"Fuck her Joe, you earned it." Vanessa said. She nodded giving me a nonverbal "go for it".
I reached down and pulled Angie on top of me. She rubbed her wet pussy up and down my hard fat shaft. She slowly worked her way to the tip. I reached down lifted it up slightly which was just enough for the tip to separate her wet lips. She slowly pushed back as the head of my cock entered her for the first time.
She moaned. I moaned. This was something we both had wanted for a long time. She moved back and forth as my precum made an already slippery pussy just that much more slippery.
I watched her eyes grow as she slowly took me in inch by inch. She was sooo tight. I had forgotten what it was like to fill up a new pussy. In and out she went until I was fully inside of her. She sat up and moved her hips back and forth as she adjusted to my girth.
"It's so thick." She moaned as she moved back and forth.
I reached up and pulled her lips to mine. We kissed as she moved back and forth. We found a nice rhythm where I would push deeply into her as she pushed back onto me.
Lost in time and ecstasy we made love like this for awhile. Not sure how much time had passed but she grabbed my shoulders and rolled me over on top of her. She wrapped her legs around my lower back and told me to stay still. She started moving her hips up and down impaling herself on me while I towered above her on all fours.
I felt Vanessa come up next to me and she ran her hands down my back as I fucked her best friend. She started massaging my butt cheeks. I felt her finger slip a finger between my cheeks and massage my ass hole.
She did like ass play. I have to admit that when she tongued and played with my ass when we would 69 I kind of liked it. She got behind me and I felt her spread my cheeks as Angie continued sliding up and down my cock.
When her tongue hit my hole it sent a shock through me. This was new. I let her do her thing while I enjoyed my new tight pussy. Her tongue and a lone finger entered me next. I had sensations coming from every part of my body now. I felt a second finger enter me as she continued to lick and finger bang me. She was rubbing my prostate now and it was sending some crazy feelings through my body.
Vanessa moved to the side and slipped her two fingers out of my slippery saliva lubed ass. She put both hands on my ass cheeks and spread them apart as I felt a new finger rub circles around my ass hole.
Oh no! Jake? What was going on tonight!! He liked ass play too? Not thinking about the big picture here, I didn't put a stop to anything.
"Let them do their thing, concentrate on me." Angie half moaned half whispered looking me in the eyes. "This is a fantasy of mine."
"Ok." I whispered back.
I do know that I would do anything for this girl. I also knew I badly wanted to cum deep inside of her. So I continued slowly fucking her.
That is when I felt Jake slowly slip the tip of his finger easily inside me. His finger was almost the same as the two Vanessa had been finger fucking me with. His finger was definitely longer as he slipped it all the way in. He wiggled it around inside and slowly started to finger fuck me from the tip to the base of his middle finger. He also massaged my prostate increasing an intensity inside cock that was deep inside of Angie.
Still though, I couldn't believe I had another guy's finger inside me. I again had to remind myself that I would do anything for this girl. I have been fantasizing about her for 2 years. She had me under a spell and I wanted to fulfill her fantasy.
I let it happen. If this is what she wanted...then OK.
He was in sync with my back and forth movements as I fucked Angie when he slipped a second finger deep inside me.
I had just gotten used to one finger being inside!
The extra stretch of my ass lips brought me a little discomfort. His fingers were definitely bigger than Vanessa's. He gently did this for a while and the discomfort seemed to slowly disappear.
Disappear into what? I wasn't completely sure yet.
Angie kept her hands on my face and her eyes locked on mine the whole time this was going on. She pulled me close and started kissing me deeply as Vanessa and Jake played with my ass.
Then out of nowhere, I felt myself reaching the point of no return. I wanted to hold back but I couldn't.
With her tongue deep in my mouth and Jakes finger deep in my ass massaging my prostate, I came inside her. I came hard and a lot. I filled her pussy with my cum as I tensed up slowly coming to a stop.
I didn't want to pull out of her but I was going soft and didn't have much of a choice in the matter.
We continued kissing as I felt the fingers slip out of my ass. Vanessa stayed where she was. She spread my butt cheeks apart again. There was some moving around on the bed.
I heard the squeeze of lube.
I heard what sounded like someone stroking a wet slippery cock.
More moving.
Then I felt two large hands grab the front of my waist as Jake positioned himself behind me. I felt the warmth of his thighs as he pushed up against me. He leaned forward and rested his hard slippery cock on my lower back right where my ass crack started.
I could feel the tickle of his pubs as his balls pressed against my hole.
He moved it back and forth in my crack with long slow strokes.
I knew what he was going to do. Part of me was petrified about what was about to happen but another part was curious.
If I didn't put a stop to this I was pretty sure I was going to get butt fucked.
I should stop this now.
Apparently, the part of me that was curious was in control. Because I didn't make a move to stop him.
Vanessa let go of one of my ass cheeks and lined up his cock to my ass lips. He stopped moving and just let it sit there. The head locked right on to the opening of my ass cave.
The tip of his cock was warm on my hole.
I could still stop it.
But, somewhere inside me I kind of missed the fingers that had been inside me. Somewhere else inside of me there was something that wanted to try this new invader.
Something that was stronger than my will to stop it kept me still.
I decided I was going to let this happen.
Vanessa gripped my other ass cheek and spread both of them wide apart.
I felt pressure as he slowly pushed forward trying to get into me.
I felt my ass lips fight the invader. They were putting up quite a little fight. He pulled back and slowly pushed forward again. He did this a few times and each time my lips seemed to give in and become just a little bit more accommodating to this foreign object.
He pulled back and gently pushed forward again but this time with a little more force.
His tip entered me on this push.