Matthew was smaller than Jeremy, but his brutality more than made up for the difference, and his aggressive jackhammering sent bruising force up my hips, churning my guts.
I tried to claw my way forward, and he dragged me unceremoniously back, curling his body over me to sink his cock deeper in my abused hole. I wailed pitiably, the sound jerking out of me with each aggressive thrust, the impartial gleam of a camera lens cold comfort as it trailed the contours of my face, capturing my agonised howls.
A hand wrapped in my hair, viciously, tugging my face up, displaying my tear-streaked cheeks to great effect. Neck straining, I tried to look behind me at Matthew, rutting into my asshole with a viciousness and desperation borne of years of waiting. His eyes gleamed as they met mine, as he yanked my hair harder, baring my long, pale throat, and cutting off my grunt of pain.
As lubricated and loosened as my ass was by Jeremy's passage, the friction still began to wear on me, and the deep ache turned into a scratching burn, his pubes irritating my swollen, battered anus with each slamming, grinding thrust into me. To my immense surprise, I felt him begin to pull out.
At the same time, he pinched my clit, hard, and my yowl of pain caught everyone's attention as he stealthily wiped free the leftover lubricant on his cock. He dropped my hair in favour of a vice grip on my hips, preventing me from moving even an inch as he brutally worked his dry cock back into my inflamed anus.
My howls doubled, and Lucas and Chris shared a worried look, seeming concerned that neighbours might overhear and call the police. Their worry barely registered, all my focus on the brutal assault to my asshole.
Matthew pushed me into the bed, face-first, and continued rutting in earnest, his knees locking on either side of me as he ruthlessly worked his cock into my ass, breath hitching with each pulsing shock wave that travelled through me, my whole body unified in its goal to push out the invader. He leaned into me, weight pushing the air out of my lungs and hissed,
"I've always wanted to fuck your tight ass dry. Wish we didn't have such a crowd though. If you were all mine..." He trailed off, his cock thickening and pulsing inside me at the thought.
His fingers tightened around my neck, and he panted out his next words, hips twitching with the strain of holding off his orgasm,
"It wouldn't just be my cock in your ass."
To illustrate, he straightened, and began working his fingertips into my asshole, nails scrabbling against me as I wept and thrashed. His fingers stretched me viciously, as my nerves endings jangled in agony. I tightened even further around him in response, and the snarl he let out sent chills running up my spine.
It sounded feral, and dangerous, and I wondered, through my haze of pain, at the monster in our midst, wearing khakis and a perpetual smirk, even while thoughts of my body contorted in pain under him raced through his head.
His fingers tightened in my hair, that minor pain unnoticed as I drooled and panted and cried, tears drumming onto the comforter as my legs kicked feebly.
His cock stilled in me, pulsating and sending waves of sensation through my battered ass. His fingers loosened in my hair, almost stroking through the tangled, sweat-soaked curls.
"Although, I have to admit, little slut," he breathed, fingers tugging out of my asshole and spiralling down to my cunt, gathering up the liquid that soaked my pussy and thighs,
"I never knew how hot it would be fucking your ass in front of your sweet, loving husband. Maybe I should invite you both over someday. I would have so much fun with you two."
At those last foreboding words, he stiffened, hips twitching against my reddened cheeks. His cum splashed deep into me, and I forgot to be disgusted, visions of Lucas chained up flashing through my head. His wrists chapped and sore as he fought to reach me, while Matthew plundered my pussy and ass with cavalier ease and his trademark smirk.
On principle, I tried to resist the thrust of his fingers, but they were almost gentle on me, and I desperately needed relief.
"Cum for me, little slut. Cum for the bastard that raped your tiny asshole, dry. I can feel how close you are. I want you to cum around my fingers."
I shuddered unwillingly in his grasp. My orgasm was close. I teetered on the precipice, unwilling to give him more when he had already taken so much.
My mouth opened, but the groans of release Matthew wanted from me didn't come.
"Someone fuck my mouth. Anyone." I begged, tongue fumbling and thick.
Lucas didn't hesitate to step up, and his eyes burned into me as he eased his cock into my mouth, allowing his cock to swallow my pitiful sounds as I fucked against Matthew's fingers.
His fingers continued their torturous dance against my slick clit, and my eyes began to roll as his cock began to stiffen inside me again. I freed my mouth, half-crazed, my stomach cramping and coiling with the promise of relief.
"More," I gasped, "someone fill my pussy. Fuck all my holes, fuck me, fuck me, use me."
My words were charged and feverish, voice raw from my rough treatment. Chris, my saviour, elbowed Matthew out of the way, casual in the face of Matthew's glower. He stood between my legs, camera planing over my abused holes before trailing up to my flushed face and overbright eyes.
"You're such a little slut that one cock at a time isn't enough for you?" He drawled, trying to hide the excitement and hunger in his words.
My voice failed me, so instead I nodded, feeling Lucas gather my hair in both hands and guide me back to his cock, gentle thrusts that pushed him deeper and deeper into my willing mouth.
Jeremy moved forward, and had I not had a cock buried in my throat, I would have squeaked at the monstrous cock that swung between his legs, heavy and thick and lethal. His face was gentle, however, and I tried to watch him circle me hungrily, even as Lucas ground his balls against my face, sodden curls scraping against my cheeks and chin.
"Can I... Can I try her...?"
Jeremy trailed off, gesturing to my cunt as he looked at Lucas. The hesitancy and lust in Jeremy's voice sent shock waves through my pussy. He wasn't asking me, wasn't even looking directly at me. I had become a commodity, a collection of holes to fuck. Lucas didn't fail to pick up on this, and his lips quirked in a smile as his cock fell from my lips with a pop.
He gestured to the crumpled, damp bed with an expansive wave, and Jeremy lifted me gently to my feet. I swayed back and forth, blood thundering in my ears as cum ran down my legs, trickling and sticky.