a-unicorn-goes-hunting
GROUP SEX STORIES

A Unicorn Goes Hunting

A Unicorn Goes Hunting

by Juanseiszfitzhall
19 min read
3.95 (7700 views)
threesomebisexuallesbiananalingusfellatio
Loading audio...

(

Note to readers:

As always, all characters in sexual situations are at least 18 years old. I don't think anything here would count as triggering, but you can check the tags for details of the sex. Enjoy!)

***

It was their fourth date. Elise had seldom gone out with a man this much. These days, she never agreed to sex through the third date, and this drove most guys away.

At the end of Date Three, Grant frowned when Elise said goodnight, as they left the movie theater. But when she added that she wanted to spend time with him again, he agreed to her request for her to set up another date.

Now they were seated at a table in a rooftop tavern, on a nice autumn night, meeting just for drinks. She presented herself now with more allure than she had before. Dress, hair, and makeup emphasized her positives. He saw this. She saw that he saw.

He, however, was about the same as he had been before. He wore a sport coat over a turtleneck, with those and the pants in mild earth tones. He remained clean-shaven, despite a vague jawline. Elise read this to mean that Grant was willing to show himself as who he was, even if he knew that his appearance wouldn't impress anyone.

Elise had gained this knowledge of him through their times together. She studied the men she dated closely. Elise's site profile stated, 'We begin as strangers. I'll need a lot of time to get to know you.' This bluntness probably led many men to swipe past her.

"Thanks for hanging on with me, Grant," she said after a sip of wine. "I'd like to keep things going with you. But it's only fair for me to tell you something that may make you drop me."

He blinked. After a moment he said, "Okay...go ahead."

I don't want to ruin everything, Grant,

she thought,

but you should know what you're dealing with.

She leaned forward and lowered her voice. "This is in two parts. The first part is, I'm bisexual. The second is, I only want to be with a woman if she's part of a married couple. I'd like to live with one man, but not be in threesomes with him. I'd want plain vanilla sex with my home partner, threesomes with couples elsewhere. Does that make any sense?"

Grant looked stunned.

In a reflex, Grant glanced around. He saw few other tables occupied. He wondered if Elise expected this relative privacy, and chose this location accordingly.

"I...don't think I get it," he said, also in a lowered voice. "I mean, if you're attracted to women as well as men, that's no problem. Uh, for me. But why wouldn't you, ahh, want to do that with, um, the man, that you're with?"

She sat up straighter, and tried to gesture meaning with her hands. She realized that maybe she hadn't rehearsed this speech enough. "See, the experience I've had, shows me what I like most. I like having a boyfriend, and doing things together with him--out in the world, and, um, in the bedroom. Being with a boyfriend makes me calm. 'Going steady' means just that to me, a steadiness in my life."

She smiled, but again lowered her voice. "But once that steadiness is there, I'll feel safer...well, to fly my freak flag. To hook up with a man and a woman, and have fun with both of them."

He was quick to say, "But the man isn't your boyfriend?"

Elise saw that he'd gone from confused to annoyed. She said, "I know that this is a big load for anyone to carry. Any man. I may not be worth it, to you. That's why I wanted us to have this talk now. If you want us to part ways, I understand."

He leaned back in his chair, and looked up at the clear night sky. Then he looked at her.

To her surprise, he grinned.

"Of all the excuses I've ever heard from women who dumped me," he said, "yours is the most creative."

Now she was the one who was stunned. Her mouth dropped open, but words were not available.

"Tell me, Elise," he said. "What's your next step if I accept this situation? Because I

can

accept it. I can be the boyfriend you leave alone when you unfurl your freak flag--as long as you don't do it

too

often." He chuckled, then said, "Your move."

She stared at him for a moment. It surprised her that she hadn't seen this depth of self-awareness in him--despite all of her 'studying.' But it pleased her that the depth existed, and showed up now. His dark humor didn't worry her, because he seemed to direct it at himself.

"My next move," she said, feeling a smile claim her mouth, "is to welcome you to the next stage in your boyfriend audition! I hope you were honest about your acceptance. But that wouldn't have to be tested for a long time. Tonight...I'm ready for us to find out how boyfriendly and girlfriendly we can be. If you're interested in that."

His smug look vanished. This pleased her even more.

He really thought I was dumping him!

she thought.

Back to your move, Grant!

He recovered. "Just because I let you escape me on the third date," he said, "you think I'm not interested?"

