Amy and I have dabbled in the swinger lifestyle for several years now. We have enjoyed making new friends with the same outlook on life, but most of all, we appreciate how much closer it has brought us in your relationship. Plus, it has allowed us to explore our sexual fantasies openly together. Amy and I both enjoy reading about other people's sexual fantasies and experiences here on Literotica. Several stories on here have been the impetus to exploring some fun scenarios, one in particular that led to an eye-opening dinner party. Our closest friends become friends with benefits, but that is a different story.
The events of this story took place on a weekend night. Amy and I met up with Keith and Amanda for dinner in the city; Amanda is one of Amy's long time college friends. They are long time vanilla friends. Dinner was terrific, and the conversation had all four of us laughing throughout the night. Occasionally conversation turned to sex and sexual fantasies. Amy, as usual pushing the conversation in that direction with some very pointed questions of Amanda's likes and dislike in the bedroom.
While I enjoyed the time we have spent with Amanda and Keith over the years, I have always found it odd that Amy and Amanda became friends in the first place or remained friends over the years. Amanda is the exact opposite of Amy, very quiet and shy. Sometimes, at dinner parties, I almost forget she is there; she is so unassuming. Amanda is attractive in a plain Jane sort of way. I have asked Amy in the past how she and Amanda have remained friends. Amy said she doesn't know why, just that she does enjoy her time together with Amanda, plus, it doesn't hurt that Keith is so attractive.
Which my response is always, "really?" Keith is a nice enough guy, but I would never put him in the handsome category, but then what do I know. When I ask Amy if she is attracted to certain men, I think she would be attracted too, almost every time she says, "not in the least."
Anyway, Amy kept asking leading sexual questions during the dinner every chance she got, "Have you ever?" or "would you ever" type of questions. Amy directed the questions mostly to Amanda, trying to see if Amanda had a wild side pent up in her very stoic demeanor.
I knew why Amy was steering the conversation in this direction. The night before, Amy and I read a story about Adult book stores and the glory hole rooms in the back of the stores. In the usual scenario, the husband takes his shy inexperienced wife into an adult book store, and next thing you know, she is banging endless mystery cock's sticking through the wall.
I should have known Amy would find a way to bring that up during dinner. As she explained the story to Keith and Amanda, she kept pausing, hoping for a reaction out of them. But neither one did much more than smile.
Amanda, saying, "Oh my, that's crazy."
Amy turned to Keith and asked him directly if he had ever been in an adult book store and ventured into the back rooms.
Keith said, "Well, I have been to an adult book store or two in my life, but never seen any that have booths in the back."
Amanda perked up upon hearing that from Keith and asked, "When was this mister?"
Keith stuttering said, "um, well, remember your birthday present?"
Amanda blushed and said, "oh, never mind."
Amy wasn't about to let that go unchallenged.
"So, what was this birthday present? It sounds fascinating. Amanda, you are such a lovely shade of red right now." Amy said, giggling.
"Oh, it was nothing, really!" Amanda responded.
"Come on, girlfriend, spill it. What kind of toy is it, and do you like it? I may need to get one if you give it a good review. Five screaming orgasms rates Amanda." Amy said.
Amanda was very embarrassed now, and she wasn't taking Amy's teasing very well.
Amy picked up on Amanda's discomfort with the current topic and quickly changed the subject.
Amy said she needed to go to the bathroom. As she got up to go, Amanda jumped up with her saying she needed to use the facilities as well.
The girls left for the bathroom, and I quickly apologized to Keith and told him I hope Amy didn't embarrass Amanda or you with her questions.
Keith said, "it was OK. Amanda is timid and private, as I am sure you have noticed. I am sure I am going to get a talking to about bringing up that birthday present."
I said, "well, I hope Amanda isn't upset. We enjoy hanging out with you two. We need to do this kind of thing more often. We don't take advantage of living so close to the city enough."
Keith said, "agreed."
I was dying to ask Keith what kind of toy he did buy Amanda for that birthday. But figured best to let it go, for now, I did file it away, for now, thinking next time with a little more alcohol, it might be a good time to ask.
The girls were in the restroom for much longer than I expected. Keith and I passed the time by ordering another drink and debating whether the national league should have the designated batter rule. He had clearly lost his mind by advocating for the designated hitter.
The ladies returned to find Keith and me in a heated debate.
Amy said, "Hello, boys, we are back."
Amy and Amanda were standing at the table with their arms around each other's hips. I had never seen these two so touchy-feely with each other. I was looking forward to asking Amy just what went on in the bathroom between the two of them.
I noticed Amanda was still slightly flushed, and I figured Amy must have embarrassed her some more in the bathroom.
"All is well, ladies?" I asked.
Amanda said, "Couldn't be better, but it is late, Keith; we have an early day tomorrow if we are going to head to the lake. We should call it a night."
I looked at Amy, wondering if Amanda was upset; Amy just gave me a wink, which I knew meant she had something to tell me when we were alone.
We said our goodbyes, and Amanda surprised me by kissing me on the lips as we hugged. That was the first time that had ever happened.
We parked a few blocks away, and Amy and I started walking back to the car.
"So, just what happened in the bathroom? Amanda was still blushing when you got back to the table and full of giggles." I asked as we walked.
Amy said, "None of your business; it is between Amanda and me."
"Oh, come on, that's just mean," I said.
Laughing, Amy said, "Well, it seems Ms. shy and demure Amanda has some pretty wild fantasies."
"OH? Do tell. Anything we could help with?" I asked.
"You dirty bastard, yes we could IF I was at all attracted her that way," Amy said.
That caught me off guard. Amanda isn't the most beautiful woman, but she isn't ugly. I find myself attracted to her physically. She has a beautiful smile and captivating blue eyes. A woman's eyes are my main weakness; her long legs and round butt don't hurt either. I was kind of shocked that Amy had no sexual attraction to her, but then Amy has been very clear about her preferences when it comes to female sex partners. Petite brunettes with big tits and curves.
"How about Keith," I asked. "Are you attracted to him sexually?"
Amy didn't pause, "hell yeah, he is hot."