The door slams open and you're wide awake, scrambling for the belt knife you'd concealed under a pillow even as you'd been thrusting into Malia.
Malia screams. You put your body in front of hers, holding her behind you with one arm as you hold the knife in the other, blade arcing back against your forearm as you prepare to ward off an attack.
The man from earlier is standing in the doorway, breeches pulled up and tied off at his waist. He's fuming. He points a finger at you, but then, seeing that you have a knife and he doesn't, he shrinks back to the threshold. He extends the finger again, this time hesitating to put it any closer to your knife than need be, regardless of the several paces of open floor between the two of you.
"Your—your time's up!" the man stutters. "I—I don't know who you are. I just—it's my turn! I was here first—you had your turn, and now...now...I want mine, blast it!"
You lower your knife arm. The man is trembling. You take a closer look at his face. He's not a beautiful man, as you saw before, but...he isn't bad looking. Just young. A hump-happy young man who must have learned not too long ago how to fuck something.
You chuckle.
"I—I'm not joking," the man sputters.
"Come on in," you tell him, trying not to burst into full-fledged laughter at the look on his face. "Come on, I won't hurt you." You put the knife back in its sheath and toss it onto a chair across the room.
The man frowns, stares over at the knife. He looks like he's thinking hard. He takes that first step after more than enough time. He shuts the door, hesitating before releasing the latch and turning to face you.
"You...I heard what you did to her. I could hear it down the hall..."
"Did to me?" Malia laughs, coming out from behind you, wrapping herself around your arm, leaning against you.
You look down at her. She smiles up at you. You don't remember falling asleep, but you feel better rested than you have in many years. She kisses a crisscrossing of scars on your shoulder.
"You did something, that's for sure," Malia whispers. You can hear the smile in her words.
"I know what you said earlier...," the man speaks up after a bit of silence. "What you said you'd do to me."
"I know what I said, too," you respond, looking up at him after a moment staring down at Malia's red hair as it glows warm in the candlelight. She smells like warmth, honey, wild mountain flowers. And a little like you, now.
"Does it...does it hurt?" His eyes are wide as he asks. You can hear him swallow.
"Only if you struggle against it."
"Oh..."
"Mmmmm...," Malia hums. "I think he's curious."
"I...!" he begins to protest. "I... Maybe I am. A little bit."
"That's okay," you tell him, looking him up and down. You know he's watching your every movement, every rise and fall of your chest, the flickering of your eyes over his entire body. He's on high alert, perhaps half-expecting you to swoop down on top of him and pound him where he lands.
"I've...heard...things," he says, quiet. "I've heard men talk...about how it felt that one time they tried it...How...it's different...but really...feels good."
You chuckle gently. "It does."
He looks up at you. "You've done it?"
You nod. Malia watches you, as well, her fingers trailing slowly up and down your arm, raising goosebumps where she touches your skin.
"Which part?" he asks, watching his bare toes scrape around on the wood floor.
"Both."
Malia hums again, brushing a roaming kiss lower on your shoulder. "An adventurer," she whispers for your ears alone.
"Does it hurt?" he asks again.
"Only if you fight it," you repeat. "And only if we don't take it slow the first time."
The man nods, slowly coming closer.
"But I also want my turn in her," he says, not really sounding all that convinced anymore.
Malia laughs. "I think we can work something out between the three of us. It's not my first time with two men at once."
You wrap an arm around her and she snuggles against you as you squeeze her tight. You then let her go and crawl off the bed. The man watches you, his eyes going wide as your bare dick bounces flaccid against your thigh.
"It's...huge."
"I'll go nice and slow," you assure him, "you have my word."