Risy Games Have Consequences!

Attention Reader! This is the fourth installment of a longer story arc. If, by chance, you are not caught up, here is the series: https://www.literotica.com/series/se/risky-games

The following story includes a very brief recap woven in to the first few paragraphs, just to make sure the most pertinent bits of the previous installments are fresh in the reader's mind.

Note: All (extrauterine) characters are at least 18 years old. This story involves risky, unprotected, dubiously consensual sex, including dubiously consensual insemination, as well as themes of blackmail, deception/betrayal/revenge and secretly filming sex acts (great material for fantasy, but not recommended in the real world). The following story is purely fictional. Any similarity to real people, places, or events is unintended coincidence.

* * *

Gary smiled nervously at Erin as she began pulling up the videos that she had recorded earlier that morning.

First up: the recording captured by Camera 1, the top-down view from his ceiling fan.

From this vantage point they could clearly see Gary stripping June down and pushing her backwards onto the bed. His muscles rippled and sweat glistened on both of them as his stocky-but-fit middle-aged frame loomed over the petite, bisexual 18-year-old, who Erin and he had conspired to seduce.

"Wow, this turned out better than I could have imagined!" Erin remarked while the half-Korean-half-white track star placed her feet on the edge of the bed and spread her knees apart, opening up her completely shaved pussy, which was nearly perfectly centered in the middle of the camera's view.

Together, they watched as the Gary on screen crawled up between June's legs and began lapping at the insides of her thighs.

"You never do that do me anymore," Erin whined slightly.

"I thought you were more into the naughty games than the sweet foreplay... but I can bring that back." Gary responded without peeling his eyes from the screen.

Erin rolled her eyes at Gary as they could hear his recorded voice showering compliments on June, "You're delicious!" lick "Fast," lick, lick "beautiful" lick "obviously smart," lick, lick "and apparently, delicious to boot!"

Then, Erin flashed Gary an evil smile as the Gary on the screen winced and complained about dislocating his jaw while eating June's pussy. "Nice touch. I wondered how you were planning on convincing her to let you out of the 'oral only' promise."

She continued watching with a big smirk as June flipped over into doggy position, and stuck her ass out so Gary could plunge his thumb into her plum.

From this angle, they could see June's little butthole winking right up at the camera. It tensed and relaxed as Gary worked his magic on her G-spot and clit with his large hand. They could clearly see the liquid that leaked out of her pleasured pussy and ran down his wrist.

When Gary finally stood up to align his cock with June's pussy, Erin paused the video. She scanned forward quickly and said, "Aww man, this angle sucks for doggy. All I see is her bony back, your shoulders, and the bald spot on top of your head. Sorry, not sorry!"

She switched to Camera 2, which captured the side-on view from his dresser. And after a minute of messing with it, found the same moment.

"That's more like it!" Erin exclaimed as the side-on view exposed so many exquisite details. They could see (in profile) the faces June was making as Gary pushed his long cock into her unprotected, and very wet cunt. They could see her little tits hanging down and jiggling as June began rocking back and forth, subconsciously fucking the cock buried inside her.

"The lighting isn't great, but hey, it's about as good as I could do without actual stage lights.... and that probably would have tipped her off about the cameras."

"Hey, I'm not exactly happy you recorded me fucking her with out telling me either." Gary complained.

"You want to stop watching?" Erin asked flatly.

"...no." Gary admitted.

Erin started stroking Gary's erection as they watched for the final moments of June's most recent insemination.

They listed as the recording of Gary's announcement blared out of the little computer speakers, "I'm gonna blow!"

Erin snickered as June groaned back, "Aww... Fuck!" then they watched as she grabbed the sheets and moaned, "Unh... Fill me up!"

They looked on as Gary grabbed her hips and pulled her all the way back, ramming his long cock deep into her tiny body.

"What the fuck is

this

?" shouted Erin from off screen.

Erin paused the video just as June's face blanched with terror at being caught.

"Haha, oh that's perfect!" Erin laughed maliciously at the still image of the shocked teen. "Ok. Your debts, hers and yours, have been repaid. I'll let her know I forgive her for fucking you behind my back after she's had a little while to stew."

She continued playing the video just long enough to show the enormous glob of Gary's semen slide out of June's twat as she tried to cover herself from the screaming Erin.

"What's that, the third time this month you've cum inside her?"