She laughed. "Just making sure." Then she took a breath. Then she said, "I'm inviting you to my place. You should know that I'll have someone checking up on my safety. I don't think you're dangerous, Grant, but a bad misunderstanding, when things get physical, could be enough to cause big problems."

He nodded. "I expect we'll talk, before things get physical."

She smiled, from both comfort and excitement. "It seems like you've gotten to know me."

"I've paid attention." He picked up his gin and tonic, and stared into the glass as he swirled it. Feeling a bit snarky, he said, "All I've been allowed to do is watch and listen."

Her voice took on an edge. "You'll be welcome to do more. If you lose that attitude."

He met her eyes. His attention-paying now recorded that she wasn't always sweet.

Is she now showing me more of her real self?

he wondered.

Does that mean she thinks this can work? With me?

"Sorry," he said.

She brought her phone from her purse. With a friendlier smile, she said, "Here's my address."

***

Their talk was brief. They found a good deal of overlap in the vanilla activity they were willing to try.

In the half-dimmed lighting in her bedroom, they disrobed separately, interspersed with kisses and hugs. Then there was manual and oral foreplay. During the latter, they murmured yes-yes-do-thats, and the 'thats' got them into quite a lather.

She arranged them for legs-up missionary. She fingered aside her moist labia, while he slowly pushed between them his condomed glans. Then she switched to rubbing her clitoris. "S-someday," said Elise, "I might give you th-this task. But now, just keepthatthing, of yours, g-going in there!"

Grant just nodded, wheezing. She was tight where he was thick, giving them both strong rushes. He pumped when he could, but had to stop when he got too close, and then resume slowly. He didn't tell her that the condom made it easier for him. Bareback, he might have blasted on entry.

πŸ“– Related Group Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

Elise's compact body had some wasted ounces, notably at her midriff and upper arms. Grant nonetheless found her attractive. He hoped to give her whatever pleasure she needed, for her to keep him as, at least, a friend with benefits. He had gone more than a year without sex, and much longer without a true girlfriend.

"G-getting close," she huffed. "Can you keep going?" She wasn't attracted to his naked self. In the half-light, his body hair mercifully blurred his fleshiness. Yet his cock stayed rigid even through his pauses, and her pussy kept wanting more.

He squinted, head tipped back, and gripped her raised legs along his torso. She hadn't expected that, and it got her started. "Yeahyeah! There yeah!" She spasmed on his dick, three times, more, and hoped he'd feel it. She let go of her clit, now too sensitive.

Elise gasped into a laugh. "Go for it, Grant! You fucked a bi girl and, and, made her cum! Yay!"

He sped up. She felt his putz throb, and her old primal fear of sperm kicked in. When she felt softness, she said, "Done?"

"Yeah," he said. Awkwardly he leaned back, and let go of her legs. His dork slid free of her vulva.

Elise leaned to the nightstand and brought the lamp to full brightness. She peered closely at the latex that began to wrinkle as Grant shrank.

It looks okay,

she thought.

He mumbled, "How'd my audition go?"

"I'll have to sleep on it. With you."

Having established the physical aspect of their boy- and girlfriendliness, they settled into pillow talk. Grant took it past what they had just done.

"I imagine I have the same fantasies as most straight guys," said Grant. "So, naturally, the idea of being the M in an FMF throuple is dynamite. But I think it's clear, from the way you wore me out, that I might not deliver the goods for both Fs."

"If this is what I get from my boyfriend every night," she said, putting on the husky voice tone she knew sounded sexy, "I will be very happy." Then her word choice worried her: 'Will' instead of 'would.' Was she already deciding that Grant was the one?

"Still, I have to ask," he said, "why wouldn't you want to bring in another woman to join with your boyfriend?"

Elise hadn't rehearsed this part, and if Grant wasn't 'the one,' she should hold back. Part of the fun she hoped for was in the tension she'd cause in the married couple. She didn't want that tension to exist in her one-on-one relationship. She wanted her domestic life to be calm and restful, something she could return to after an excursion that was intense, surprising, even risky.

She also believed that causing tension to a boyfriend wouldn't be fair to him. The man now stroking the hair on her neck seemed calm. She thought,

I should allow him to stay that way

.

She decided to say this: "I don't want to hunt unicorns. I want to be a unicorn."

To herself she added,

And the one who does the hunting.

