We each had a couple of drinks. Ellen was sitting next to Dave on the couch and was laughing a little too loudly- she was definitely not getting cold feet- when our guest casually leaned over, kissed my wife's lips, and began touching her tits. Let the games begin!
Ellen definitely kissed him back and while in his embrace waved to me to come over to the couch and sit on the other side of her. I knew what was coming next but it still felt strange, even for a self-proclaimed pervert like me, to watch another man kissing and feeling up my wife. Dave was getting into it and I too was excited. We all stood and the guys began to take off their clothes. Ellen watched as Dave and I removed everything and stood in front of her- she was flushed and couldn't get her eyes off Dave's body. He was modestly muscular with a nice chest and arms but Ellen (and I) were drawn to his penis and, as a non-bisexual, if I was interested she had to be awestruck. Dave's cock was at least 10 inches, was not circumcised and was as thin as a rail. I, on the other hand, am 7 inches, circumcised and very meaty.
It was now Ellen's turn to disrobe. She slowly unbuttoned her blouse showing us her new bra; she removed her shoes and then pushed her skirt to the floor revealing thigh high hose and a garter belt- with no panties. For a woman who has never been nude in front of another man, Ellen seemed right in her element. We adjourned to the bedroom.
Ellen was now in full control at this point. She got on the bed and had Dave and me on either side of her. She was sitting crossed-legged in the center of the bed and Dave and I were lying down. She began by kissing our lips and face one at a time and while doing this she was rubbing each of our penises. In no time Dave and I had maximum erections- Ellen couldn't get over this long, thin cock with the extra skin and she began to give him a blowjob while, simultaneously, giving me a hand job.
In a short while, Ellen removed her bra, garter and left her hose on. She really wanted to see if she could tolerate Dave's cock entering her pussy without any pain; so, she mounted him and began to methodically insert his cock inch by inch. To my surprise, and her delight, there was no pain. She began to slowly move her hips up and down and sideways while never letting her hand off of my cock. As her rocking continued I could tell that she was getting more and more aroused- hell, we all were!
Ellen was now really fucking Dave. As she leaned over him, each thrust had her breasts rubbing over Dave's chest making her nipples hard as rocks. While she was doing this, somehow she was still able to turn to me -- I was now standing on the bed next to her so that my cock was right in front of her- and she put my cock in her mouth. What a friggin' sight- it was unbelievable.
After a while, it seemed that we all understood at the same time that we needed to change positions. Ellen sat on the edge of the bed and spread her legs so that Dave could kneel on the floor and lick her pussy: she and Dave alternately took turns playing with her clitoris. I began to suck on her nipples and play with her tits. It didn't take long and Ellen had her first exploding orgasm. Her whole body was shaking, she was both moaning and screaming at the same time, her pussy was dripping from the combination of her juices and Dave's saliva. Ellen continued to have orgasm after orgasm as she fell back onto the bed with her legs still dangling over the edge. When she did this Dave shot his load. His cum went from her pussy to her breasts- she was covered with it. I wasn't far behind and I came all over her face and hair. She was literally immersed and dripping in cum.
We all took a few minutes to catch our breath but really didn't want to stop. Ellen's orgasms were continuing even while no one was touching her! So Dave and I went "back to work". We put Ellen on her stomach and began to touch her very sensitive ass. Dave was able to get into a position so that he could screw her from behind and I began to lightly stroke and kneed her ass cheeks and then I kissed and inserted a finger into her anus. She loved this and the shaking and squealing started all over again. Ellen had multiple orgasms (again) and not long after, Dave and I had our own orgasms.
The second round of lovemaking didn't last as long as the first but it was enough to satisfy all of us. We collectively went into the shower, continued the touching, kissing and caressing while soaping one another and then dried off. We went back into the main living area, sat around in various stages of undress, recapped the night's activities and all agreed that it was a truly memorable experience.
It's been nearly a month since that night with Dave. Ellen still bumps into him occasionally and they don't reference the encounter at all so that the secret evening remains secret. We however, talk about it almost non-stop and invariably it has lead to many great conversations and lovemaking. Although we've said that we should do it again I don't think it'll happen, as we know that just like the first time we fucked we'll always remember the first time we had a threesome. First times are always the best regardless of what "cums" later.