This happened a couple of years before Nicole and I were married. We had been dating for about 3 years and had always enjoyed a great sex life. Both being very open with each other, we had discussed our fantasies freely, often trying them out in the privacy of our basement apartment.
We experimented with anal sex, which we both enjoyed and had a gel dildo we would use on Nicole to give her the sensation of having two cocks to herself and also tried some light bondage. The fantasy of having two cocks at once was a particular favorite of hers and during sex she would often ask me to slide the dildo into her pussy and fuck her with it as she was sucking my cock.
Over time this became our most common fantasy during sex and I was beginning to think more and more of watching her being fucked by another guy. I often wondered how I would feel watching a stranger sliding his cock into Nicole's pussy and fucking her on our bed. I guess she had been thinking the same, because one night just after we'd had sex, she asked me if would ever consider doing it for real. I was cautious at first, but after seeing the excitement on her face, I told her that I would be very much into trying it at least once.
I left it up to her to arrange as long as the guy she chose was clean and not too old. It was on my mind all the time, now that it might actually happen. About 2 weeks later she told me that she had set up a meeting at our place for the Friday night, but there was one small difference from the original plan. When she had made the suggestion to a guy at work, a friend of his had been listening and before she knew it, they both talked her into coming round to our place.
She told them she would check with me first, but thought I'd be into the idea. It made no real difference to me, just sounded even wilder. I couldn't stop thinking of Nicole naked on our bed with two guys kissing and touching her and then potentially both of them fucking her. Nicole loved this idea. The night came and we spent the afternoon having sex and then both getting showered and cleaned up. We shaved her pussy lips leaving a small patch of her soft brown pubic hair above her clit and shaved my balls clean of hair and trimmed the rest of my pubic hair short.
A few rules were in place such as; they could both fuck her pussy or ass (her idea) but they had to pull out if they were about to cum in her pussy (my idea) but were allowed to cum in her ass. They were not allowed to touch me, unless it was due to a certain position they were in while fucking Nicole. The door rang at exactly 7 p.m. and Nicole invited them both inside. Nicole introduced them as Ryan and Mike. They were around 25 or 26 and both white with good looking bodies and they seemed very clean. We sat and chatted for a bit over a few drinks, then there was an awkward silence.
Nicole asked them both to join her in our bedroom while she explained a few ground rules. I watched the three of them enter the bedroom and immediately felt my cock start to grow in my pants. My heart was racing, but I waited for about 10 minutes before going through. When I opened the door, the two guys were standing by the bed naked and Nicole was sitting on the bed wearing only a pair of white cotton panties.
She looked a little nervous, but I guess that was to be expected, we had never done anything like this before. I sat on a chair in the corner of the room and watched as they sat next to her on the bed. Their cocks were both hard, but not fully, and both thicker and longer than my own. They each placed a hand on Nicole's thighs and began to stroke them gently as her legs opened a little. Ryan then turned her face towards his and they started to kiss. I could see her nipples stiffen as they kissed and watched as Mike cupped one of her breasts in his hand and started sucking and licking her nipple.
By this time I was getting pretty horny, so I pulled my jeans down and held my hot, stiff cock in my hand. Nicole lay back on the bed and stretched her arms up over her head as their hands stroked her stomach, breasts and thighs, and passed teasingly over the front of her panties. I kicked my jeans off and held my cock firmly in one hand, then rolled my foreskin down slowly, revealing the fat, purple head. I then began to jerk off slowly as I gazed at Nicole and realized she was starting to relax and was getting hornier by the second.
She lay on her back and continued to kiss Ryan passionately as Mike kissed and licked her nipples, then slid his hand down over her stomach and over the front of her panties. She pushed her hips up against his hand and I was now eager to see her pussy exposed. He slipped his hand inside them and began to rub his fingers over her warm, moist mound. As she pressed her pussy up to his hand she said to me "Honey, get me out of these fucking panties" and raised her hips.
I stood up and went over to the bed and placed my hands on her thighs and slid them up until I reached her panties. She looked down at me and smiled as I hooked my fingers around them and pulled them down slowly over her thighs and right off, leaving her now totally naked on our bed with two naked men. I sat back down and watched as Mike's fingers toyed with her lips and brushed over his clit, then saw him push a finger inside her and pull it out all wet and shiny.
The moisture soon spread across her smooth lips and in seconds her entire pussy was glistening with her own sweet juices. Her legs opened wider as he stroked her and she sat up for a second and looked down at him kissing her soft belly and making his way down between her legs. She reached out and took hold of Ryan's balls as he moved closer to her on the bed. She caressed his smooth shaven balls and ran her fingers up and down the underside of his shaft, barely touching the thick head as she reached the end. He moved closer still to her face as he knelt beside her and she then brought her mouth up to meet his swollen cock.
My own cock stiffened as her tongue came out and licked around his bulbous tip, leaving saliva hanging from the underside, then she pushed her lips over the entire head almost filling her mouth. She sucked up and down a few times and moved her tightly clenched fist up and down his shaft as he let out a deep sigh. She then put her head back down on the bed and rubbed the full length his cock across her wet lips, kissing his balls as they brushed the side of her face and then turning her head to the side as she reached the head to take it into her mouth.
I could see the saliva build up on the side of her mouth as his shaft slid across and then trickle down onto her neck. It was early in the evening and we had barely started, but I was keen to cum right now and sensed that the other two might be as well. I mean we had all night, so why not! I had also been watching her pussy lips swell with the attention down there and Mike had began to kiss her clit and lick the sides of her pussy, dipping his tongue into her a few times.