"I think I believe you," he said. "But please understand why I'm a little...concerned. Let's say you tell me that you have a date with a couple. How would I know that you actually have sex with women? That you're not just meeting a single guy?"

She pulled a face. The edge returned to her voice. "I don't happen to have any videos of my sapphic excursions. Will you settle for a testimonial?"

While he puzzled over that, Elise got her phone and placed a call.

"Hi, Rowena. It's, let's see, nineteen minutes before you were scheduled to call. Turns out, everything is fine. I'd like you to talk to my date."

Grant was still flummoxed when Elise handed him the phone.

Into his ear, a woman's voice declared, "Whoever you are, you better treat my ex right. And don't go thinking you'll ever win her over to your side. Just because she has this fascination with penises, she's still a dyke, and someday she'll accept it."

"Um...okay, thanks for the advice."

Elise took back the phone and, smiling, said, "Thanks, Ro. Nighty-night."

"Now then," said Elise to Grant, stroking the hair on his chest, "Is your mind at ease? Can we go to sleep?"

***

Elise met Rowena at their usual hangout, an arts-district coffee joint where conversation could be open. Very,

very

open.

"I was hoping he'd be a scumbag," said Rowena, "and you'd beg to be rescued. So I could charge in at the vanguard of the Lesbian Defense Strike Force."

"Sorry, Honey," said Elise with a theatrical sigh. "He turned out to be a nice guy. Out of respect to him, I don't want to go into more detail."

Rowena rolled her eyes. "What, you think I'm going to dish about him to my social circle? We have, shall I say, essentially no interest in gettin' busy with Y-chromosome types."

"Ro, I'm serious," Elise returned. "I like him, and I think he could be hurt if I'm not careful."

Rowena sipped her brew, looking over the top of the cup at Elise. Then she said, "He may not be the only one who could get hurt. You seem a bit fragile yourself."

Elise looked at the table. It took a while for her to say, "Dating is a giant bite in the butt. Everything about it. Doing it on my terms has weeded out guys who needed to be weeded, but it seems like it could drive away all guys. Grant might be as good as it gets. I'm twenty-eight, I need to see some success!"

She stopped, only then realizing that she'd raised her voice.

"Poor little bi girl," said Rowena. "Do you count it as 'success' only if you get your dream sheet? Boyfriend stuck at home while you go out and play unicorn?"

Elise glared at her ex. "Yes. And don't sneer at me. The L in LGBTQ needs to respect the B. It was, what, twenty years ago when Q-world finally started to accept bi? Are you going to go all pick-a-lane on me?"

"Plenty of people out there never get anything. You want a smorgasbord."

"You think I don't know what it's like, not getting anything? What about those bar crawls when you ditched me for some pretty fem?"

Rowena looked away, and muttered, "I was drunk."

"Several times!"

"You could always just go find a guy."

"Because I had to!"

An aproned waiter hurried up to their table. "Anybody need a refill?"

Rowena snorted a chuckle. "Does it sound like we should have more caffeine?"

"Thanks, Ned," said Elise, smiling. "You're a fine actor. That was an excellent entrance."

"Thank you!" he said, and set small flyers on their table. "We open next month. Previews in three weeks. Show this and get two dollars off."

πŸ”“

Unlock Premium Content

Join thousands of readers enjoying unlimited access to our complete collection.

Get Premium Access

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

And then he was gone. Elise was again able to look at tall, blonde Rowena as an old friend, rather than as a drama-roiled ex-lover. Rowena's smile seemed to show the same.

Yet the drama had happened, for more than a year. It had led Elise to try to find a calm, steady home life with the male of the species. And go after ladies who'd only dabble in lesbianism, with their husbands present.

Rowena asked, "Will you want the Strike Force to be on call when you get into a throuple?"

"No," said Elise, imagining a different kind of drama. "For that, I should ask the person who'd be most affected."

***

For a while, Elise kept her life simple. She continued to date Grant. Sometimes there was sex, sometimes not. There was always talk, which moved gradually from current life details to long-term goals. Elise's hope to become a unicorn was never mentioned, but Grant believed that a different creature--an elephant--was always somewhere on the premises.

In time, the premises were his. He lived in a townhouse, and he and Elise got serious enough for her to move in with him when her apartment lease ended.

"Twelve months, okay?" she said as she piled up boxes next to her furniture, in the room he'd cleared for her. "I won't do anything then that'll make you uncomfortable. If I bring something up, be honest how you feel about it."

