My wife and I met when we were 25 and 29 respectively. We were, and continue to be, a shy and relatively reserved as people. Our first date went off extremely well and I was absolutely enamored with her appearance. The thing I remember the most was her eyes - piercing blue that felt like they saw through you. The date went so well that we ended up making out in the back of my car until the early hours of the morning.
Her body was, and continues to be, amazing. Her D-Cup tits are accentuated by wide hips and a narrow waist. Her ass is firm, curvy, and wonderful. She keeps her pussy clean shaven and always looks put together even when she puts almost no effort into her appearance.
As our relationship progressed, she moved in with me quickly. We had passionate, but not wild in any imaginable way, sex. I don't think that either of us really craved more in the bedroom at the time, but one night with a few drinks and a little chatting resulted in us taking a sex quiz. This particular quiz had each participant take it separately and would only show things that we agreed on. The choices were, "No," "If My Partner is Interested," and "Yes!" When you completed the quiz, you sent it to your partner for them to take their half.
We both seemed a bit apprehensive about it at first. We were only a few months into our relationship and we both agreed that it's important we be honest and we do not judge one another. Thankfully, we were both pretty open minded in that department albeit inexperienced. My biggest kinks for as long as I could remember was group sex, cum covered fucking, and voyeurism. I think that this is rooted in old porn I had consumed as a younger man.
I sat down and took the quiz first. I filled out my name as Joseph and hers as Anne. My heart was pumping as I answered each question of the quiz and inched closer to my personal kinks. I stared at the questions when they came and debated lying, but decided that I should tell the truth... If there was a time that I was going to find out that my kinks could come true, I thought now was the best time.
I completed my portion and sent her the link to complete her portion. I sat and waited thinking it was silly of me to worry about it - after all she's probably not into the same things that I am and she won't know my secret urges. I watched her pause and flush occasionally while reading and taking her quiz. After what felt like an eternity, she turned to me with a big smile. She took a deep breath and said, "Okay. I'm all done."
The results set off notifications on both of our phones. She curled into a ball against my chest as we read through together. I'm sure both of our hearts were pounding. As we're slowly skimming through our results, I discovered a few things that surprised me along the way but I was eagerly waiting the voyeurism and group play section. When it got there, I had butterflies in my stomach.
The first that popped up was, "Show pictures of Anne on the internet." Both responses were, "Yes!" I was visibly aroused at this point and her hand had navigated towards my crotch. Rubbing almost absent mindedly while we find out each other's hidden desires. My thumb continued to scroll. "Be watched be a male, female, or another couple during sex?" Both responses were, "Yes!" again. My mouth was dry and I squeeze her tighter to me. "Really?", I asked.
"Yes," she said bashfully. "I think it's hot to know that I can get someone excited. I'm surprised that you're into that."
"I like the idea of showing you off," I said. "I think a body like yours should be seen."
Almost nervously, I continued to scroll. I expected that to be the end of it... but it was not. Surprise after surprise we continued to scroll and read in silence.
Have a threesome with Anne and another woman? Yes.
Have a threesome with Anne and another man? Yes.
Watch Anne have sex with another person? Yes.
We sat in silence for a few minutes until suddenly turned her eyes from her phone and to mine and locked her lips onto mine. She threw her leg over me and began to grind against me, kissing me with fervor I haven't seen before. Our clothes came off and resulted in the steamiest sex we've ever had complete with dirty talk about our results. It was the best sex we have had to that point in our time together.
In her post sex splendor, bare breasted and out of breath, she turned to look at me and asked a simple question, "Fantasy or reality?"
We spoke on it for a while and decided that if we want any of this to be a reality, it would have to be right and we would have to establish some boundaries. We agreed that for the first time we would try to find a solo female or male that fits the mold for us and that either person could call it off at any time. Being shy caused a huge issue for the both of us - neither knew how to approach this.
After looking on and off for a few months, we nearly gave up. We utilized several different apps and message boards until finally we made a Fetlife account and found a few potential people to join us in the bedroom. We landed on a single guy and we spoke more about it. I was unsure how I would do with jealousy, so we agreed that it would only be a blowjob unless both of us agree to more in the moment.
We travelled to a semi-local hotel and met him at the bar. Aaron was somewhat quiet but we all noticed that there was some serious sexual tension in there air. We all knew what we were there for and yet we all were afraid to acknowledge it.
We made small talk, shared an appetizer platter, and had a few drinks to lower inhibitions. At one point, she leaned over into my ear and told me that she was incredibly nervous and didn't know if she could go through with it. I was almost relieved.
About an hour into our meeting, the topic of sex finally came to the surface. He looked at me and said, "I think it's really cool that you guys are willing to share in one another's fantasies. I think it would be hard to discuss and talk about."
