We've known Melissa for quite a few years. She was more Annie's friend to start with but we socialise together every once in a while.
I like Mel. She is quiet, though not exactly shy. I honestly don't know whether she even has boyfriends or lovers - that's how quiet and straight Mel can be. She is small in height and a little plump but she carries it well and there is no going past the fact she has a nice bouncy pair of B-cup tits. We both enjoy her company. Annie isn't sexually attracted to her at all but I was very keen on seeing whether I could corrupt Mel - lead her astray and maybe into our little world of sexual pleasure.
Once or twice I'd made suggestive comments to Mel. But her being a bit reserved and me being in a relationship with Annie meant she'd ignored my hints about taking things further.
The time came soon enough, however, when the three of us were discussing sex in the way adults do. So I 'let slip' that Annie and I are not monogamous. Mel was shocked to hear that! Then, as if trying to reassure her that it wasn't so strange for a devoted couple to be having sex with others, I mentioned that we also played together.
'What?' she stammered. 'I don't think I get it'.
'Yes you do' I replied, teasing her. 'Sometimes Annie and I have a third person in our bed. When we can both agree on the other person.'
Annie was trying to get me to leave things be. I know she hadn't expected to be outed like that. Even most of her closest friends don't know about our sexual lifestyle. Fortunately for me, despite her protestations of shock and horror, Mel was warming up on the subject.
'I could never be like that with a woman' she blurted out. 'Maybe kissing or something but I could never be turned on.'
'Oh yeah' I replied, trying to sound casual. 'Its not for everyone. And we don't do it all the time' I tried to reassure her. 'Only once in a while.'
'But you really don't mind letting Annie do that?' she asked.
'If she wants to' I answered. 'It isn't really about me letting her do anything. If Annie wants it then its not up to me to say no'.
'Even another man? So you can have two men at once?' she demanded of Annie
That has been the least of Annie's sexual adventures to date. But Annie quietly nodded, squirming with embarrassment and pleasure as she recalled some of her more recent nights.
'But how?'
I laughed quietly. 'I think you would need to find out for yourself' I answered for Annie.
'Well I could never...' shot back Mel.
'But you have thought about it' I suggested.
'I'm sure I couldn't...'
'Well you don't need to. We're not trying to convert you' I went on (lying through my teeth).
But I was right and Mel had been thinking about it at some point. 'The thing is I don't know if I could feel safe' she offered. 'If I felt I was in control that might be different.'
She had been thinking about it...and I knew by now I was close to having her hooked. It was unlikely Mel would play with us and anyway, after the way I'd 'put her in it', I don't think Annie was too impressed about the thought of Mel playing with me. But it was a rush to think I might be able to entice sweet, innocent Melissa into something debauched like her own private cock party. If only I could be there to watch!
'Well its nice to be able to think about these things sometimes' I said. 'If you ever did want to know more then you know you can ask Annie or I.'
Which was where we left it for the time being. Later on Annie and I talked some more and we agreed it would be fun to see how far we could go in encouraging Mel to explore a very private fantasy. Annie definitely did not want to be involved. Somehow Melissa wasn't someone she wanted knowing more intimate details about her. I knew not to make a big deal over my wanting to fuck Mel - but it was agreed I was free to organise a small cock party for Melissa if (a big 'if' it seemed) she was game.
From there I left it a few weeks. In time I sent Mel a couple of emails to her private address. Yes, she told me, she had been thinking about it. But she had no idea how to go about setting up a night with two men at once. She was sure she'd be too scared. It was something best left to the realm of fantasy.
I followed up with some research and sent Mel two stories from Literotica.com
Then she really did get interested.
Finally I 'offered' to help with a few ideas about how she could make this fantasy come true.