"I will."

She tested that during their third month of cohabiting. She showed him a website that catered to open relationships.

"I'd like to establish a presence here," she said, looking at him very closely as he looked at her laptop.

"Go ahead."

"I'll give you the login and passcode."

"You don't have to--"

"Yes, Grant, I do." She wanted to grab him, hug him, kiss him deep, but she didn't. It would seem like pre-guilt. Yet she wanted that contact with him. It had become an important part of her comfort, as their relationship had deepened. Like the placement of his hands when they hugged, his left hand at the base of her left shoulder blade, his right just above her right pelvic dimple.

He nodded. Then he looked at her. "Will it make this easier on you if I start being...open?"

"I know you're not interested. So, no."

He chortled a little, then stopped himself. Her 'not interested' interpretation put him in a more favorable light than he put himself. His life experience had given Grant no reason to believe that any random woman would be sexually interested in him. He had made this much progress with Elise only because they had taken time to get to know each other. He was also convinced that some of her affection for him arose from his willingness to let her (eventually, sometimes) get out her freak flag.

"I won't post a picture yet," she said, starting to type. "I'll be vague in my description. I won't say anything about what I'm looking for, or willing to discuss."

He was about to tell her to post whatever she thought might work, but again stopped himself. It was clear to him that she wanted guardrails, as much to limit her own involvement as that of the site's unicorn hunters.

She wants to keep me as her safe haven,

he thought.

I'm still willing to play that role.

He tried not to put in words, even silently, how deep he was with her. But he felt it.

Once she had set up her profile, she departed the site.

It was three days later when she logged in. She made a point of doing it while Grant was with her.

She had 137 responses.

Grant chuckled. "Gosh, that much interest in someone claiming to be a single woman? What are the odds?"

He'd guessed right. Her expression, initially alarmed, eased to mild amusement.

"I'd better cull the herd," she said, hands to the keyboard.

Making sure that he watched, she responded to a few of her responses. In those cases, she stated that she was interested, but not yet willing to do more than converse, lightly and generally, and maybe with long time lags.

In their domestic life, Elise and Grant actually had some fun that had nothing to do with sex. They took a cooking class together, and gained some skills they hadn't previously acquired. One night a week, sometimes two, they made use of the skills, though they didn't always enjoy the results. Still, this helped them bond.

***

After another four months, on an evening when neither Elise nor Grant had brought work home, she took her laptop into the living room. She had them sit side-by-side on his sofa, and asked him to watch as she loaded the site.

"Tell me what you think of this couple," she said, setting the laptop on their neighboring thighs, "and how we've interacted."

Grant had tried to prepare for this moment. He'd always said, and mostly thought, that this was Elise's business. That he'd accept whatever she chose to do, if it was as she'd always said--a brief fling that wouldn't affect her life with him. Yet he had to stop himself from trembling as she settled next to him on the sofa, and rested the laptop on her thigh and his.

The screen showed him a few photos of a smiling couple. Male and female, white Americans, like Grant and Elise. Older, likely past 40. The text in their profile confirmed that.

Grant read the entries in the thread, which also included a phone pic of Elise.

He could feel Elise's gaze on him.

Neither of them moved.

When he looked up, she asked, "What do you think?"

"Obviously, I don't know them," he said, "but I'd say this is mostly his idea. She might be going along with it to make him happy."

"So you don't think she's bi?"

"Umm...you'd have a better idea of that than I would."

Elise looked at the screen, and scrolled to a certain passage. "I think she is. There are some code phrases in here. But, I agree, this is something that he wants more than she does."

Grant took a breath, then said, "In the most recent entry, they've given you a specific invitation."

"Yeah. They have."

"And?"

"How do you feel about this?"

The motion from his exasperated look at the ceiling almost sent the laptop to the floor. "How I

feel,

" he said, "is that we can't dance around this forever. I need to know...'Lise, I need to know if this is going to work."

To him, 'this' meant more than one thing. She picked up on that.

Elise looked at the man who gave her comfort and steadiness, and saw hints of fear that he probably didn't want her to see. He could have given her a flat no, with or without some made-up excuse about these two people who wanted a unicorn. She would have accepted that, but with unspoken regret. Yet Grant had the courage to face whatever would happen. Elise knew she should honor his courage, allow him to escape endless tension, and achieve calm. Someday.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like