"Yeah..." Gary responded, absentmindedly caressing Erin's enormously pregnant belly.

"Heh heh... Come here and gimme whatever you've got left in you..."

* * *

Meanwhile, about a mile away, Casey slid open the shower door, turned off the water, and stood there triumphantly holding her adoptive sister's defiled panties. "Ok, spill it, slut! I want to know. Whose jizz is this? Did he cum

in

you?"

June didn't know what to say. There was no way out of this. At first she was just shocked at the intrusion of her privacy, but as soon as she saw the look on Casey's face, she forgot about the fact that she was completely naked, and focused on the possible consequences of Casey's discovery.

"You can't tell on me!" she begged her adopted sister futilely.

"Why not?" Casey asked with a malevolent smile.

"We can work something out... please! Dad would

kill

me!"

"I know. It's gonna be awesome! Do we have any popcorn?"

"Just.... wait! I can give you whatever you want." June clasped her fingers together as she pleaded.

Casey shot that down with derision, "Psht! What I

want

is to absolutely

humiliate

you by exposing what a fucking whore you are to Mom and Dad."

"Please, you can't! I'll do anything!"

Casey looked at her sister with condescension. It was something she couldn't often do, so she basked in it for a while.

June's parents had adopted Casey when both girls were four years old. At first, June had been so excited to have a new 'twin sister', but the chaos that Casey brought soon dominated their household and June resented her for it ever since.

Casey was a troubled kid, and June was the angel, so Casey resented June right back. Now that she had June under her thumb, she would enjoy it as much and as long as she could. She smiled smugly as she allowed June to continue begging

"Just wait, please! Listen, if you tell now or if you tell later, you get the same result. As long as you keep this a secret, you can hold it over me. Once you've snitched, that's gone! Just give me enough time to come up with an offer. Or you can think of something.... Please!"

"Hmmm...." Casey said slowly, obviously enjoying this. "You make a strong case... maybe you

are

the smart one." she glanced down at the semen-soaked panties in her hand and smirked again and teased, "...mmmmaybe not..."

* * *

Gary returned to his house that evening after a late dinner, and saw that there was somebody smoking on his front porch. All he could see was the telltale glow of a lit cigarette. The face behind it was illuminated by the orange light, but not well enough to see who it was. "No one I recognize! I don't think..." Gary thought, suddenly nervous at the idea of an unknown person waiting for him at his house...

He had already parked in his driveway before noticing the trespasser. "Well, they know I'm here..." Gary thought to himself, "May as well go ahead and see what this is about."

He cautiously slid out of his car and approached the house.

"Took you long enough!" a young woman's voice called out menacingly. Then the burning end of the cig flared as she took a drag. The stranger then flicked the burning butt haphazardly into one of Gary's flower beds before demanding, "So you gonna let me in to some air conditioning, or what? It's fuckin' sticky out here!"

Gary peered into the darkness.

"Sorry. Do I know you?" He asked tentatively.

"Not yet. But, apparently you know my sister

quite well!

"

Gary's mind raced. Who was this? He was now close enough, with his eyes adjusted to the dark, to make out that she was a short, somewhat plump, young woman with long blondish hair--it was hard to tell exactly in this light. "Surely not related to June or Erin or Katie... right?" he wondered nervously.

"Who?" he managed to croak.

"I'll give you a hint: she's half your age and you took advantage of her and treated her like your own personal cum dump."

Well, that could be either June or Erin...

"Uhhh..." Gary said stalling for time before deciding to deny or acknowledge any familiarity with such things, "

What?!?

Surely you must be mistaking me for somebody else. I have no idea what you're talking about!"

"Aren't you Gary Marsh? Who lives at

this

house, on Sawmill Road? You know... with the gardens?"

"Fuck!" He thought.

"Let me in, so we can talk about June."

So this was about June.

Gary sighed heavily and unlocked his front door. Once he pushed it open, he held it for her and motioned that she should go in first.

Once they were both inside, he shut the door quickly and asked, "Ok, what do you think you know? And what do you want?"

He observed her closely as he interrogated her. She was maybe a little taller than June, but very curvy, verging on plump. Her eyes were green, her hair, strawberry blond, and her complexion, slightly pinkish, and mottled with lots of little freckles. Gary was certain she couldn't actually be June's biological sister, seeing as June's dad is Korean. Gary wondered to himself, "Maybe she's a half sister or step sister? Or adopted?"

