth is that I had had some fantasies about sex with men even before that vacation, and I had thought you might be open to it. I never acted on it because I was afraid I might be wrong. Was I?"
Ted took a long time to answer.
"Well, no, if I'm being honest. I have wondered about it, too, ever since my divorce. Before that, actually."
"Oh?" Rick said. "Tell us about that."
"When I was a teenager, junior high maybe, I used to get teased about my big dick in gym. I know it sounds like a good problem to have, the biggest cock in the locker room, but it wasn't, really. Guys were always staring at me, pointing and elbowing each other. It made me feel kind of freakish.
"When I got a little older, and started dating girls, things got a little better. Some girls are put off by a big cock, but a lot are intrigued. I had one girlfriend who loved to suck it -- though she never got as much in her mouth as Tom just did. When we tried to fuck, though, she said it hurt too much.
"Later I had a college girlfriend who was able to take it all in, but we broke up for other reasons.
"Just after I graduated from college I ran into a guy I hadn't seen since junior high. He had come out as gay, and over drinks he said he had always admired my dick and wondered if I'd ever let a guy touch it. I said I hadn't, and he said he'd love to be the first.
"At time I was desperate for sex I said OK. We went back to his place, I took off my pants, and he immediately started sucking me. He got all but an inch or so in his throat, and then he let me fuck his mouth.
"We did that several times over the next couple of months. Then he found out he was getting transferred out of town. We had one last night together, then he was gone.
"A year or so later I met my ex. She loved my cock, but at some point she met another guy and after a while she was gone, too."
"Any girlfriends since then?" Rick asked.
"No," he said.
"Boyfriends?"
"None of those either."
"So tonight was..."
"....the first time I've had sex with another person in about four years."
Rick whistled.
"And how did you like it?"
"Well," he said. "I was so surprised when you put your hand on me that I couldn't think straight. I don't think I really registered what was going on till you started sucking me. After that it seemed pretty damn great."
He gave us a big smile. Then a puzzled look came over his face.
"Did you guys plan this?"
"Kinda," Rick said. "Like I said, I had thought about approaching you before. When you offered me the cabin, it seemed like the perfect opportunity."
"What was that about double or nothing?"
"Rick bet me he could get you to have sex with us within an hour after dinner."
"So you won the bet?"
"I did, but I lost it again when Tom got more of your cock in his mouth than I did."
Ted stared at us for a second, then burst out laughing. It was the first time since we'd arrived that he seemed to be truly enjoying himself.
"Well, that's kind of tacky, but I guess I don't mind. I got something out of it, too."
"Glad you enjoyed it," I said. "That was some load of cum you had."
"It's been a few days since I came," he said.
We were quiet for a second before Ted spoke again.
"You didn't ask me the obvious question."
"What's that?" Rick asked.
"Whether I returned the favor and sucked my gay friend."
"Did you?"
"Yes, a few times."
"Did you like it?"
"Very much."
"Would you like to try it again?"
"Sure," he said. "But let's take this inside. I'm getting chilled out here."
We gathered up our things, Ted turned off the tub and we headed up to the cabin, still naked.
Once inside Ted showed me where he kept some old quilts and suggested I spread them on the floor in front of the fireplace. Meanwhile he got a fire going and Rick opened another bottle of wine.
I also noticed that Rick got a small tube of lube out of his duffel bag and put it on the floor within reach.