Crazy, I thought, but I couldn't stop now. I brought the little cheerleader's leg slowly across my body, leaving her straddling me, her tiny box rubbing gently against the base of my dick. Michelle and Meghan were taking turns kissing Elise and me, our lips, necks, ears, etc. Their hands roamed non-stop over both our bodies. I took a long deep breath to savor the moment, got a firm grip on Elise's teeny little bubble butt and started to slowly lower her onto my fat cock.
With the buoyancy of the water and Elise's tightness, gravity wasn't enough to force my 8 inches into her tiny box so I motioned for Michelle and Meghan to help and they took hold of her shoulders and brought her down slowly but surely onto my dick. Elise bit her lip and hugged me tight as she fought through that first bit of pain as I broke through her cherry, she kept biting her lip for different reasons as she got into a rhythm on top of me, working herself up to her first orgasm, Meghan and Michelle kissing her neck, rubbing and twisting her perky nipples as her breathing got heavier and her eyes got glazy.
With her hair wet and slicked back and her freckles showing on her face, she looked so much like a little kid that I felt like the world's biggest pervert defiling this innocent young thing, and it felt good. I adjusted my grip on her little ass, and slid a finger slowly up her asshole. She gasped in surprise and here eyes popped wide open, but I just quickened my pace and started really bouncing her up and down on my cock, but I felt I wasn't getting enough thrust going, so I collected Elise in my arms, brought her out of the water and laid her on her on her back on the chaise lounge, got her legs up over my shoulders and started pounding this little beauty like crazy. If Elise thought she was being fucked before, she was now experiencing a whole new level as this new position allowed me to get that last inch or two into her, my dick amazingly disappearing into this tiny body.
Elise started to moan, signaling all of us that she was ready to finish, Michelle's mouth on her nipple brought her over the line, and she grabbed onto me with everything she had, lips, arms, legs, so tight I could barely breathe, then she shuddered like a car with engine trouble, and came like crazy. I was right behind her, but I did remember to pull out at the last second, with Meghan talking me in her hand as my cock twitched and Michelle doing her one better by taking it in her mouth. I came so hard it hurt, with Meghan feeding my cock to Michelle, who swallowed every drop.
I collapsed on the lounge, Elise cuddling in next to me, quiet now, satiated and probably, in love with me forever now. Michelle noted the lateness in the afternoon and suggested we "hit the showers" which sounded good to me!