"I know I know everything. June told me

all

about what you and your perverted girlfriend did to her. And, personally, I don't care that you hurt her." She paused for dramatic effect, before continuing solemnly, "I care that you hurt her more than I ever could."

Gary shifted uncomfortably as she went on, "Lucky for you, I'm an opportunistic bitch!"

Gary perked up slightly. This bitch was also kinda cute, but in a different way from any of his recent lovers. Gary usually preferred more athletic types, like Katie or June. And Erin's thin form had been sprite-like before being transformed so much by her pregnancy. Something about this short, curvaceous, jiggly young woman made him want to squeeze her soft, warm body close to his. Made him want to invade her soft hole with his hard cock.

Her faded cutoff denim shorts hardly covered her round ass, and her huge tits swayed and jiggled tantalizingly underneath the many layers of tank top she had attempted to squeeze them into. Gary's cock stirred a little bit as he listened to her.

"Our parents do not yet know what I know. June is afraid of them finding out, and has assured me that you would willingly meet any of my demands to keep your misadventures secret. You see, my dad would surely kill you if he knew what you did to June--she is his Angel..."

"Wow, that's quite a story! Do you have any proof of whatever the allegations are?"

"Just a gob of your spunk in her panties!" Casey spat out at him. "I put them in a zip-lock baggie in my freezer, and I'm sure the cops can do a DNA test if they needed to..."

Gary's mind raced silently, "Cops!?! Wait, June's 18, right? And we didn't... well, I guess what Erin and I did to her might have broken some laws..."

He replied to the intruder as calmly as possible, trying not to show how shaken he was, "Hmm, and what are 'your demands' that I would need to meet to keep this secret?"

"You're over 21, and you have plenty of money, right?"

"I am well over 21, and I guess it depends what you mean by plenty of money..."

Gary thought silently, not wishing to share, "I am a single guy with a six-figure income, but also a mortgage..."

"But, like... you could buy me a shit ton of booze, and weed, and vapes, and cigarettes?"

"If I got you all that, what keeps you from asking for more and more?"

"Hehe, nothing, I guess! You sure catch on quick!"

Gary thought to himself and made a gamble, "June wouldn't be into any of that stuff. You called her 'Daddy's Angel', so you must be the 'bad one.' Huh, funny." he continued, smiling at the angry brat before him in her skimpy, rebellious 'bad girl' getup. "I bet what got you maddest is that she got laid, and you didn't!"

"Are you calling me a virgin?"

"Are you?"

"No." Casey responded indignantly. But Gary could clearly see he had hit a nerve.

"But you can't just have mind-blowing sex over, and over, whenever you want it, like June does, can you?"

After a moment of stunned silence, he continued, "No, I guess not. That's gotta sting, no?"

"At least I didn't have to scoop your creepy old geezer cum out of my twat in the shower this morning... yuck!"

"She still keeps coming back for more. Her orgasms were really something, I could tell!" Gary bragged defensively. "And she was the one who asked me to cum in her... just ask her!"

"That whore!" Casey muttered.

Sensing an opportunity, Gary continued, "Oh, you didn't know that? Well, I even have video of her asking me to do it."

"Wait. You

recorded

June getting fucked?!?"

Gary immediately regretted revealing that detail, but decided he had to keep playing this hand through... it could still work out.

"Yeah..." he said wistfully. "I've got it all. From multiple angles. She cums so hard. She asks me to fill her up. I do. It's

really

hot."

Gary could see Casey was getting flushed.

Casey challenged his claim the best way she knew how, "Bullshit!"

Gary smiled at her, then sighed for dramatic effect and asked, "Do you want to see it?"

Casey's eyes narrowed as she tried to scan his face. She couldn't get a read on him, but she knew she had gotten him flustered at the mention of the cops, so she figured that would be the angle to play again.

"I bet the cops would

love

to see that video."

"Tsk, tsk little girl!" Gary chided her and continued his bluff, "If you threaten me, you get nothing. The cops won't give a shit because nothing criminal has happened. Hah! They hardly care about

actual

cases of rape or sexual abuse. Of course, I wouldn't

want

to show them if I didn't need to, but it would prove that it was all consensual."

"Ok, fine. Show me if you're so confident!"

