An hour or so went by, as they talked, then a young man came over to them. He was not so tall, red headed, and a tiny bit overweight. He offered the two girls a drink, and was very complimentary and shy. He even said yes ma'am and no ma'am to them. He was dressed very plainly, and even after buying the two girls a drink, he made no attempt to sit with them or make any pass. He just walked back over to where he was sitting and sat down, letting his shy gaze wander over to them, and when they caught him looking, he blushed. He was very nice to them, and finally Mindy told Brenda, "Why don't we let him sit with us? It will thrill him, and he's harmless."
"Yeah, a little too harmless. Min, there's no excitement there, do ya think?" Brenda said back, before Mindy waved the youth over to her and offered him a chair. He sat down with them, and the girls could tell he was thrilled. He continued to be totally mild mannered and chivalrous, and not the least bit threatening or pushy. He never once came onto either girl, and it was if he was sure that he would be rejected. Mindy began to flirt with him a little, but except for a few blushes, he didn't really respond to her. He was again very complimentary and when they began discussing her workout schedule and how it made her look, he told her that she looked incredible and the workouts certainly paid off. She smiled at him and leaned over to kiss him on the cheek. He turned as red as a tomato. It was obvious that he had never talked to any girls as pretty as Mindy and Brenda, and he felt totally in over his head. When they asked him about his own love life, he mumbled, stammered, and blushed again. His name was Russell, and finally Mindy asked him, "Russell, have you ever made love to a woman? Ever?" Once again, he blushed and finally just shook his head no.
"You can call me Rusty, ma'am." He said in a low voice, his eyes diverted downward.
"Only if you call me Mindy, and quit calling me ma'am," Mindy replied. He cut his eyes upward and smiled shyly at her. She smiled at him again. "How old are you, Rusty?"
He dropped his eyes again as he whispered, "Eighteen."
She reached over and patted him on the leg just above the knee. He was wearing shorts, so she was on bare skin. He trembled from her touch. "Are you scared of me, Rusty?" she whispered softly.
"I don't know. I never dreamed that I could ever talk to a girl as pretty as you. I guess I am a little scared. I just don't know." Rusty shook his head and blinked his eyes almost like an owl. Mindy's smile grew. He was so cute and so shy. She felt the urge to tease him more. And she knew that Brenda was turned on by the idea of a virgin guy. A plan was forming in her mind, and Rusty was going to be the unwitting beneficiary of her scheme. She started flirting a little more with him. He didn't know how to react, he was embarrassed and shy and mostly he just turned red. Finally, Mindy leaned into him and kissed him on the lips. It was just a small, chaste, close mouthed kiss that still left him gasping for breath and with a huge tent in the front of his shorts. Mindy looked down and saw it, and teased him, "My goodness, Rusty, what is that in your pants, honey? Brenda, did you see this, what do you think it is?"
Brenda grinned and said, "I don't know Mindy, he looks like something has swelled up on him. Do you think he's ok? Does he need some medical attention or something?" Mindy grinned at the young man, who was totally embarrassed. He looked totally miserable that his erection had been discovered by the two girls. Even his embarrassment did not make his erection subside; it stayed as hard and as prominently throbbing as before.
"It's really OK, Rusty," Mindy said, "Girls know about those, we even like them sometimes, you know?" He nodded, but still looked miserable. She spoke again, "Rusty, yours certainly looks like it's a big one, really nice for a girl. Has anyone ever told you that?" He only shook his head negatively. Mindy put her hand on his leg again. She slid her fingers up and down just a little as he trembled again. His skin was smooth and almost hairless under her touch. She lifted her hand and set it back down right on top of the bulge in his shorts. She gently fondled it just a little. He almost fell over backward in his chair. She felt it swell more and pulse under her hand. She giggled and winked at Brenda, who made a motion toward the door with her head. She wanted to get out of the bar.
"Rusty, would you like to come home with us? We're ready to get home and you will have fun. We would love to have you. It's not very far. What do you say?" Rusty could only nod; evidently his mouth wasn't working so well. But he agreed to follow them to Mindy's apartment. They paid their tabs and left the bar, with Rusty following the two girls in his own car. Mindy and Brenda giggled together, planning his overwhelming initiation into the world of physical pleasure. He had no idea what was in store for him.