Author's Note: This is part of our ongoing adventures, and our eleventh story. It references events and characters from our previously published stories. You can read it alone, but we would love for you to check out our other work. Enjoy!
*
Depending how you looked at it, our first time visiting a sex club was either a great success or a colossal failure. For Jason and Brooklyn, our friends who had gone with us, it had been a wonderful experience no matter how you sliced it. A month earlier the four of us had all visited together. They had met and swapped partners with a very attractive black couple in their early 30's. We had fooled around with a couple a few years younger than us.
How you would view our trip as a success was obvious. First off, even before you get to the sex part, we had a lot of fun. The club was interesting, and the couple we met had been nice, although nervous. They got there as swinger virgins, and left as not. Mandy had given the guy we met, Cody, an amazing blowjob and he came a bit too early in the night. Then he watched Mandy and I fuck his girlfriend, Sara, a short Hispanic woman who was absolutely stunning. Sara and Mandy traded numbers before Cody and Sara left the club.
After playing with Cody and Sara we hung out with Brooklyn and Jason, and their new friends Kayla and Jordan. Kayla and Jordan were both very fun, and they were regulars of the club, whereas the four of us were new to it (as were Sara and Cody). We had swapped numbers and then left for the night.
The way it turned out to be a failure was the after effects with Sara and Cody. As we had learned from Sara, they were not on the same page with each other about what they wanted to do. Swinging had been Sara's idea, and Cody was only going along with it because he was worried that she would dump him if he couldn't keep up with her sexually. After he came, Sara had asked if she could have sex with me, and he had said yes. It turned out that unbeknownst to us Sara had promised Cody that under no circumstances would they go past oral sex with others. When she asked in front of us after he had already came, he felt like she unfairly put him in a position where he couldn't say no.
Long story short, they had broken up. Swinging isn't a way to fix problems in a relationship, and as Sara told us that was what they were trying to do. They were a young couple, both only 21, and had only dated 7 months, so it wasn't like we had taken part in ending a tight relationship, but it still didn't feel great to learn about.
Sara now wanted to hang out again and have a threesome with us. So far I had been reluctant to do that. Don't get me wrong, she was gorgeous and the idea of having her again was alluring, but I felt like we shouldn't hop into bed with her right after she got out of a relationship, which we were at least in a small part responsible for ending. After expressing that feeling to Mandy, she agreed, and we decided to still be friends, but hold off on the sex. (Although 5 years later, at the time of this writing, we have been with her a few times, and she is now happily married to a very nice guy who is aware of her swinging past, but blissfully ignorant of who it was with).
I had picked up on some clues Cody wasn't comfortable when Sara wanted to move to full swap with me, but Mandy was too tipsy to notice, and she and Sara were so enthusiastic about everything we did that it created a situation I didn't know how to stop, so I just went with it and hoped for the best.
After that experience, we set some ground rules for our second trip. Ground rules for playing would be set up front, and not changed once we were all naked on a bed. Condoms were still a must. We would try to avoid another couple who were both very young and completely new to swinging. Mandy wouldn't drink as much so she could give me backup if it got awkward again. And lastly we set up code words to use to each other to say if we did or did not want to swap.
For obvious reasons we were keeping our swinging side a secret from our friends and family. Mandy had made an exception to this, and was keeping her best friend Liz updated on what we did. By extension that meant Liz's husband, Mike, who was one of my best friends, also knew what we were up to.
The four of us had gotten together for Saturday brunch and Mike was peppering me with questions about it. He knew what had happened, but didn't know details of any of the people things had happened with. He also didn't know that Cody and Sara had split up after playing with us. Every time the server came by the table he awkwardly paused. Mike was good at many things, but he had a horrible poker face, and could never have been good at a job like being and actor or a spy.
"I think it's awesome that you two are doing this," he said, for the third or fourth time that morning.
"I think we all know how awesome you think it is honey," his wife said patting his leg and laughing a bit.
"I'm just saying, when we all did it in college, it was amazing. And I'm not trying to say I'm unhappy with my sex life, because it's fucking awesome, but it's only two people, and the idea of more again is exciting."
"Well at least for now you have to live vicariously through them," Liz said.
"You don't have to only live vicariously," Mandy said giggling. "You could always get a sitter one night and come spend some time in the hot tub."
"I'm going to need alcohol to get up the courage to do it again," Liz said. "And I'm not drinking until after I finish breastfeeding."
"So is that a yes to doing it eventually?" Mike asked excitedly. "You only breastfeed for a year right, so you're basically done."
"Eventually, if Mandy and Chris want to, then yes, we can do it again," she said, eliciting a very excited response from her husband. "But, some doctors say I should breastfeed for two years, so you may have to wait a while."
"I just can't believe you haven't had a drink in almost two years," I said. In college Liz had been a bit of a wild child.
"Yeah, it's been different. A lot of changes. You two will be there one day. You know, after you get tired of screwing other couples."
"When are we going to meet one of these couples?" Mike asked.
"We are keeping that life and our normal life very separate," Mandy answered.
"I was really hoping that couple that was at your house last weekend when we swung by was one," he said. "That woman was a babe."
"Sorry to disappoint," Mandy said. "They're just neighbors, not swingers, although I agree Brooklyn is very sexy."
The weekend before we had Jason and Brooklyn spend the night. Mike and Liz had been in the neighborhood and had called to ask if they could swing by and drop off a casserole dish Liz had borrowed. Mandy had said yes, telling them we had friends over who were about to have dinner. We had lied and told them that Brooklyn and James were simply neighbors we had met out. In truth, they were neighbors, and we did meet them first in person at a restaurant in our neighborhood, but that had been after meeting them on a swingers site and planning the date.
"I also agree, Brooklyn is hot," I said. "Maybe I should see if they are up to becoming swingers," I joked.
Mandy gave me a look that made Mike and Liz both laugh. I laughed too, knowing they weren't actually in on the entire joke.
I turned back to Liz. "While I respect your desire to have alcohol, I must say your breasts look amazing and I will not be opposed if you decide you want to play earlier."
Everyone laughed again and Liz looked down at her chest. "Yeah, I don't know what I'm going to do with all the new bras I have had to buy once they go back down. Mike wants me to get the them done to stay this size permanently."
Liz is 5'0", and had dropped back to her roughly 100-pound weight pretty quickly after having a kid. She now had a nice pair of C cup breasts though, as compared to the perky B cup breasts I had played with in college.
"I don't think you should do that," Mandy said. "You have great enough natural tits."
"But you should show of those amazing puppies before they are gone," I joked.
"Wait, so Mike seriously hasn't sent you pictures?" she asked.
"What, no." I said.
"He joked that he was going to, I thought he was serious. He's been telling me he hasn't but I didn't believe him."
"Well he hasn't," I told her truthfully.
"Ok," she said.
The conversation paused, Mike was looking at his wife smiling. She was giving him a look back I couldn't quite read. Finally, she broke the silence.