June 2002
I met Casey at just before 9 AM. He was the last person we were picking up on our road trip to a comic book convention. In the front seat of the 4Runner were my friends Donny and Phil. The trip from where we picked Casey up on the north side of Milwaukee to Indianapolis was supposed to be just about 5 hours, so I'd probably get to know the guy.
At 9:45 we stopped for traveling drinks and snacks. By then, I knew Casey was 22, a student at UW-Milwaukee going for Veterinary Science. He lived with his older brother and his wife, was interested in Marvel comics and old Sad Sack strips. He wanted to get a vet practice in the small northern Wisconsin town he'd come from.
10:00 or so Donny and Phil had both started to give Casey some good-natured crap about how he still wasn't out to his brother and the guy's wife. His retort was that he would when he'd start to bottom. Donny said, "Joe'll show you how to bottom...he's the best bottom in the vehicle."
10:25 the razzing had stopped and we'd started talking in general about experiences, some general, some sexual, some very explicit.
11:00 Casey and I were talking one-on-one. "So, are you one of those serious...what...power bottoms?"
"No," I replied, "Not at all. I'm a bottom when I need to be a bottom. I top when I need to top. I keep myself open minded as much as I can." I smiled.
11:15. We'd finished some of our chat and were chilling out. Casey slid back in his seat, and I side-eyed his crotch. There was an impressive bulge. I noted it.
Five minutes to noon we started playing a road game, sort of a truth or dare thing. Phil, 32 years old, slender in a wiry, runners build had gotten the first 'sketchy' dare and was now sitting nude in the passenger seat. He'd also mouthed Donny for a few moments.
12:05 I got my first dangerous dare, which was to also undress. Casey paid a great deal of attention to what I was doing. I was solid at the time, a bit of extra padding in spots that would be worthwhile when I was climbing glaciers. He was watching pretty intently as my pants and underwear slipped off, my six and half inches most of the way to erect.