As breakfast wound down, Dave said. "So, what do we want to do today?"
"Looks like they have that farmers' market downtown again," said Sam. "I need a break from the sun until I'm feeling better." Dave was also not in great shape after the events of the previous night, so he forwent his usual eye rolling at her suggestion. Besides, maybe there was still some fun to be had.
They made their way back to the cabin to change. The guys loitered as the girls showered, but Susie shooed them off to the bar. "You've seen it once, but that doesn't mean you get a season ticket."
The guys ordered Mimosa's at the Swing Bar, hoping that "hair of the dog" would help them feel better. As they sat facing the lake, Dave swilled down two Ibuprofen, trying to cure the dull pounding in his head.
Andy asked, "What do you think the girls have planned for today?"
"Not sure," said Dave. "They were in the driver's seat yesterday, but I think it's time for us to take charge. Let's go with the market thing, but then maybe we suggest we split up with our opposite partners for a while and see where things go. You know, pretend to be together. Nothing crazy--just a little fun."
Andy seized the opportunity without hesitation. "Deal."
"So," said Dave, "it's maybe not my place, but I was curious what you and Susie got up to in the shower. I had a lot of sun with Sam, but it was driving me crazy not knowing what you were doing."
Andy chuckled, "Yeah, I think that was Susie's plan; keep you on your toes. If you're sure you want to know, I'll tell--she didn't say not to."
Dave nodded his assent, though he was not entirely sure he wanted to know the gritty details. Was it better to know or to leave certain things to the imagination? Andy sat forward in his chair.
"First, I'm sure you know saw all the footsie under the table at dinner; she had me ready to explode." Dave nodded and said, "Same with Sam."
"Well, then it continued at the lake. She pulled me in without giving me a chance to remove my clothes; we were soaking, but it was sexy, you know?" Dave nodded, saying that he did indeed know.
"Then she's kissing and touching me, rubbing her body up against me. Man, her tits are nice." Andy realized he may have overstepped at the last, his face flushing. But Dave was getting turned on. Andy continued, "She was reaching down, touching my cock, running her hand down my chest, grinding her butt right up against me. Then she vanishes under the water and tugs my shorts down, giving me a fucking blowjob in the lake. It only lasted a few minutes, and she didn't let me cum, but it was hot as hell." Dave felt a small lurch in his stomach, but then remembered that he'd been having his own fun with Sam.
"That sounds awesome." Dave said. "Me and Sam didn't go that far, but we did feel each other up underwater, and..." He trailed off.
"What?" said Andy.
This was weird. Dave knew women were more comfortable discussing sex, and he always assumed Susie was discussing the details of their intimate times with Sam. For Dave, this was uncharted territory, especially when it was the Andy's wife he had been with.
Was Andy going to be OK, knowing he had made Sam cum?
Dave sucked in a breath and went for it.
"Well, I was touching her underwater--you know, her tits and her pussy. I swear, man, within a few minutes, she was humping my leg and cumming. I hope you're not mad. We didn't discuss any rules; I feel guilty for overstepping."
Andy laughed in response. "Mad?" he said. "Look, first off, I got to fuck Susie last night, something I've been wanting to do for ages, and then we all had sex on the same bed," he said. "Also, you guys were so focused on yourselves that you didn't notice us watching you. I think Susie has a thing for seeing you with other people." Dave was stunned. They were watching? Susie had never given him any hint that she wanted to see him with other people, but this put of a different light on the events of the past day. Dave felt much more comfortable with how the evening had unfolded.
"So then, when she grabbed me for the shower," said Andy, "I didn't know what the hell to do. I wasn't prepared to imagine you fucking Sam, but I secretly hoped that I could have sex with Susie."
"And did you?" Dave asked--not sure if he wanted to hear the answer.
"Nope she, promised it was only soft stuff for the moment. It was perfect. I think that if we had fucked the first time without the other present, it would have caused a lot of resentment." Dave agreed and noted Andy's use of 'first time', as though they were all assuming there was more to come.
"That took the pressure off," said Andy. "We were having fun. You know?" Dave did, but it was different--more intense for him, only assuming Susie would obey the same rules she had given him.
"First, we washed each other. She soaped up my cock, and I was lathering her amazing tits. Then she turned around and ground herself against me, rubbing my cock against her ass. It was the closest thing to fucking without doing it. She went down on her knees and started blowing me; you are a lucky man. Her mouth is totally amazing; within minutes, I felt like I was going to explode, but she said there was a lot more in store for the night. She stopped right before I came. It was hot but frustrating. You know?" Dave knew exactly what he meant.
"Then she let me lick her pussy. So tight, so soft." Dave felt his erection stiffen as he listened to Andy recount using his mouth and tongue to drive Susie to an orgasm.
"And that's where we ended the shower and came out to see my wife going down on you," Andy finished.
Dave recounted his side of the story and was sure Andy would trust that he and Sam had also not broken the rules. By the end of the story, both men were feeling much better--their headaches were retreating, and both were raring to go. Discussing the details of the previous evening that had gotten them both worked up. It was fun hearing what had happened behind closed doors.