"Are you 18? I don't think I can show explicit videos to a minor. You did just ask me to buy you cigarettes..."

"I'm 18."

"Funny, so's June, but you don't look like twins."

"Yeah, I don't anything look like that perfect little porn star supermodel bitch do I?...of course I'm fucking adopted, you idiot!"

Gary silently noted this was sensitive topic for her, and decided it might be useful.

"Show me the tape, asshole!"

"Let me get it set up for you, it'll take a minute. Feel free to help yourself to a beer in the fridge,"

Casey wondered to herself, "What happened to are you even 18? Now he's offering me beer?" but she was happy to have a drink. There was never any alcohol at home, and she didn't have many opportunities to get it.

As Casey rummaged in his fridge, Gary went to his bedroom and texted Erin quickly:

> > Junes sister is in my house asking questions < <

> > Come help! < <

Then he grabbed his laptop and opened the video with the top-down view, and skipped ahead to when it clearly showed June's whole naked body as Gary ate her out on the bed. They could even make out her scrunched up facial expressions, as she felt his incredible oral skills.

Gary had already

lived

the experience that morning, and had also watched the video multiple times throughout the dat. But he really wanted Casey to see that bit, so he paused the video there and walked out with the laptop to show Casey.

She had chugged about two thirds of the beer straight off, and had begin to sip it more slowly when he returned.

Gary set the laptop up on the table and opened the screen to reveal the fully nude June, spreadeagled on his bed, and making a pleasured face as Gary's mouth serviced her.

"Oh, haha, not that part!" he said with mock embarrassment, as he watched Casey for her reaction. He was not disappointed.

Casey's eyes widened and her already rosy face flushed completely as she opened her mouth to gasp quietly.

Then he skipped to the moment that June asked him to fill her up. He had already committed the timestamp to memory, so he knew exactly where to skip ahead to.

Neither face was showing, but June's voice clearly rang out between wet, vigorous thrusting sounds, "Fuck! Unh... Fill me up!"

Gary paused the video immediately after those words were uttered. And he looked expectantly at Casey. "See? Your sister's a happy cum slut."

"I want that video." Casey demanded before finishing the rest of her beer in a single large gulp.

"You'll never get it. You're gonna have to fuck me to even see the rest of it."

"What?!?"

She asked, shocked. Then she belched loudly.

Gary suppressed a smile at the belch, thinking, "Gosh she drank that beer fast... let's see how far I can take this!"

"You heard me,

Bad Girl

You want it, first take it." Gary gestured rudely at the bulge in his pants. He hoped he wasn't overplaying his hand, but he was actually really enjoying this game now. "Come into

my

house and try to blackmail me, bitch?" He thought silently to himself.

"No! No, no, no... I don't think you've been paying attention." Casey shouted angrily. "Give me a copy of the video, or I tell our dad. He'll fuck you up."

"I don't think you would do that if you think you can still work me for booze and weed... now, I'm willing to buy your silence for a stipend of goodies, but that tape is a completely separate deal."

It was a competition of wills. And she was a slightly tipsy and very emotional 18-year-old, going up against a sober and conniving 38-year-old.

"I've never been to a dispensary before," Gary said, wrestling the conversation away from the tape. "But I know more than a little bit about weed. As a show of good faith, I'll get you an ounce of some good bud tomorrow, and a flask of your pick of liquor to get you started. You let me know when you've worked your way through that."

"Sure, whatever. Now about that vid."

"Wait, one deal at a time." Gary said, asserting his dominance, "You agree to keep June's secret, and as long as it is kept, I can supply you with alcohol, weed and cigarettes or vapes, within reason. Deal?"

"What's within reason?"

"Like, I can supply your personal habits, but not your friends."

"Sure."

"Deal?"

"Yes, it's a fucking deal! Now give me that video!"

"You heard my offer. If you want to even

watch

the rest of it, you gotta fuck me."

Gary had already cum twice that day, once in June, and once in Erin... but this short, curvy, little skank had gotten him hard again, and he wanted to fill her up too.

"No way. I ain't on birth control, and I know your style." Casey rejected his proposal, but didn't sound that forceful.

"Ok, ok. Fair enough, how about, this? If you wanna watch it, you gotta strip down. Completely naked." Gary desperately wanted to know what she looked like without her clothes.

"What?" Casey asked, somewhat shocked.