Josh had the same close friends the majority of his life. From grade school on, he'd never been one to make "many" friends, but he was seemingly perfect at making "lifelong" friends. Now in his early 20's, Josh was enjoying one of his last summers lounging about his hometown, hanging with his childhood friends every day, and just making the most of life before he graduated and hit the endless grind.
Today had been an exceptionally epic celebration; as Josh and his friends Ryan, Nate, and Neil were finishing up a day that had been filled with Josh's favorites: tennis, golf, and videogames. Having been going hard on the last of the three for over 5 hours, the proverbial flame finally died down, and Josh's friends took their leave. Shortly after, at nearly 2AM, Josh's doorbell rang. Josh ran and opened the door, thinking maybe one of his friends had forgotten their phone or keys.
Upon opening the door, he was surprised to see not his friends, but rather their 3 younger sisters: Ellie, Ashley, and Kate (18, 20, and 21 respectively). These three had become good friends due in no small part to the lifelong bonds their older brothers had forged in their youth. Years of seeing them hanging out had led to them reaching out to each other's siblings, and, well, the rest was history.
Josh, for his part, had fond memories of Ellie and Ashley, as each had been nice enough to him over the years while he'd been at their houses hanging with their brothers. Kate, to the contrary, had been a massive pain in the ass his entire life, seemingly out to take any chance at getting a jab in, or ratting out the boys when they missed curfew. Unfortunately, Kate's status as the oldest and most brash had made her the de facto leader of the girls, meaning Josh had had fewer and fewer positive interactions with any of them over the years.
"Hi Josh," Kate said as the door swung open. "We were out clubbing near here and wanted to make sure we stopped by to say happy birthday!"
"Hey, wasn't expecting any other visitors for the night after your brothers took off. Sorry I look like a mess. How was the club?"
At that moment Ellie hiccupped and Ashley burst out laughing.
"uh..." Kate began, "That's the thing. We're like.... A little more wasted than we thought we'd b-" Kate was cut off by Ashley's continued laughter. She had now doubled-over wheezing while Ellie dazedly looked around, an absent-minded but somehow adorable expression on her face.
Turning back to Josh, Kate continued, "Is there any chance we could crash here tonight? Even just like on the floor or something? We don't particularly want our parents to see us in this shape, and we can be gone right away in the morning."
"Sure thing guys. Your brothers would kill me if I said no," Josh chortled. "I have a guest bedroom and a couple couches you can crash on, if that works?"
"We'll take it!" Ashley proclaimed as if she'd just purchased her first home, immediately beginning to once again slip into a giggle fit.
"ooooook then. Thanks Josh" Kate said as she stepped through the doorway. Those were perhaps the first nice words she'd said to him in years.
It was weird, up to this point in his life, these three had always just been 'his friend's little sisters' in his mind. Looking at them as they walked in though, he had to admit that they'd really grown into stunning young women (not that he'd ever admit it to his friends).
Kate stood merely a couple inches shy of 6 feet tall, and had already begun making a name for herself in the collegiate volleyball circles. Her auburn hair was cut close, and her hazel eyes were beautiful, but always seemed to have a stern, or perhaps focused, gleam in them.
Ashley, the bubbliest of the three by far, was a long-haired red-head with glasses that had made her "nerdy" in her teen years, but worked absolutely brilliantly now on her lightly freckled face. Her bright green eyes reflected like polished emeralds as the light caught her glasses.
And then there was Ellie. The youngest of the three by a couple years, Kate and Ashley had become close friends before she'd really been old enough to join. Coupled with her naturally quiet demeanor, this had made Ellie the sweet and shy one; forever the "innocent little girl" of the group. All the same, her light blonde hair and piercing blue eyes were strikingly beautiful. Josh wondered how he'd never noticed before.
Chalking up these thoughts to slips of the mind due to exhaustion, Josh quickly showed the girls where their sleeping arrangements were, and then headed off to bed, quickly drifting off to sleep.
...
...
...
"pssst... pssssssssssst... pssssssssssssssst...HEY JOSH!"
Josh bolted up in bed, Kate's voice ringing in his ears. Standing around his bed were none other than Kate, Ashley, and Ellie.
"So uh, Josh, we're really sorry to wake you, but this is important. We were all chatting downstairs, and it kinda came up that all of us have sort of had a crush on you for like... years. And you've been an absolute fucking tease all that time, leading us on!"
"Bu-"
"I am NOT finished"
"I KNOW you were looking at my ass earlier, and Ashley said you two nearly kissed at a party once. Even Ellie said that she was pretty sure you'd sent some stolen glances her way."
Josh didn't know what to say, as to his knowledge not a single word of this was true. None of this had happened... at least... not intentionally.
"You've got it all wrong guys; you're like... sisters to m..." he trailed off as he began to take in more of his surroundings and realized each of the girls had only underwear covering their bottom halves. "What are you d-"
"I'm STILL not finished," Kate interrupted. We came up with a solution. We're gonna play a game. Basically, we're each gonna fuck you on your terms, and then on our terms; and at the end you have to agree to go out with one of us.
